Theory The true source of power in One Piece

#1
To begin: Characters can defy physics because of their hearts. Literally. It is the direct source of their personality and willpower.


Vegapunk says Kuma's ability to overcome everything is due to the power of love.


The desires of people manifest as powers.


A fist of "love" cannot be blocked.


Sanji can do Diable Jambe because... his heart burns hotter.


Zoro can speak because of his heart... defying the laws of physics.


When hearts are swapped in characters, they adopt the personality of the heart's owner, not the body—but they don't keep the powers.


When Luffy "dies" and turns into Nika, his voice goes away.

The Voice of All Things

Luffy is suddenly recognizable as Nika when he transforms. His heartbeat turns into the drums of liberation. Luffy's personality even changes when he turns into Nika, but not completely, which is very strange.


Zoan fruits have a will of their own. Luffy's heart, when Nika, has Nika's rhythm. If the Nika fruit has a will of its own, then it is taking over part of Luffy's will. So his heart beats differently because it's not exactly Luffy's heart, it's beating like Nika's.


When near death, Zoro hears drumbeat/heartbeat SFX of inanimate objects. Why does this happen?


Oda loves to hide the truth in trashposts. A character's "voice" is literally their heartbeat. For the briefest moment, Zoro could hear the "voice of all things." He can hear the "heart" of living objects.


Roger could communicate with poneglyphs, inanimate objects, with the "voice of all things." He could hear the "heartbeat" of these inanimate objects.

Devil Fruits
In essence, the "heartbeat" of something is combined with the person. This heartbeat/drumbeat is expressed only in the person's body, not their heart or mind.


Devil fruits use onomatopoeia in their naming structures, and they are "doubled" giving them the sound of a particular rhythm.



With one's heart, someone can modify their body, similar to how Sanji can make his feet burn hotter. When you eat a DF, you are effectively commanding the rhythm/beat of the power with your own heart.


Awakening is when you no longer have two different heartbeats, but instead one singular heartbeat.


The "Nomi Nomi no Mi" is actually a revealing pun: Mi doesn't just mean fruit/seed, it also means body. It's a pun that literally means "mind" (nomi) and "body" (no Mi). So this is has the double meaning of "mind mind: mind" and the nika fruit is the "nika nika mind" It's a triple meaning. Fruit, Mind, Body. So Kaido is basically saying, "your mind and body catch up to the mind and body of the fruit."

The devil fruit, basically, just modifies your body with some future science that doesn't make a lot of sense. However... Let's return to an earlier idea again:

Kuma is able to defy his own death/erasure because of the power of love. This is his heart... not dying. His heart and will are intertwined.

Devil fruits respawn... because the will/heart of a buccaneer (and also person, maybe) is incapable of dying. If the heart can LITERALLY manifest desires, then the heart is where someone's dream comes from. This leads us to two of the most important double spreads in the entire manga:


The dreams... the things that hearts manifest into reality... literally do not go away.


How can anything being imagined happen?Because the heart wills it.

So these reality manipulating desires reincarnate because "dreams never end."

The Five Elders
So if anyone can manifest their desires, how is a minority rule through the WG, Five Elders, and Imu, capable of happening? If the world is full of suffering, why have people not simply willed their way out of this horrible world and into a better one?

They have obviously erased Ohara and Lulusia.


Why are the Level 6 prisoners held captive instead of executed? Because if the world forgets they exist, and they live on, their wills cannot be passed on.
A man dies when he is forgotten.
The point of the WG going through all of this stuff is to make people forget that people have risen up against the WG before. Erasing the very concept of resistance is the only way they can actually maintain power, because if people manifest their desires... then the WG has a ghost of a chance.

We can see this in three different places:

Roger being executed because they don't want anyone to continue in his image.

Ace is being executed to symbolize the death of the pirate era.


Saturn wishes to "erase" things, including Nika and Ohara, to make sure no one believes they can resist the WG. The WG erases things (and was told to erase a name by Imu).


Bonney's power is explicitly limited the "more she knows about reality." Saturn is explicitly saying that the less you imagine, the weaker you become.

