Anyway, I had a bunch of quotes but I can't really be bothered posting them.
I didn't like how Ekko initially tried to pair Fuji off with me. While he didn't play it off as serious his follow up to my entrance suggests it's an angle hes going for, and I suspect he might be playing positionally.
Flower buddying with Ekko straight away is also weird, and logically her case on hime was poor. I don't just disagree with it. The notion that scum would contest a plan that, quite frankly, doesn't really guarantee anything, all because they're scum, doesn't hold up - scum are not the ones eager to draw attention to themselves that way. Contention like hime's pretty much always comes from town, and her way of working into that read wasnt very good. Also treating my slot exactly the same as Ekko which is bad.
Speaking of Ekko, his arguments on hime are pretty bad too - he initially presented it as "NAI" but then also moved into a scum read, feels like a fake thought to me.
On the topic of the plan, there are a few things that they all seem to fail to consider.
Flaw #1 - a plan is only good if it considers its executors.
Simply put, the idea of everyone targeting a player is a pipe dream. It won't happen, and even if most do, there will be enough going off shoot or inactive that no one is fully exposed by it. But let's say that they are. Once the Watcher is outed, all attempts at enforcing co-operation are moot.
Flaw #2 - Who is deciding the targets
Seems to have been skipped in consideration - who is deciding who we target? I have a solution to this, it's a bit funny actually, but I want to see what the ones making this plan think. Because I think we would agree this is the single most important part of the whole plan.
Flaw #3 - late game
How does this plan work in late game? Do we assume that the watcher will never get killed?
I do think co-operation is going to be helpful on some level. But you need to be able to accommodate people going off the beaten path so to speak. Or, like I alluded to in Flaw #2, you insert some consequence for whomever decides the target.
In terms of reads, I think Yoho, hime, Hayumi, Stargate are all possible town, to varying strengths. Flower can be town, in that she's certainly capable of presenting a read that she doesn't really believe because she's angry at someone, but I have reservations there. Ekko I think can be scum, need to see how he gets treated at large though. Would lean getting a claim there. I guess flower would be at slight scum and Ekko at lean scum.
