Character Discussion The reason why Bonnie is

[S.W317]

Not Luffy’s apprentice but rather She is the same generation as Luffy, she’s 12 and he’s 19 meaning if he was 30 she’d be 23, they were born in the same decade.

Roger and WB ages are 7 years apart similar to Luffy and Bonnie but WB wasn’t Roger’s apprentice lol

Bonnie is not a kid compared to Luffy, same gen, if anything she’s his contemporary similar to Law, Kidd and BB

I’m not saying she can’t join the crew, she probably will join but her role won’t be apprentice lol, she’s like Zoro who’s also one of luffy’s contemporaries as a supernova but he’s still a part of the crew, it’ll be as if law joined kinda deal

 

[Foul Legacy]

No lol.
They all adults in the crew.
Roger crew never even started sailing when they were 17/19.
Shanks did and uta was there and so was luffy (if he ever joined Shanks he would do as apprentice not as a member at that age).

SH just got success before handedly.

 

[S.W317]

No lol.
They all adults in the crew.
Roger crew never even started sailing when they were 17/19.
Shanks did and uta was there and so was luffy (if he ever joined Shanks he would do as apprentice not as a member at that age).

SH just got success before handedly.

I’m comparing Bonnie to Luffy here, compared to him she is not a child, mentally she’s as mature as the rest of them and isn’t far off age wise, so she’s joining as a member not an apprentice

 

[Foul Legacy]

I’m comparing Bonnie to Luffy here, compared to him she is not a child, mentally she’s as mature as the rest of them and isn’t far off age wise, so she’s joining as a member not an apprentice

Mentally she isn't mature at all. We are shown to be that way.
The fact her imagination still running wild is evident how much immature she is.

 

[S.W317]

Mentally she isn't mature at all. We are shown to be that way.
The fact her imagination still running wild is evident how much immature she is.

Man stfu, don’t argue with me it’s annoying, I don’t care about what you say, you’re stubborn and I hate stubborn people.

I told you she’s not joining as an apprentice but joining as a member, full stop

 

[Foul Legacy]

Man stfu, don’t argue with me it’s annoying

So,
People debunking is not your thing.
Man up to even accept you're wrong lmao

 

[S.W317]

So,
People debunking is not your thing.
Man up to even accept you're wrong lmao

I’m not though, you’re just yapping your headcanon, and you didn’t debunk anything, you’re just being an asshole that’s it

 

[ZenZu]

I’m comparing Bonnie to Luffy here, compared to him she is not a child, mentally she’s as mature as the rest of them and isn’t far off age wise, so she’s joining as a member not an apprentice

You're correct. She has a df that ages her up in actuality not just appearance, so that includes her brain.

 

[S.W317]

So,
People debunking is not your thing.
Man up to even accept you're wrong lmao

And don’t talk back to me, I know y’all are mostly 13-16 years old, so I’m older than all yall

Post automatically merged: Jun 22, 2024

You're correct. She has a df that ages her up in actuality not just appearance, so that includes her brain.

Exactly, this guy is triggered because he thinks I’m against her joining and isn’t trying to understand what I’m saying just yapping like an idiot

 

[L57]

Garbage character

 

[Foul Legacy]

I’m not though, you’re just yapping your headcanon, and you didn’t debunk anything, you’re just being an asshole that’s it

Lmao.
Enjoy your headcanon.
I just explained why she would be seen as a kid only. Lol

And don’t talk back to me, I know y’all are mostly 13-16 years old, so I’m older than all yall

Lmao I'm older than you.
We got a buthurt old citizen here.

 

[zoro69syourmom]

bonney is 12 bro if she's joining the crew it's as a cabin girl

 

[Foul Legacy]

bonney is 12 bro if she's joining the crew it's as a cabin girl

Don't hurt his headcanon , the adult will cry.

 

[MonsterKaido]

Bonney as apprentice is fine for SH

 

[S.W317]

bonney is 12 bro if she's joining the crew it's as a cabin girl

But she won’t, why y’all have this mob mentality, this herd way of thinking where no one is allowed or dares to think otherwise and when Oda does the obvious you all act shocked afterwards

Post automatically merged: Jun 22, 2024

Bonney as apprentice is fine for SH

No it isn’t, she already accomplished a lot as a pirate, her becoming an apprentice/cabin girl is a huge setback to her and a huge disrespect to the character.

The SH aren’t a parallel to the Roger pirates, when will you understand this? Shanks started off as an apprentice but Bonney didn’t, she’s a full-fledged pirate like her peers

Post automatically merged: Jun 22, 2024

Don't hurt his headcanon , the adult will cry.

When will you understand that I’m not against Bonney joining the crew? I just don’t want her to join as a cabin girl but I don’t mind her joining.

Again I’m not against Bonney joining the crew please understand this, please I know you’re mad cause you misunderstood what said and thought I said that Bonney won’t join, but that’s not what I said; I said that Bonney will indeed join the crew

I will spell it again, Bonney will joint the straw hats after egghead but it won’t be as a cabin girl but rather as a full-fledged member like Usopp and Sanji and Nami etc…