Saturn's entire purpose up until now hasn't been to win, but to crush. If he crushes people's hopes and dreams, this is the ONLY way they cannot pass on or manifest. Because people still believe in Nika, the fruit was still able to reincarnate. The buccaneers had to be erased because their belief in Nika meant that he could return, and that return is the single most likely way to cause their downfall.

The WG has a ton of strength and power, but the most important thing they must do to maintain it is utterly destroy any hope that people have in the world.

So where's this all going?
The hearts of individuals are the source of power in this world. Through their heart they can manifest desires in a very literal fashion. The "heart" of things like inanimate objects and people that once existed are exhibited through devil fruits, and often reincarnate into human beings time and time again. The WG maintains power not simply through destruction, but by limiting the very imagination of the world through the erasure of information and falsely presenting a hopelessness.

Nika's true power, one of inspiration and unlimited imagination, is the single greatest threat to the WG because Nika is the only person/thing that can make people believe the unbelievable, and finally actualize the destruction of a tyrannical world power through their own belief.

Everything ties neatly together.
 
Last edited:
#3
I see you've given this a lot of thought. I'd like to share what I have to say about the subject.

What is a voice?
- From my perspective, there is a misunderstanding in this logic. The part where you insist that the heart LITERALLY makes desires.
- I believe that you have discovered where the soul resides in a person. It is in the heart. However, you attribute voices to inanimate objects without sufficiently explaining where the "heart" of an inanimate object is located or if one even exists.
- I believe that you must consider that a voice is constituted by more than just a desire or a will. A voice can exist without a body at all (in the time between transferring vessels).
- The voice of something may be constituted by the subtle energy which comprises it.

Psychic Senses
The way that Zoro detected a voice in rocks, trees, and steel (his surroundings) is the explanation of Observation Haki from his point of view. Now, the important part is how he detected the voice - what did he do, exactly? It is my belief that he used what is known as a Clair Sense. Clair Senses are otherwise known as psychic senses, and they mirror the traditional human senses. For example, the traditional sense of touch becomes the psychic sense of touch. Why do people need to use Observation Haki to determine where a voice is coming from? It's because a voice is a form of subtle energy which is only detectable using psychic sense.

Dreams
I would also like to share my thoughts on where dreams come from. I would say that dreams are created in Heaven. In fact, I would say ALL ideas come from Heaven. They existed there from the beginning of time. People became familiar with these ideas when they were first created by God, and sent down to Earth, and each time they died and went through the process of rebirth they went back to God and became familiar with these ideas again. This leads to conversations about philosophical subjects such as Plato's realm of light/realm of ideas. It is a metaphysical dimension. It is Heaven. Take this explanation with a grain of salt.
 
#6
I think some of the points here illustrate why the World Government may not be the final villains.

The World Government wants to control the world. It's World Conquest. The Five Elders are concerned that other people also want to pursue World Conquest - luckily, for them, Shanks doesn't seem to want to do that. So, he's a bit of a wild card. When the Blackbeard Pirates were questioned about their mysterious actions by Saturn, they claimed they were pursuing, "The World". However, I think the Blackbeard Pirates, and Blackbeard himself have different ideas in mind than conquering the world and ruling over it.

It is my opinion that Blackbeard represents a greater threat than the World Government does itself. This is based on Blackbeard possibly not being content with ruling it, and instead he wants to destroy it. His ideology corresponds with his Devil Fruit. It's why it chose him. Darkness may represent nothingness, and the destruction of All Things. Even the World Government has never pursued the destruction of All Things. That is a different kind of evil.
 
#8
nice..i already post thred like tis..if some evil fruit user is submerjed half in water..he will not be weak..but when submerj fuly he become weak to water..thats becuz his heart is also submerjed..heart is sorce of electromagnetic and electric field..teh powers of evil fruit resides in heart..
 
