Break Week Sword Association's Public Declaration

What was stronger?

  • Garp's healing panchi

  • Roger's embarassing slash


Results are only viewable after voting.

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
#61
Top of the World =/= Top of Swordsmen

How can you tell Yoru is the best in the world and not by default for Mihawk also being the World Strongest Swordsman..
Because Yoru isnt the strongest sword but the strongest weapon.
And Mihawk sits at the top of the world, not atop of the swordsmen.
Because both he and Zoro want to be stronger than everyone, not just swordsmen.
Because, and this is the most important one, logic. :steef:
 
#62
Because Yoru isnt the strongest sword but the strongest weapon.
And Mihawk sits at the top of the world, not atop of the swordsmen.
Because both he and Zoro want to be stronger than everyone, not just swordsmen.
Because, and this is the most important one, logic. :steef:
Mihawk isn't at the top of the world.. He's too much a bum for that..

And it's not known if Yoru is de facto best Blade due to Mihawk's title or because it's actually the best Blade..
 
#63
Top of the World =/= Top of Swordsmen

How can you tell Yoru is the best in the world and not by default for Mihawk also being the World Strongest Swordsman..
The manga tells us Mihawk is at the top of the world.



Mihawk isn't at the top of the world.. He's too much a bum for that..

And it's not known if Yoru is de facto best Blade due to Mihawk's title or because it's actually the best Blade..
Achieving your goal and waiting at the top for a worthy opponent makes you a bum?

:okay:


When you find another superior grade blade, let me know.
 
#64
The manga tells us Mihawk is at the top of the world.





Achieving your goal and waiting at the top for a worthy opponent makes you a bum?

:okay:


When you find another superior grade blade, let me know.
Wrong translation.. It only says '' This Strongest Seat '', which relates to his title of World Strongest Swordsman.. Mihawk is definitely not at the Top of the World..

As far as we both know Yoru is the same Grade as other Supreme Grade Blades.. We can't know if Yoru is the Strongest Blade on its own or due to Mihawk being the World Strongest Swordsman..
 
#66
Law did it with the help of his hack of a DF, while dressrosa Zoro did it casually, wano law is at best fishman Zoro lvl and can clinch a high diff win with his DF.
:josad:
Zoro was already slicing entire Pica with 1080 pound phoenix already lol.
Zoro needed something to separate Pica from ground or he is invincible and keep shifting location.

Moment law creates a room that big , even a blind person can move away lmao.
 
#67
Wrong translation.. It only says '' This Strongest Seat '', which relates to his title of World Strongest Swordsman.. Mihawk is definitely not at the Top of the World..

As far as we both know Yoru is the same Grade as other Supreme Grade Blades.. We can't know if Yoru is the Strongest Blade on its own or due to Mihawk being the World Strongest Swordsman..
Your "wrong translation" argument doesn't work here. If it doesn't say anything about swordsman you can't add it. Mihawk is saying he will wait in the seat that is for the strongest. Not, in the seat that is for the strongest swordsman. There's only one seat at the top, the strongest seat, and that's the seat he wait in for Zoro.

If black blades are supposed to unbreakable than an unbreakable sword will always be stronger than a breakable sword. Shusui an excellent grade black blade is stronger than any regular supreme grade blade.
 
Last edited:
#75
No point in putting Iron Garp there then. Nothing to feel sad about, we saw Hody with no haki bypass Luffy with haki defense. Its just to show the lethality of swordsmanship/sharp weapons in OP.
Dude this was fodder reaction to what Shyriu did, this isn't like they were reading the situation like they were experts, more like the opposite. If Shyriu was so secure he could do that do Garp anyways, he wouldn't have gone for Koby's ass
Post automatically merged:

How can he be caught off guard when coby was the one getting attacked ?
Because Garp's whole point of being there was to assume Koby would escape
 
#77
Dude this was fodder reaction to what Shyriu did, this isn't like they were reading the situation like they were experts, more like the opposite. If Shyriu was so secure he could do that do Garp anyways, he wouldn't have gone for Koby's ass
Post automatically merged:


Because Garp's whole point of being there was to assume Koby would escape
Yeah and the multiple Garp is now weakened were also only fodder reaction and the author did not want to show that Garp took a serious hit?
Shiryu fights dirty, you guys bring the most weird excuses, if Shiryu was so secure why did he dishonorably kill the jailer guards, why did Shiryu dishonorably attack Moria. If a character is equal to someone who can one shot Yami BB then there should be no problem with said character running Old Garp through a sword.
You guys put certain characters at a pedestal and then another at another level and then you lock them up in that and then have an issue when things dont happen as you expect and give weird excuses.
 
#78
Yeah and the multiple Garp is now weakened were also only fodder reaction and the author did not want to show that Garp took a serious hit?
Shiryu fights dirty, you guys bring the most weird excuses, if Shiryu was so secure why did he dishonorably kill the jailer guards, why did Shiryu dishonorably attack Moria. If a character is equal to someone who can one shot Yami BB then there should be no problem with said character running Old Garp through a sword.
You guys put certain characters at a pedestal and then another at another level and then you lock them up in that and then have an issue when things dont happen as you expect and give weird excuses.
Dude all im saying is Shyriu wouldn't do any better than Roger at the same circumstances we see in the latest chapter like some are lowkey trying to imply, he suceeded fighting dirty and not in a fair fight, which makes it not accurate to scale his feat as a raw strength feat alone, not to mention he looked like crap after a pretty casual slam from Garp. Fodders are so reliable that they thought Big Mom would be killed cuz Kid hit her with iron bars lol
 
#79
Wrong translation.. It only says '' This Strongest Seat '', which relates to his title of World Strongest Swordsman.. Mihawk is definitely not at the Top of the World..

As far as we both know Yoru is the same Grade as other Supreme Grade Blades.. We can't know if Yoru is the Strongest Blade on its own or due to Mihawk being the World Strongest Swordsman..
Well Mihawk is one of the strongest characters so he is at the top of the world in that sense
 
Top