Future Events The Straw hat crew structure and hierarchy

[S.W317]

After officially being a Yonko crew I have a feeling that the straw hats and grand fleet captains will have to sit together and think about how to manage their fleet and territories as this is essential in facing off against the other Yonko as well as the marines.

And while I’m sure Luffy himself will not be interested in it people like Jinbei, Zoro, Sanji and Robin will convince him of the idea and how important it is and that it won’t affect their overall journey or crew dynamics.

So in general the direct command will be done by the fleet captains and the crew members as the fleet executives with the fleet captains specifically having the same rank of executives, so it will be as follows;

Luffy: Fleet Admiral/Whatever title they come up with

Chief executives:
-Zoro
-Sanji
-Usopp
-Nami

Executives:
Jinbei
Yamato
Robin
Franky
Chopper
Brook
Cavendish
Bartolommeo
Sai
Ideo
Hajrudin
Leo
Orlbumbus
Aladdin

 

[Master OF Haki]

It will happen off screen so it doesn't matter, for Oda it's much better to spend time showing characters running rather than actual developments.

 

[S.W317]

It will happen off screen so it doesn't matter, for Oda it's much better to spend time showing characters running rather than actual developments.

That’s really unfortunate
[automerge]1655760484[/automerge]

It will happen off screen so it doesn't matter, for Oda it's much better to spend time showing characters running rather than actual developments.

Why is it that not many people interact with my thread, and what can I do to make them appealing?

 

[Santoryu D Bazooka]

 

[Galahad]

After officially being a Yonko crew I have a feeling that the straw hats and grand fleet captains will have to sit together and think about how to manage their fleet and territories as this is essential in facing off against the other Yonko as well as the marines.

And while I’m sure Luffy himself will not be interested in it people like Jinbei, Zoro, Sanji and Robin will convince him of the idea and how important it is and that it won’t affect their overall journey or crew dynamics.

So in general the direct command will be done by the fleet captains and the crew members as the fleet executives with the fleet captains specifically having the same rank of executives, so it will be as follows;

Luffy: Fleet Admiral/Whatever title they come up with

Chief executives:
-Zoro
-Sanji
-Usopp
-Nami

Executives:
Jinbei
Yamato
Robin
Franky
Chopper
Brook
Cavendish
Bartolommeo
Sai
Ideo
Hajrudin
Leo
Orlbumbus
Aladdin

Looks like you didn't read One Piece.

There will be no organization, neither for the fleet, nor for the territories. Everyone who is next to Luffy will be of good will, he will not need a control and Luffy will not receive anything for his protection.

The only rule that governs the Muguiwara fleet and territories is, "touch my friends and I'll kick your ass".

 

[faker]

No, the position of vice captain is not set up in more than 1000 chapters. Why should a hierarchy be set up near the end

 

[Galahad]

No, the position of vice captain is not set up in more than 1000 chapters. Why should a hierarchy be set up near the end

Nobody talked about Vice Captain here. But whether you like it or not, Zoro is the Vice Captain. That's how people outside the band consider him and that's how he acts when the situation warrants it.

 

[Master OF Haki]

Why is it that not many people interact with my thread, and what can I do to make them appealing?

You're asking the wrong guy man, some of my threads have been ignored and remain empty without a single post, unless I tag everyone on this Goddamn forum.

 

[faker]

Nobody talked about Vice Captain here. But whether you like it or not, Zoro is the Vice Captain. That's how people outside the band consider him and that's how he acts when the situation warrants it.

No, Zoro's position is still a combatant so far. The reason why Oda doesn't want to set up a vice captain may also be that he doesn't want to have a clear hierarchy

 

[Luffydom56]

Zoro is vice Captain. Barto said it himself

 

[BleakAsh]

You're asking the wrong guy man, some of my threads have been ignored and remain empty without a single post, unless I tag everyone on this Goddamn forum.

the latter is so trueeee you gotta resort to tag kun

@S.W317 depends on many things but tag me in your threads next time around

 

[Shasha23]

No, Zoro's position is still a combatant so far. The reason why Oda doesn't want to set up a vice captain may also be that he doesn't want to have a clear hierarchy

Jesus, everyone in the One Piece world calls Zoro the vice-captain, it seems it hurts your feelings when this is pointed out to you.
If you dont like Zoro being vice captain then Luffy's band of pirates are not the Strawhat Pirates since thats the name the world gave them, Luffy didnt come up with it, nor did anyone in the crew come up with the name Strawhat Pirates, so why are you butthurt by the fact Zoro is the vice captain?

