Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

[Lord Melkor]

@Lord Melkor what did you do to Ace?

Sińce he claimed protect day 1 i used my bodyguard ability that redirects kills targetting my target to me. I survive first one though.

 

[KWEH]

Mmm okay strange stuff afoot

As part of my wish I get to watch Ratchet every night

And he had no visitors last night

 

[Flower]

Mmm okay strange stuff afoot

As part of my wish I get to watch Ratchet every night

And he had no visitors last night

You used it during the day yes? So not at night which can be messed with?

 

[Lord Melkor]

She claimed to have used Invests and they all failed. And if Orca is to be trusted she was not commuted either as he got a result, so one of you 3 is scum for sure.

Interesting. What exactly is Naomi's claim? Orca said he is watcher day 1, right?

 

[Flower]

Interesting. What exactly is Naomi's claim? Orca said he is watcher day 1, right?

Tracker. And Trapper.

 

[Flower]

Xlaw is probably confirmed scum, after all?

 

[Lord Melkor]

All 3 failed...well mine didn't

You used you watch on Naomi? What exactly were your results then?

 

[Flower]

Can‘t be a Bus Driver because they would show in the Watch results.

 

[Flower]

Naomi and Melkor can’t both be telling the truth because Naomi was clearly blocked if she is being truthful and Melkor would have seen that. Unless Orca is lying and Naomi was bus driven and Melkor actually went elsewhere.

 

[Lord Melkor]

okay im terrible at posting on this forum

Not our fault forum is not working properly.

You are confirmed town, what is your direction?

 

[Flower]

Not our fault forum is not working properly.

You are confirmed town, what is your direction?

Well, from a Town you pov your direction today should be between Naomi and Orca.

 

[Flower]

@KWEH you‘re positive you targeted Ratchet and not somebody else?

 

[Flower]

Personally I think we should vote between Xlaw, Melkor and Orca today, preferably the former two.

 

[KWEH]

You used it during the day yes? So not at night which can be messed with?

It's my wish, I watch Ratchet every night

 

[bittersweet]

Did Orca ever give his results?

 

[KWEH]

It's my wish, I watch Ratchet every night

And he received no visitors last night

@Ratchet is there anything about your role that would mess with my result?
@Xlaw same question?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Well, from a Town you pov your direction today should be between Naomi and Orca.

I need to think about it. But why would Naomi or Orca, even as scum, lie about their results? Just to get me lynched?

Between those two i think that Orca is more likely to be scum. I scum read him day 1. Today i barely read anything yet.

 

[Flower]

Did Orca ever give his results?

Visited Naomi, Melkor visited her.

And Melkor confirmed the visit.

Which means

1) Orca wasn’t redirected
2) None of them was messed with otherwise.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Melkor was your only visitor. Which i believe you figured out lol

Then it does not make sense. Because according to my results my target (Naomi was not roleblocked or redirected) and you saw only me visiting. Some kind of ninja maybe? But why scum would not save it for faction kill?

 

[Flower]

I need to think about it. But why would Naomi or Orca, even as scum, lie about their results? Just to get me lynched?

Between those two i think that Orca is more likely to be scum. I scum read him day 1. Today i barely read anything yet.

Well, I think it’s more likely you‘re the scum out of them.

But if you’re not then

1) Naomi claimed before Orca did, she probably didn’t expect a Watcher on her if she’s scum

or

2) Orca wants to play you two against each other and chain mislynches

Because technically Orca is being truthful (if you’re Town you did visit her, he might just be leaving out the actual blocker from his results) you couldn’t even truly hold it against him.

Can exclude the possibility of a Ninja blocker though because you would have learned she was blocked in that case.

Tldr there’s a motive and angle for the two of them to be scum if you’re Town and it’s not like they‘d suicide on you as you claim.