Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

[bittersweet]

Did he claim before or after the Polar Bear flip?

 

[Naomi]

I know he claimed this, not sure if he claimed anything else.

also just realized if we had protects paying attention they would protected him, kinda scummy ace overlooked that Xd and protected charlie who unclaimed.

 

[Naomi]

Did he claim before or after the Polar Bear flip?

after polar flip in discord.

 

[Naomi]

@bittersweet he claimed he might have results day 2 in discord is what i meant.

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

Did he claim before or after the Polar Bear flip?

he randomly claimed watcher at the end of some other post somewhere on day one

it looked bizarrely out of place

 

[bittersweet]

So we can't confirm that it wasn't PB's janitored role?

 

[Zemmi]

So we can't confirm that it wasn't PB's janitored role?

What do you mean by this?

 

[Naomi]

What do you mean by this?

he questing if polar was watcher i think, think he misunderstood the claim order.

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

actually now that I'm thinking about it, does anyone have a list of the claims that were made day one?

I had a theory overnight that other than the watcher claim, all of them are likely to just be town and I want to double check that

 

[bittersweet]

That's why I was asking when he claimed.

If he did it before PB's flip, then I'd believe it or at least tentatively believe it.
If after, I would heavily scrutinize it.

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

Scum above
Town

Naomi
Charlie
Yoho
Polar

Flower indy/scum

Rest nullish town to nullish scum

I'm watcher

I found the watcher claim

I did not find this claim townie at all

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

oh of course now I see that it was directly asked for

okay belay that the claim is NAI then

 

[Zemmi]

actually now that I'm thinking about it, does anyone have a list of the claims that were made day one?

I had a theory overnight that other than the watcher claim, all of them are likely to just be town and I want to double check that

Naomi's character claim
Orca's watcher claim
bittersweet claim where he can get a census and he said invest results can be messed with.
and the multiple parts of flower's claim. Indie, has to grant wishes, as to make sure a player dies before her (likely a town) and jailor.

I can't really remember any others off the top of my head.

 

[Zemmi]

I found the watcher claim

I did not find this claim townie at all

Did he do the one I posted first or the one you posted first? I missed the one you posted until just now.

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

I don't particularly care about character claims since they're not directly mech so I'm considering this NAI for that exercise

but I remember the bittersweet claim now and I'd consider that town yes

I was considering Ace Marvel's commuter claim too since that was out of nowhere and found that pretty townie

a lot of why I'm considering Flower's claim as likely genuine is mostly the timing and especially claiming an anti-town part of their role, it looks truth-coded to me

so if that's the extent of it then I think the read is probably accurate

 

[bittersweet]

Town:
The Orca - watcher claim
Polar Bear - died, janitored role
freckles - tree stump

Slight town lean:
Naomi
KWEH

Indie:
Flower

Null
Ali v2
Charlie
Xlaw
Zemmi
Alyssa the Lamb
AceMarvel
Michelle
Yoshi
jinri

POE:
Ekko
Ratchet
Yoho
Lord Melkor

Not really confident on the POE. The thread state was really convoluted at the end of the last day phase.

 

[Zemmi]

Did he do the one I posted first or the one you posted first? I missed the one you posted until just now.

Holy crap, it looks like I missed a post he was directing to me.

I must've been more disengaged then I even realized at that point.

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

Did he do the one I posted first or the one you posted first? I missed the one you posted until just now.

where's the one you posted? it's not on this page

 

[Zemmi]

where's the one you posted? it's not on this page

This would have been fun. I think we could have caused hell together lol

Scum above
Town

Naomi
Charlie
Yoho
Polar

Flower indy/scum

Rest nullish town to nullish scum

I'm watcher

Didn't see it. Was asleep until a little bit ago. Alyssa had a weird jump on vote of Naomi toward the middle ish of D1 when a few jumped Naomi. Seemed out of place and kind of like the vote scum will do to push a line up. Didn't really feel like it was genuine. Brad and jinri evaporated post wise. Ali is using bad logic and doubling down on stuff that is easily disproved and looks to be forcing a read on me. Flower I could totally see being scum. Its just like an upgrade or double move role (the wishes)

I'm the watcher. I see who visits my target

These are all the posts that came up when I searched for his post with the keyword watcher. @Alyssa the Lamb I can't believe the one you posted was actually him responding to me. lol

 

[Alyssa the Lamb]

okay you just reminded me of the other reason that I've been really wolfreading Orca for a while now

Naomi's wolfread on me is completely nonsensical and Orca essentially parroting it and then later saying my vote on her is weird pretty much the same way that Naomi did doesn't look like a real read to me at all

plus watcher is such a basic normal claim compared to every other claim we've had so far, and if what I've been hearing about him being cagey with his info is true, then that's another pretty significant red flag