 

[Galahad]

No, Zoro's position is still a combatant so far. The reason why Oda doesn't want to set up a vice captain may also be that he doesn't want to have a clear hierarchy

As you say, Oda does not want to make the hierarchy clear, for two reasons:

1. The hierarchy in the Mugiwaras is only evident in very specific situations, not only that of Zoro as Vice Captain, but even that of Luffy as captain.
2. The second reason is to have the fans debating.

But in those specific moments, Zoro is the Vice Captain. Zoro was the first member (as Rayleigh). Zoro is seen as Vice Captain by outsiders like Urogue or Bartolomeo. He even has a cover shared with other Vice Captains, even though Oda was quick to say no.

 

[S.W317]

the latter is so trueeee you gotta resort to tag kun

@S.W317 depends on many things but tag me in your threads next time around

Thanks bro I really appreciate it man
[automerge]1655761797[/automerge]

As you say, Oda does not want to make the hierarchy clear, for two reasons:

1. The hierarchy in the Mugiwaras is only evident in very specific situations, not only that of Zoro as Vice Captain, but even that of Luffy as captain.
2. The second reason is to have the fans debating.

But in those specific moments, Zoro is the Vice Captain. Zoro was the first member (as Rayleigh). Zoro is seen as Vice Captain by outsiders like Urogue or Bartolomeo. He even has a cover shared with other Vice Captains, even though Oda was quick to say no.

Oda is a coward for not admitting it
[automerge]1655761852[/automerge]
But generally I do think that the straw hats having a structure that won’t affect their dynamic is still essential

 

[Luffydom56]

Zoro is second in command when Luffy’s out, infact water 7 showed even when Luffy’s there and doesn’t have the resolve, he is there to set him straight.

 

[S.W317]

Looks like you didn't read One Piece.

There will be no organization, neither for the fleet, nor for the territories. Everyone who is next to Luffy will be of good will, he will not need a control and Luffy will not receive anything for his protection.

The only rule that governs the Muguiwara fleet and territories is, "touch my friends and I'll kick your ass".

Why do I feel like people don’t read my threads properly because I said that it’s just a thing in case they go to war with other factions where they won’t have the samurai or monks with them like this time, having a clear war-time structure is essential and IT WONT AFFECT THEIR OVERALL JOURNEY OR CREW DYNAMIC.
[automerge]1655762039[/automerge]

Zoro is second in command when Luffy’s out, infact water 7 showed even when Luffy’s there and doesn’t have the resolve, he is there to set him straight.

Zoro is definitely Luffy’s right hand man weather Oda says it clearly or not but anyone with reading comprehension and acceptance IQ can see it
[automerge]1655762150[/automerge]
People don’t realize that normally the straw hats wouldn’t have strong allies like Kidd and Law or the samurai and Minks all the time unless their interests intertwined unlike the grand fleet that are direct subordinates to the straw hats

 

[Galahad]

Oda is a coward for not admitting it

It's not that Oda is a coward. In fact, it is Oda himself who is leaving clues. It's just that 99% of the time Zoro isn't the Vice Captain and 98% of the time, Luffy isn't the Captain. You have to blame the fans who don't know how to read between the lines and they have to tell them everything and many times they don't even understand.

Why do I feel like people don’t read my threads properly because I said that it’s just a thing in case they go to war with other factions where they won’t have the samurai or monks with them like this time, having a clear war-time structure is essential and IT WONT AFFECT THEIR OVERALL JOURNEY OR CREW DYNAMIC.

As with the crew, the fleet is also not going to be ranked 99% of the time.

The closest thing will be those who plan, for example, the assault on New Marine Ford. Which I guess will be Nami, Robin and Jinbe. The rest of the Mugis and the fleet will follow the plan, except Luffy and Zoro of course. As usual.

Don't expect a defined hierarchy.

 

[faker]

As you say, Oda does not want to make the hierarchy clear, for two reasons:

1. The hierarchy in the Mugiwaras is only evident in very specific situations, not only that of Zoro as Vice Captain, but even that of Luffy as captain.
2. The second reason is to have the fans debating.

But in those specific moments, Zoro is the Vice Captain. Zoro was the first member (as Rayleigh). Zoro is seen as Vice Captain by outsiders like Urogue or Bartolomeo. He even has a cover shared with other Vice Captains, even though Oda was quick to say no.

So I said Zoro's position is still a combatant so far

Just because he is competent doesn't mean he is the vice captain. These are two concepts

 

[Finalbeta]

I wonder if Luffy will care enough to structure it properly

 

[thedarkdragon11]