Role Madness Too Many Doctors (Game Thread)

Status
Not open for further replies.
hime

hime

‎
#2,684
#2,684
Polar Bear said:
This is a scum post if I have ever seen one

Flower was wrong on 1 out of 21 so they have to be wrong on their strongest read.

Lmao.

Ratchet was wrong on one of his reads but he's 100% right about ekko, oh and everyone who was voting his wrong read has to be town....like wtf is this logic from some of you.

Hime and Alexis are scum imo
Click to expand...
what read was ratchet wrong abt?
 
hime

hime

‎
#2,688
#2,688
hime

hime

‎
#2,692
#2,692
EkkoLoJinx said:
oh lol thats normal for them, thought u got something there

whats a bit abnormal is orca town reads polar but is not voting the same wagon as him. idk how much i wanna read into that but could be something noteworthy
Click to expand...
actually i dont mind this read from u at all
orca typically tunnels me and given polar was voting me last day, i expected orca to as well but then he didnt
not sure what that means but still think u r scum tho
 
hime

hime

‎
#2,693
#2,693
Hayumi said:
I don’t think the order really matters all that much. They should both be dead by tomorrow morning. If both are town this really is just a game full of inactive and low poster scum

:few:
Click to expand...
if the order doesnt really matter then y not vote ekko who is being voted by multiple ppl?
this is sus, esp the timing of it all
 
hime

hime

‎
#2,694
#2,694
Alexis2282AE said:
  • @Ali v2: Target @Alwaysmind.
  • @Luka: Target @The Orca.
  • @Yoho: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Daniel.
  • Daniel: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect me (Alexis).
  • Alexis2282AE: Protecting @Yo Tan Wa.
  • Yo Tan Wa: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Michelle.
  • Michelle: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Random Asshole.
  • Alwaysmind: Target Ali v2.
  • Random Asshole: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Stargate18.
  • Stargate18: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @York.
  • York: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Polar Bear.
  • The Orca: Target Luka.
  • Polar Bear: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Red Night.
  • Red Night: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @hime.
  • hime: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect @Hayumi.
  • Hayumi: If Watcher: Target Alwaysmind. If Doctor: Protect Yoho.
  • The Mafia has a 100% chance to attempt their factional kill.
  • If they target the single unprotected Town member (identified by figuring out who the Watcher is and thus who isn't being protected in the chain), the kill will succeed. This is a 1/12 chance if they guess randomly among the assumed Town members.
  • If they target a protected Town member, the kill will fail unless the Mafia JOAT successfully roleblocks the specific Doctor protecting that target.
  • The Watcher's success depends on Alwaysmind being visited by another Mafia member (as per this plan or by scum's own strategy like a Mafia Doctor protection) and the absence of JOAT interference (Sensei on the visitor or Roleblock on the Watcher).
  • If anything goes wrong:
    • A Town member was killed: This most likely means one of two things:
      1. The Mafia targeted the one Town member who was not protected by a Town Doctor (because the Doctor who would have protected them was actually the Watcher).
      2. The Mafia's JOAT successfully roleblocked the Town Doctor who was assigned to protect the Town member who was killed.
    • The Watcher receives no results on Alwaysmind: This could indicate:
      1. No one actually visited Alwaysmind.
      2. A visitor to Alwaysmind was made undetectable by the Mafia JOAT's Sensei ability.
      3. The Watcher themself was roleblocked by the Mafia JOAT.
Repeating: 11 out of the 12 assumed Town members (approximately 91.7%) will be protected by a Town Doctor. One assumed Town member (approximately 8.3%) will be vulnerable to a direct kill.
Click to expand...
using doctor as a regular doctor might open very town read players to get killed tho easily bc scum also has a doctor
 
Stargate18

Stargate18

‎
#2,696
#2,696
Alexis2282AE said:
  • If anything goes wrong:
    • A Town member was killed: This most likely means one of two things:
      1. The Mafia targeted the one Town member who was not protected by a Town Doctor (because the Doctor who would have protected them was actually the Watcher).
      2. The Mafia's JOAT successfully roleblocked the Town Doctor who was assigned to protect the Town member who was killed.
Click to expand...
...Alexis, you do see the issue with this, right? If this happens, town won't know which scenario happened, but scum will.

This plan has a decent chance of making a game state where scum know who the watcher is and we don't. That's pretty much the worst case scenario here.
 
hime

hime

‎
#2,698
#2,698
ok ive caught up now

i think in a world where ekko flips scum, the following slots would be those i would look into first:
fuji/luka
michelle
daniel
hayumi
potentially orca

if he is town i would have to heavily reassess tho i think im a goner if so
 
hime

hime

‎
#2,699
#2,699
i dont agree with using doctors as protects btw, i feel like its too risky
we should be using them as vigs bc anyone u target has the potential of dying as a result

if anything, i think watcher should be treated as the protect this game
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top