[FNZ] Role Madness Star Wars OT - Game Thread

[EkkoLoJinx]

Vote Lynch Mango

did u look at any of my posts b4?

 

[Ratchet]

it gives more info on orca and ultra and can solve the kiku topic, and would make scum have no answer for the cop/watcher roles if they r town

Yeah that's fair. But also, Mango's role is one even you think is scum.

 

[Dr. Watson]

bye now

 

[Ultra]

I mean it's my honest opinion. I don't think he's given all that much thought to it - he thinks Fuji is Serial because of the sub out thing and his clash Day 1, and then fits that into what is claimed.

Please look closer to how he answers that question, I think he was being intentionally evasive here

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Yeah that's fair. But also, Mango's role is one even you think is scum.

im aware we can just be moving from scum to another, im suggesting the one that help us the most, idk why ppl r doing mango first

 

[SoulKiller]

I'm not picking at anything, I ask you a straightforward question and you aren't answering it in a straightforward way.

I think you know the answer to this question is "no, Serials don't usually have investigative utility". What's suspicious here is that instead of admitting this, you dance around it in a way that suggests you acknowledge the point but don't want to contend with it directly.

I'm going to ask you again, because if your answer is "Serials usually don't have invests", that undermines your entire point

In other words you have no problem measuring and comparing the likelihood of each of those claims being SK, but you are deflecting from why this is even likely to be the case to begin with.

We're close to end of day so I'm going to speed forward here - Serials do not usually have active investigations. Some headhunter type indies do.

I think you know what the average serial comes equipped with. It's mostly passive utility besides their kill, and sometimes they have something supportive to assist them with being town read.

So when you go "well I design Serials differently", differently as opposed to what? You're not answering, which is SUS

Soul keeps pointing to this dichotomy (or trichotomy, I guess) of investigative roles, but that's typically the last place you'd expect to find a Serial killer in lmao. or at the very least not the first. Would say this applies to blocking utilities as well.

I don't think he's coming equipped with a different set of assumptions either, based on how he answered that question.

Ultra, I elaborated on my thought process. See how I design serials they usually don't have investigation utility unless they need to hunt something specific. I was theorizing here.

Like I am gonna be real here with you Ultra, I don't really dwell or talk much when it comes to mechanics nor it's my forte. I have not played alot of games lately ultra and each game I play host do their own version of shit. So when you come here and tell me do Serials have investigations abilities, it's possible I was theorizing, but my read on the slot does not stem from that. I think it's nonsense that we have 3 investigative roles but all of them is townie in this list. Plus, watson watch on mango failed, why did it fail? who blocked her? if you watched the role blocker and he visited no one? this tells me that she must be capping and the entire watcher claim is buggos.

I was discussing and theorizing with you based on the question you asked initially.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

doesnt these ppl popping last second to vote mango make it any suspicious here. mango is at L-1 rn i believe

 

[Ratchet]

Please look closer to how he answers that question, I think he was being intentionally evasive here

Eh I mean it's not like he needs much of an argument to justify a serial suspicion.

 

[Ultra]

Ultra, I elaborated on my thought process. See how I design serials they usually don't have investigation utility unless they need to hunt something specific. I was theorizing here.

Like I am gonna be real here with you Ultra, I don't really dwell or talk much when it comes to mechanics nor it's my forte. I have not played alot of games lately ultra and each game I play host do their own version of shit. So when you come here and tell me do Serials have investigations abilities, it's possible I was theorizing, but my read on the slot does not stem from that. I think it's nonsense that we have 3 investigative roles but all of them is townie in this list. Plus, watson watch on mango failed, why did it fail? who blocked her? if you watched the role blocker and he visited no one? this tells me that she must be capping and the entire watcher claim is buggos.

I was discussing and theorizing with you based on the question you asked initially.

See I'd respect this more if you weren't placing so much stock in "one of the invests has to be Serial" because that's a form of rolespec itself. Clearly you do pay mind to these details is my point.

 

[SoulKiller]

Please look closer to how he answers that question, I think he was being intentionally evasive here

No one is being evasive here. I have no idea how in blue hell do you see me being evasive. I just think you are not as familar with me as you think you are. Like I feel like if you are townie here, me and you right now do not mesh and everything I say falls on deaf ears and you view it differently. I think you are picking and choosing and deciding not reading and you think I am evasive for some weird odd reason.

 

[Ultra]

Eh I mean it's not like he needs much of an argument to justify a serial suspicion.

I'm thinking more along the lines of he doesn't want to answer that question directly because it doesn't look great for him. I think if Soul was town he'd probably own up and admit "yeah I get it looks kinda scummy lol". Feels...political, if that makes sense.

 

[SoulKiller]

doesnt these ppl popping last second to vote mango make it any suspicious here. mango is at L-1 rn i believe

RN doing same shit as with polar, if mango flips townie. Nuke RN.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

im locking soul and ultra town, mafia pls feel free to yeet one of them anytime

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

@Red Night stop being a pu55y, cop claim isnt gonna save u from my wrath

 

[SoulKiller]

See I'd respect this more if you weren't placing so much stock in "one of the invests has to be Serial" because that's a form of rolespec itself. Clearly you do pay mind to these details is my point.

Me saying that one of the invest being scum is not me saying that the scum has to have those abilities per say, it's more like it's unlikely all 3 are townie and one of them is basically cap.

 

[Ultra]

No one is being evasive here. I have no idea how in blue hell do you see me being evasive. I just think you are not as familar with me as you think you are. Like I feel like if you are townie here, me and you right now do not mesh and everything I say falls on deaf ears and you view it differently. I think you are picking and choosing and deciding not reading and you think I am evasive for some weird odd reason.

I was trying to go through your thought process step by step here but unfortunately we don't really have the time, so I'll admit it's possible I'm jumping to conclusions here. But that is what I made of your posts, and I feel it's important to get it out there because you are potentially dangerous

 

[Ratchet]

doesnt these ppl popping last second to vote mango make it any suspicious here. mango is at L-1 rn i believe

Not really. I mean how many do you think are scun really

 

[Ratchet]

Not really. I mean how many do you think are scun really

Like max one of them is scum with Reloaded. You think they just come out if the woodwork to save their scum mate like that @Emil

 

[Ratchet]

I'm thinking more along the lines of he doesn't want to answer that question directly because it doesn't look great for him. I think if Soul was town he'd probably own up and admit "yeah I get it looks kinda scummy lol". Feels...political, if that makes sense.

I don't think Soul is likely to admit to looking scummy ever regardless of his alignment.

 

[Ultra]

im locking soul and ultra town, mafia pls feel free to yeet one of them anytime