Character Discussion Strawhat Canidate: Vivi

[MagnetoEustassKidd]

While personally I prefer Boa and Bonney, there is a chance it is actually Vivi who rejoins the crew as the last female member.

If she joined she was need an ability to make herself useful. A devilfruit or ancient weapon maybe.

Ancient weapon: Vivi could have control of Uranus

Devil fruit scenario:

At the reverie, Vivi was very close with Shirahoshi the mermaid princess. She's an ancient weapon with control over the sea kings.

So what if Vivi and Shirahoshi are two sides of the same coin. Vivi would find a water devil fruit giving her control of the sea. While Shirahoshi controls the creatures of the sea.

Vivi was saved by Sabo who controls fire, Vivi would control water.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Without a devilfruit or ancient weapon it wouldn't make any sense for Vivi to join the crew and she doesn't contribute anything other than friendship and the armies of alabasta who would help the strawhats whether she joins or not anyways.

She would also be a huge anomaly for strawhat member recruiting process. She became a strawhat pre timeskip and left the crew pre timeskip. Joining 2 years later would just be weird.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Verdict: Vivi probably won't join the crew

 

[ShiShiShi]

You misspelled candidate.

 

[Marco Vipsanio Agrippa]

Yamato is more useful than Vivi

 

[Herrera95]

Vivi can't be a pirate. She couldn't before when she was a princess and can't even less now that her father is dead. Alabasta needs someone to govern them.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Vivi at best will get a snow fruit, if not then Vivi will be the only Strawhat that can't fight.

 

[MagnetoEustassKidd]

You misspelled candidate.

I guess

 

[WizardKing]

She will be very important in the end she will get captured and sanji will save her

 

[Ace]

She’s basically already a member

Pretty sure we’ll get the inverse of the end of Alabasta where Vivi is publicly stated to be a Strawhat

 

[ShiShiShi]

She will be very important in the end she will get captured and sanji will save her

He’ll save Pudding if anything.

 

[Phoenix D. King]

Miss when you were banned

 

[RoronoaZorro]

Vivi is already a SH. She got the 5.5 numbering from Oda.

 

[Rej]

Lmao not another thread... this thread finna will die and another one will pop up shortly after.

Yes imho there won't be any new strawhats, except Vivi, who already is one more or less.

Bonnie is the temporary ally who will sail with them, but won't be an official member.

 

[Cozy Sofa]

Vivi can't be a pirate. She couldn't before when she was a princess and can't even less now that her father is dead. Alabasta needs someone to govern them.

I would have said no at first but in light of your post I would say yes, Vivi might become a pirate. I do find it most likely that she becomes a revolutionary - she basically always has been one at heart - but the one thing she can't be is the Queen of Alabasta with Imu killing her dad and wanting to kill/kidnap Vivi as well.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Yamato >>

 

[Zenos7]

Vivi is already a strawhat anyway?

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Strawhat Canidate: Vivi

Is this a hint????
Vivi eats the dog fruit? Yamato dies???😱😱

 

[Herrera95]

I would have said no at first but in light of your post I would say yes, Vivi might become a pirate. I do find it most likely that she becomes a revolutionary - she basically always has been one at heart - but the one thing she can't be is the Queen of Alabasta with Imu killing her dad and wanting to kill/kidnap Vivi as well.

Vivi whole introduction was to avoid a revolution in her country. Yet you come here to say she is a Revolutionary.

You simply don't think about people of Alabasta. Everone received the message about Cobra being killed and Vivi being kidnapped/disappearing. What you think this cause to a country? Someone has to take charge. Vivi needs to go back as soon as possible to calm her people and lead them.

About WG... She can reinforce her patrol around the island. Use a sosia... There are multiple things to avoid being killed. Letting her country ungovern isn't a choice she would make.

 

[Cozy Sofa]

Vivi whole introduction was to avoid a revolution in her country. Yet you come here to say she is a Revolutionary.

You simply don't think about people of Alabasta. Everone received the message about Cobra being killed and Vivi being kidnapped/disappearing. What you think this cause to a country? Someone has to take charge. Vivi needs to go back as soon as possible to calm her people and lead them.

About WG... She can reinforce her patrol around the island. Use a sosia... There are multiple things to avoid being killed. Letting her country ungovern isn't a choice she would make.

She is a princess and a very capable regent, not least when she made Luffy understand it's sometimes better to bow his head, otherwise his friends might die. But she was also part of Kohza rebels as a kid. She stands with one leg in each fraction + she has pirating experience with the Strawhats. She might be the only character in the whole series that actually has experience from all three and understands their respective motives.

I'm not forgetting about Alabasta. But she is not safe there and she would end up putting the whole country at risk. If Crocodile and Baroque Works were more than enough to take down Pell, Chaka, Igaram, "the holy guards" (forget their names, the 4 that took a drug to gain strength) what do you think the WG could achieve if they attacked? Ryukogyu alone is enough to take the whole country down and he'll do it with pleasure. There is absolutely nothing Alabasta can do unless they use Pluton.

 

[ShiShiShi]

If she goes back to Alabasta without Luffy, she risks her country getting obliterated like Lulusia was. The WG will do anything in their power to obtain or destroy something, and they have it.

 

[Herrera95]

She is a princess and a very capable regent, not least when she made Luffy understand it's sometimes better to bow his head, otherwise his friends might die. But she was also part of Kohza rebels as a kid. She stands with one leg in each fraction + she has pirating experience with the Strawhats. She might be the only character in the whole series that actually has experience from all three and understands their respective motives.

I'm not forgetting about Alabasta. But she is not safe there and she would end up putting the whole country at risk. If Crocodile and Baroque Works were more than enough to take down Pell, Chaka, Igaram, "the holy guards" (forget their names, the 4 that took a drug to gain strength) what do you think the WG could achieve if they attacked? Ryukogyu alone is enough to take the whole country down and he'll do it with pleasure. There is absolutely nothing Alabasta can do unless they use Pluton.

Again your are forgetting that Vivi only did piracy in order to save her country. She is a princess and her country that she loves more than anything doesn't have a king anymore. She has to take her father's place.

How the hell Vivi would be safer as a pirate being hunted by marines going in battles against marines, pirates, CP-0 agents... WG won't stop hunting her because she is a pirate. Look how they are handling Shichibukais. The moment they discovered where Weevil was they sent Greenbull there.

Now the thing is. Not all countries of the World are already part of WG. WG can't do much against those countries instead of going into war with them for quite a while. Revolutionaires army is about that they are taking part of those wars and helping countries to free themselves from WG.

Also WG can't do much about territories dominated by Yonkos. Best thing Vivi can do is to call for Luffy's protection now that he is a Yonko. No one can attack Yonkos and probably their territories without higher permission. If anyone try to attack Alabasta Luffy's crew(maybe whole fleet) would run there to protect them. Way more safe than travelling those dangerous seas