#9
nice..i already post thred like tis..if some evil fruit user is submerjed half in water..he will not be weak..but when submerj fuly he become weak to water..thats becuz his heart is also submerjed..heart is sorce of electromagnetic and electric field..teh powers of evil fruit resides in heart..
by a mecha heart did you mean like an advanced prosthetic for a human that would keep them alive forever, or some kind of machine meant to act as the heart of a giant robot like the ruined one in elbaf
 
#10
by a mecha heart did you mean like an advanced prosthetic for a human that would keep them alive forever, or some kind of machine meant to act as the heart of a giant robot like the ruined one in elbaf
1st i tel u few consepts where oda insipired and decided one piece trézor to be mecha heart..

-1st concept of love is very important...it was forshadowed in egghead arc kuma-boney flashbaks..kuma despite him turning into robot still had emotions..joyboy same he was cyborg (human but had mecha organz)...jonboy invented one piece aka mecha heart from trash found in goa kingdom...it will take longer to u to explain so to sum it up tink of it like tis : joy boy despite losing his biological heart..he still didn't lose his emotions and love..

-2nd : inspiration from disney works like voyage of sinbad : there a song "ur heart is ur compass"..lufy in fact don't need compass or log poze..he's or his heart electromagnetically (haki) conected with one piece trézor aka joyboy's mecha heart..so mecha heart is atracting lufy toward it without even lufy realizing tis..

-3rd : read about aztec sun heart ritual (also forshadowed in skypia sacrifice ritual chapters)...notice how lufy's biologikal heart had received many injuriz in battles (crocodile pierced his chest..so did akainu)...also i don't tink lufy's biological heart will be able to sustain gear5 for long..so at some point in manga..luffy's biological heart will have injuri and will need to be replaced by mecha heart aka one piece trézor..notice oda how he alredy marked lufy's chest with X scar aka mark of location of trézor or where it will end up buried in pirate maps..chest is word with dual meaning..1- it can meanbody part above abdomen.....2-it can mean container or box of trézor...so teh wordplay here is : "INSIDE LUFY'S CHEST LIES HIS HEART"!!!...like in aztec sun heart ritualz..lufy's heart will be sacrified for sun and in exchange of that teh sun itself in form of one piece trézor will become his new heart..one piece trézor aka mecha heart will have shaped and design of both aztec sun disk and compass...

4-why mecha heart as one piece trézor???? : becuz mecha heart will boost lufy's Gear abilitis (gear 6)..it wil also amplify his nika heartbeats...also it will inscreaze his haki powers..

5-it's inspired from bible : teh burning heart of jesos....

tis is maximum sum up i could make..

oh also lufy wil turn into giant robot..and oda in last arcs wil reveal manga's true genre : mecha genre..(also steampunk)..
 
#12
1st i tel u few consepts where oda insipired and decided one piece trézor to be mecha heart..

-1st concept of love is very important...it was forshadowed in egghead arc kuma-boney flashbaks..kuma despite him turning into robot still had emotions..joyboy same he was cyborg (human but had mecha organz)...jonboy invented one piece aka mecha heart from trash found in goa kingdom...it will take longer to u to explain so to sum it up tink of it like tis : joy boy despite losing his biological heart..he still didn't lose his emotions and love..

-2nd : inspiration from disney works like voyage of sinbad : there a song "ur heart is ur compass"..lufy in fact don't need compass or log poze..he's or his heart electromagnetically (haki) conected with one piece trézor aka joyboy's mecha heart..so mecha heart is atracting lufy toward it without even lufy realizing tis..

-3rd : read about aztec sun heart ritual (also forshadowed in skypia sacrifice ritual chapters)...notice how lufy's biologikal heart had received many injuriz in battles (crocodile pierced his chest..so did akainu)...also i don't tink lufy's biological heart will be able to sustain gear5 for long..so at some point in manga..luffy's biological heart will have injuri and will need to be replaced by mecha heart aka one piece trézor..notice oda how he alredy marked lufy's chest with X scar aka mark of location of trézor or where it will end up buried in pirate maps..chest is word with dual meaning..1- it can meanbody part above abdomen.....2-it can mean container or box of trézor...so teh wordplay here is : "INSIDE LUFY'S CHEST LIES HIS HEART"!!!...like in aztec sun heart ritualz..lufy's heart will be sacrified for sun and in exchange of that teh sun itself in form of one piece trézor will become his new heart..one piece trézor aka mecha heart will have shaped and design of both aztec sun disk and compass...

