Speculations The reason Whitebeard didn't want to go to LT is because he knew DF users can't go there

[Celestial D. Dragon]

Who gives a shit... right... Sengoku saying those things to Ace is just another tatict. Why the hell he would say that if wasn't to destroy Ace hopes to survive?

WB said he doesn't act much like Roger. Just look the fucking panel on spoiler I had on my comment. You are just embarressing yourself more and more.

Again, Whitebeard playing ignorant....

Garp literally describes to Dadan that Ace in some ways acted like Roger, and how they had a similar upbringing. You mean Garp can pinpoint the similarities between Ace and Roger, but Whitebeard fucking can't? Please....

How about you pay attention to the rest of the story, instead of taking one single panel so literal. You're embarrassing yourself more and more.

 

[Phoenix D. King]

What Island didn't make sense before?

the one that nobody has found ever... its gonna be in such a stupidly obvious place so that the casual fans can claim foreshadowing

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

LOL.
Then how Luffy is going there.

On the contrary, perhaps they would need a DF user to reset or remake whatever it is related to the sea and the DFs, so they couldn't make it even if they wanted, so perhaps no one did anything from Roger pirates even by accident when they go there.

Luffy's is kinda the ''ultimate df" so it might work

 

[Junatic]

Yes, DF Users can't go to Laugh Tale, same goes for Accessing Mary Geoise National Treasure
That's why a Fated Storm led Luffy to meet Brook & recruit him
Brook's DF is only one that can travel to Afterlife, so his Awakening can remove Restriction on DF Users when entering Laugh Tale

In other words, Laugh Tale is in Afterlife, that's why no one can find it
Soon, Lurking Legend will be Introduced & he will tease Brook's Past as a Knight
Because, just like Teach kidnapped Koby & Pudding, his Next Target gonna be Brook

This is why Brook can Split into Two without Dying (Head & Rest of Body)
Cuz Oda intends to make Luffy find Laugh Tale at same time BB access Mary Geoise National Treasure

This is also why Doffy needed Eternal Youth Operation to access that Treasure, cuz he can't normally survive there
Basically, DF Spirits are banned from Afterlife (Only Brook's DF ignores such Iron Rule)

The reason this Lurking Legend knows Brook is cuz he was present during the Incident that led to Brook becoming a Pirate
Brook witnessed the Destruction of Lunarians at the hand of Mary Geoise Knights
That's why Oda made Brook stay with Zoro, it's so that he doesn't see Seraphim & comment on Lunarians

This Lurking Legend is the same person who caused the Storm that led into Luffy meeting Brook
He basically Manipulates Storms all over the World, for example:

He summoned Whirlpool in Chapter 2
He summoned Lightning in Loguetown
He summoned Whirlpool in Jaya
He summoned Whirlpool in Wano
He summoned Storm in Florian Triangle
He summoned Storm in Edd War between Roger & Shiki
He summoned Storm that hit Bonney so that she meets Luffy
He summoned Storm that led to Nami meeting Luffy
... etc

So yes, Laugh Tale is inaccessible by DF Users & Brook is The Key
He literally is a Skull, he literally represents a Treasure Mark
Even Kaidou was pointing at him in Volume Cover
Even Roger Pirates failed to meet Brook, but Luffy was Fated to

As i'v been saying multiple times
You're not ready for Egghead Arc Ending
It will completely change your view on every single Arc & Past Foreshadowing

Regardless of whether it's true, it takes a lot of time and thoughtfulness to come up with such a well-developed theory. Props to you!

 

[Salah WG]

Cool ideas.

Regardless of whether it's true, it takes a lot of time and thoughtfulness to come up with such a well-developed theory. Props to you!

Thanks
If Egghead ends like i predict, i will share the entire Analysis/Theory

 

[Herrera95]

Again, Whitebeard playing ignorant....

Garp literally describes to Dadan that Ace in some ways acted like Roger, and how they had a similar upbringing. You mean Garp can pinpoint the similarities between Ace and Roger, but Whitebeard fucking can't? Please....

How about you pay attention to the rest of the story, instead of taking one single panel so literal. You're embarrassing yourself more and more.

So Sengoku talking about WB is true but WB talking about himself is false. You are hopeless. Nothing gives the impression he is playing like a fool/ignorant like you say.

WB is the top pirate. He doesn't have any reason to lie to anyone.

Again WB was never after Ace. Ace wad after WB.