Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Naomi *can* be town but for me she is not far enough out of range yet to give her a town read. I don't think she's earned it. If I must pick I'd say probably more likely town than not, though could see her being an indie very easily.
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
1- Ali v2
3- The Orca
4- Polar Bear
5- Charlie
6- Flower
12- KWEH
14- freckles
17- Michelle
18- Yoshi
20- EkkoLoJinx

All town to varying degrees. Rest can be PoE'd.
I wish you hadn’t put my name in that list.
because now I have more questions.

If I was a “somewhat” town in your reads, why did you agree and actively attempt to CFD me?
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I could see Xlaw being scum. He was pretty transparently lurking near the end, and made sure to drop only the flavour claim without the role. I could plausibly see scum given fake flavour claims.

Then everything that came after votes locked could have been performative. He may have been a hit you know...

Yoho is one I think I had as town back earlier in the game but I can't really recall why.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I wish you hadn’t put my name in that list.
because now I have more questions.

If I was a “somewhat” town in your reads, why did you agree and actively attempt to CFD me?
You don't think my read can change between then and now? Do you think your posting now, your questioning, the angles you're taking, the defence of you when I brought you up... do you think none of that could factor into my reads? Come on.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I believe that Flower is probably not lying about her win con and at worst has left some things undisclosed. I don't think she's entirely trustworthy but not a player I feel needs resources spent upon to discern her alighment.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
It's not like I'm saying we need to grant her her wincon. I don't recall anything about a specific townie being needed but I believe she's indie and that's enough for me to not warrant further time spent trying to solve her.
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
You don't think my read can change between then and now? Do you think your posting now, your questioning, the angles you're taking, the defence of you when I brought you up... do you think none of that could factor into my reads? Come on.
No, I don’t think so, not from you, not when I was legit afk, not when there were a lot safer/more sensible options, including flower, no.

You were so quick to CFD me, that doesn’t strike me as a townie who previously read me as town, especially when you say you didn’t read the thread, meaning the last posts you read were probably the same posts that made you town read me.

Your CFD was opportunistic to say the least, I wasn’t there and your vote contradicted your previous read on me, prove me wrong.
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
It's not like I'm saying we need to grant her her wincon. I don't recall anything about a specific townie being needed but I believe she's indie and that's enough for me to not warrant further time spent trying to solve her.
She admitted this herself and even asked whoever gets granted a wish next DP to ask fuji to change her target to a ”non-town”
 
Hello. Sorry, had to go to work and it's kinda terrible shift rn. Hoped for different result, ngl but skimming past eod i saw this comming. I mean could be worse but doesn't look like scum has to do anything rn.

So first of all, this isn't my action or anything I've done. I hate night chat with passion and i'd never put myself here by myself. If it's neither of you 2, i guess we'll learn tomorow who did it. I have no locked action or passive either so i'm 100% sure i had nothing to do with it. Maaaaybe it's some mech related to flavour? Idk. But let's not claim and make Flowers life easier. @Ratchet haven't you said you're suspicious of me and Ali? Maybe that's why we're here. To give you time to like, talk to us 2 and decide? I mean, maybe that's why someone picked us 3. If that's the reasoning and it's neither of you 2 i guess it makes sensie for town, whoever that was.

But in case there's different reason, who thought more of Charlie talk would be useful? Be my guest. I've been running like chicken without its head for half of the dp. Just because you town read me doesn't mean i'll be useful "lead", quite the opposite.

I'll be going to bed but i'll read night posts and all before eod.
 
1- Ali v2
3- The Orca
4- Polar Bear
5- Charlie
6- Flower
12- KWEH
14- freckles
17- Michelle
18- Yoshi
20- EkkoLoJinx

All town to varying degrees. Rest can be PoE'd.
I mean, Freckles is dead and flower is Indie. But i know, i know.

Werent you unsure od me and Ali when talking to michelle? Like, borderline willing to cfd one of us. How are we outside of poe rn? That's kinda confusing to me, ngl. Can you elaborate?

I would personally keep Ekko out of there rn. And maybe Yoshi? Idk about Yoshi. Let's say remove Ekko, add Yoho.

Ali i don't think ever is scum with bitter so if one flips scum, other one should be good.

Naomi *can* be town but for me she is not far enough out of range yet to give her a town read. I don't think she's earned it. If I must pick I'd say probably more likely town than not, though could see her being an indie very easily.
Well yes. If it's one of these games where scum only gets flavour and has to get claims through janitor, i can totally see Naomi's claim being some convoluted slip. Basically knowing janitors are comming and explaining why she's not dying since she claimed her flavour. It's not as obvious town read as usually which does worry me a bit.

I could see Xlaw being scum. He was pretty transparently lurking near the end, and made sure to drop only the flavour claim without the role. I could plausibly see scum given fake flavour claims.

Then everything that came after votes locked could have been performative. He may have been a hit you know....
Agree about xlaw tbh. That "shut up scum" caught me off guard. One because i don't recall xlaw ever posting in this manner, two because how does he even know flower was indie if he wasn't caught up? This did feel as if someone asked him to say that, ngl.

You don't think my read can change between then and now? Do you think your posting now, your questioning, the angles you're taking, the defence of you when I brought you up... do you think none of that could factor into my reads? Come on.
I can believe your read on Ali has changed but why would your read on me improve? I wasn't there between these 2 posts and I've voted town that got mislynched. If anything, i'd assume it would make look worse.

I believe that Flower is probably not lying about her win con and at worst has left some things undisclosed. I don't think she's entirely trustworthy but not a player I feel needs resources spent upon to discern her alighment.
Well yes. She's likely more mallicious than she let's us know but i don't think she's like, sk or mafia for that matter.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Werent you unsure od me and Ali when talking to michelle? Like, borderline willing to cfd one of us. How are we outside of poe rn? That's kinda confusing to me, ngl. Can you elaborate?
Yeah so for you, Flower mentioned you were directing night actions, and I felt that as scum you maybe wouldn't go for that. Hence, my change of heart.
 
Top