4-why mecha heart as one piece trézor???? : becuz mecha heart will boost lufy's Gear abilitis (gear 6)..it wil also amplify his nika heartbeats...also it will inscreaze his haki powers..

5-it's inspired from bible : teh burning heart of jesos....

tis is maximum sum up i could make..

oh also lufy wil turn into giant robot..and oda in last arcs wil reveal manga's true genre : mecha genre..(also steampunk)..
I dont know but I don't necessarily dislike it :usosmug: thats a theory I ain't heard before, wouldn't be too upset if something like that came true... Instead of weapons like the ancient ones the real treasure that the "mother flame" might power would be a heart, a symbol of friendship... 20 years too early may have to do with the awakened gear 5 as many have theorized, and the heartbeat is one of the most significant parts of gear 5 symbolically... We still dunno how a rubber man would be known as the sun god, and gear 5 makes him burn hot seemingly so yeah I can see his heart ultimately being what Roger was lacking.


Do you think maybe the mother flame is ultimately a flawed imitation of the burning heart of nika? The "true mecha genre" theory is something I can get behind, IDK why but I've always felt like Oda's story reminded me in some ways of old Tomino anime, the whole void century always reminded me of "Turn A Gundam" specifically and I always wondered if Pluton was truly some kind of ancient mecha like the "White Doll" from that show. Could explain Franky's mecha theming partially, if he will ultimately be connected to a true Mecha worthy of the name. Like they only call it a battleship because that is the only comparable thing the people of today know of. And of course there's the big robot/building in Elbaf Franky and Lillith discovered.

Thanks for letting me know the theory, I'll bookmark your post my dude. into the annals of interesting theories it goes :yodaswag:
 
#13
I dont know but I don't necessarily dislike it :usosmug: thats a theory I ain't heard before, wouldn't be too upset if something like that came true... Instead of weapons like the ancient ones the real treasure that the "mother flame" might power would be a heart, a symbol of friendship... 20 years too early may have to do with the awakened gear 5 as many have theorized, and the heartbeat is one of the most significant parts of gear 5 symbolically... We still dunno how a rubber man would be known as the sun god, and gear 5 makes him burn hot seemingly so yeah I can see his heart ultimately being what Roger was lacking.


Do you think maybe the mother flame is ultimately a flawed imitation of the burning heart of nika? The "true mecha genre" theory is something I can get behind, IDK why but I've always felt like Oda's story reminded me in some ways of old Tomino anime, the whole void century always reminded me of "Turn A Gundam" specifically and I always wondered if Pluton was truly some kind of ancient mecha like the "White Doll" from that show. Could explain Franky's mecha theming partially, if he will ultimately be connected to a true Mecha worthy of the name. Like they only call it a battleship because that is the only comparable thing the people of today know of. And of course there's the big robot/building in Elbaf Franky and Lillith discovered.

Thanks for letting me know the theory, I'll bookmark your post my dude. into the annals of interesting theories it goes :yodaswag:
look at iron man arc reactor..lufy is like teh tony stark..teh mecha heart can also be considered source of energy and weapon..
also plz google aztec sun heart ritual..becuz its main inspiration for oda..

-did u notice that items or trézor like gold and money dont intrest lufy..but when luffy sees mecha objects and robots his eyes turn shiny like star???..so nature of trezor being mecha heart will align with lufy's love for cyborgs and mecha objects...

what does sun have to do with ruber since ruber melts under sun...true..but did u know that sun can harden ruber when its vulcanized????..also..oda choice for rubber man fits with heartbeats..becuz tink of lufy's heart as drum beating and his rubber body as skin of drum...so teh ruber body will work like amplifier..

but teh ruber is meant for other purposes too like reaching height of giants...also its related to my greatest one piece theory wich states that the world of one piece is flat not spherical..YES ITS FLAT..PLZ DO NOT BE FOOLED BY ODA BROTHER..

for teh more infos about mecha heart u might watsh tis if u want..

..


thnkx for ur foodback..i enjoyed our discusions..
 
Top