Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

1 indie - flower

10 towns

let's take of any paranoid hat i had:
1. me
2. xlaw
3. ratchet
4. alyssa
5. ace
6. orca
7. KWEH
8.
9.
10.

That means half of these spots (4) are scum then and i've ha majority of them as town:

Ali v2 - no claim afaik, but is here to talk more because i think he said he was busy earlier?
Mr. Reloaded - cleared early for weak reasons, hasn't done much since
Zemmi - liked claim and activity but i there's inconsistency
Michelle - night chat and census from wish, looking back i hate this "ok, FOR YOU i'll vote Bitter" or whatever it was, looked really wishy washy, if sth happenns it's all YOUR fault, i've been wanting to talk with people about this spot for hours and everyone showed up for cfd only, idk, we got the census but mafia already knows how may members they have anyway
Yoshi - like ratchet said, just sheeping whoever, idk
jinri - ngl, would be funny af if i saved mafia here, but tbh just like with bitter, it looked like noone gives a shet anyway, so really wouldn't be surprised if this was town too
EkkoLoJinx - i mean idk, he cares about lynching flower more than about lynching mafia, so either it's town who cares more about proving the point which is scary because i can see it being the case, also did he want alyssa to duel melkor? or was it always, strickly about flower


@Ali v2 @Ratchet

please tell me what you think
 
et's take of any paranoid hat i had:
1. me
2. xlaw
3. ratchet
4. alyssa
5. ace
6. orca
7. KWEH
8.
9.
10.
in case i don't get the answer btw

1 - me duh, you can add "scum already had protective role in melkor" if you want
2 - xlaw - only investigator apparently
3 - ratchet - inno check
4- alyssa - dueled melkor
5- ace - scum already had protective role in melkor
6. orca - outed melkor basically
7. kweh - confirmed xlaw
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
Ali v2 - no claim afaik, but is here to talk more because i think he said he was busy earlier?
Talking to you from my yet to be decorated new home … I can’t promise to be active nor have I had the time to catchup, I might throw town off trail with my outdated knowledge of thread events.


Mr. Reloaded - cleared early for weak reasons, hasn't done much since
Huh, really? I thought Relo would have contributed by now … problem is he wasn’t even the one being cleared early on as well, it was his predecessor yoho, due to yoho related reasons, if relo does not provide results/analysis next DP, I’m afraid he will have to join the scum pile.

Zemmi - liked claim and activity but i there's inconsistency
Then why didn’t you back me up when I sused her last DP? I mean idk what was so steamin hot about bitter but I think the game is at a stall state and everyone has a chance to be scum, you should look more closely to her slot, she is already in my poe. Has similar vibes to relo, wouldn’t be surprised if they are teammates.

Michelle - night chat and census from wish, looking back i hate this "ok, FOR YOU i'll vote Bitter" or whatever it was, looked really wishy washy, if sth happenns it's all YOUR fault, i've been wanting to talk with people about this spot for hours and everyone showed up for cfd only, idk, we got the census but mafia already knows how may members they have anyway
Think Michelle is town. For me, she is as much town as you. one thing I will say is that she used to be much more active in neighborhood chat than how much she is contributing now, also, she didn’t seem the kind of person who would prefer to sheep, so Idk abou(I will vote bitter for you) part.

Yoshi - like ratchet said, just sheeping whoever, idk
Don’t have much about this slot too, started off more care free I think but then went full sheep mode, don’t know what to make of it.

jinri - ngl, would be funny af if i saved mafia here, but tbh just like with bitter, it looked like noone gives a shet anyway, so really wouldn't be surprised if this was town too
Strong Poe for me. Reasons are all gameplay activity related, I’m a strong advocate for afk = red flag, and this slot has been the most surprising red flag for me.

EkkoLoJinx - i mean idk, he cares about lynching flower more than about lynching mafia, so either it's town who cares more about proving the point which is scary because i can see it being the case, also did he want alyssa to duel melkor? or was it always, strickly about flower
Started off as town for me, don’t know if he kept his playstyle or shifted, from what I read before, he was town, as for flower lynch, I’m also a strong advocate for lynching indies, and so far he wasn’t wrong, we lost two townies because of mislynches, that number would have been reduced to one if we had reserved a lynch for evil indie flower.
 
Huh, really? I thought Relo would have contributed by now … problem is he wasn’t even the one being cleared early on as well, it was his predecessor yoho, due to yoho related reasons, if relo does not provide results/analysis next DP, I’m afraid he will have to join the scum pile.
i mean mostly fluff from what i remember

Then why didn’t you back me up when I sused her last DP? I mean idk what was so steamin hot about bitter but I think the game is at a stall state and everyone has a chance to be scum, you should look more closely to her slot, she is already in my poe. Has similar vibes to relo, wouldn’t be surprised if they are teammates.
i had to change way of thinking since there's no way everyone's town here

at the time i even had zemmi in town core, it irked me that she's going in complaining how everyone's inactive yet doesn't show up for like a day when i tag everyone to show up
 
I have difficulty believing this,
it either he is scum with Xlaw or he is GF.
I have a strong belief town ratchet would be much more active and even try to town lead, which he is not doing.
i mean maybe but like i said above, i don't want to run around with tinfoil hat anymore, i have results in front of me, i chose to believe them

When did this happen? Is kweh an investigative role?
kweh's wish for flower was to have perma watcher on ratchet and he confirmed xlaw visited ratchet
 
hmm

although when i asked for investigative action of any sort i was denied

so maybe he is lying after all

eh

i don't want to solve based on what i think fuji would or would not do, i did it with bitter already

i guess you can move kweh out of 10 "confirmed" ones for now
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
kweh's wish for flower was to have perma watcher on ratchet and he confirmed xlaw visited ratchet
So? They could still be a team.
no offense to Xlaw but I think he is getting coached. that’s like clearing two people with one stone, and ratchet wasn’t even that sus compared to people like Orca and Brad (zemmi now) and polar (at least for me) so I don’t know why he would go for ratchet … plus, other than this result, he hasn’t done anything.

What about the “let’s make town club” bizzare post he made early in D2? Does that strike you as town investigator type of post?

I’m not saying we should go for them, but clearing them off that is a bit too generous I think, he needs to either catch scum with his ability or play so undeniably towny that we look somewhere else.
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
hmm

although when i asked for investigative action of any sort i was denied

so maybe he is lying after all

eh

i don't want to solve based on what i think fuji would or would not do, i did it with bitter already

i guess you can move kweh out of 10 "confirmed" ones for now
I think kweh is fine, mainly because he was somewhat vouched for by flower, an indie that has no interest in lying D1, it’s a hunch read but I feel confi about it.
 
So? They could still be a team.
no offense to Xlaw but I think he is getting coached. that’s like clearing two people with one stone, and ratchet wasn’t even that sus compared to people like Orca and Brad (zemmi now) and polar (at least for me) so I don’t know why he would go for ratchet … plus, other than this result, he hasn’t done anything.

What about the “let’s make town club” bizzare post he made early in D2? Does that strike you as town investigator type of post?

I’m not saying we should go for them, but clearing them off that is a bit too generous I think, he needs to either catch scum with his ability or play so undeniably towny that we look somewhere else.
i mean when it comes to thread alone, nothing makes me town read xlaw, no
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
So? They could still be a team.
no offense to Xlaw but I think he is getting coached. that’s like clearing two people with one stone, and ratchet wasn’t even that sus compared to people like Orca and Brad (zemmi now) and polar (at least for me) so I don’t know why he would go for ratchet
Problem is it doesn't need to be something you would do, it just needs to be something Xlaw would do. I think investigating one of the people pushing for his wagon makes sense and is easy to reconcile.
What about the “let’s make town club” bizzare post he made early in D2? Does that strike you as town investigator type of post?
Rather, why do you think it isn't?

I know I'm wasting the time and energy because no one here is open to any sort of reason when it comes to this stuff, it'll just be tunnel until you see the flip, so consider this my obligatory "I tried" post.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
1 - me duh, you can add "scum already had protective role in melkor" if you want
2 - xlaw - only investigator apparently
3 - ratchet - inno check
4- alyssa - dueled melkor
5- ace - scum already had protective role in melkor
6. orca - outed melkor basically
7. kweh - confirmed xlaw
Which names are left over - to help me visualise this.
 
Top