Character Discussion Top 5 worst written characters

[park_min young]

The problem is that Oda clearly thinks we’re SUPPOSED to like her just because she started twerking for Luffy, despite the fact that she’s still an awful person to everyone else. Also doesn’t help that being a Luffy simp became her entire personality

She’s a good character and quite enjoyable without interacting with Luffy. Oda fucking reduced her to a simp, biggest L.

Post automatically merged: Jun 24, 2025

What you smoking? BM is the most well-written Yonko Oda has given us so far:

-Interesting backstory that's tragic and ties deeply to the events of a future arc
-Clear goals with multiple facets towards that goal including becoming PK, using science to gigantify, create a paradise with all races
-History with multiple Yonkos including brother-sister relationship with Kaido
-Powers that are far more creative and interesting than just 'muh black lightning'
-Knows much more than she leads on, including hints to OP, Lunarian race, God Valley events, etc
-Arrogant personality that becomes her own downfall yet endears her as an avenger that won't accept defeat even till the very end
-Contrast age visual appearance that shows her decline but leaves imagination open as to how she was when she was still beautiful

Oda put a lot of thought into BM despite being a secondary villain in Wano. The fact she keeps getting mentioned and her powers referenced also shows Oda actually likes the fat bitch on the side

Yeah, BM is unironically the most fleshed out yonko so far with a great backstory and characterization. I like her writing outside of Oda using her as a deus ex machina multiple times during Wano.

 

[soupongo]

Hancock is meh, shes overated and her gag stopped being funny at some point long ago, but I don't think its bad shes not actually a girl boss and is a scumbag. With the exception of Kuma, I think being sociopathic is part of the warlord charm

those popularity polls are really just trash imo

 

[RyoQ]

@EmperorKinyagi @RyoQ

Akainu at 53? Kizaru at 59? I wonder where Greenbull will rank in the next popularity poll

Probably in the 200s

I acknowledge Aramaki as a character only higher minds enjoy and that automatically discludes 99.9% of normies

Post automatically merged: Jun 24, 2025

Bro is a badly written Tsundere hence why you’re there

Insane that Greenbull having a figure he admires like Akainu is seen as a bad thing, even though this fleshes out not only Greenbull and Akainu

And gives a new dynamic to the Marines. People are crazy

 

[gz89]

Mihawk till further notice
Shanks
Oden
Kaido

 

[soupongo]

Probably in the 200s

I acknowledge Aramaki as a character only higher minds enjoy and that automatically discludes 99.9% of normies

Post automatically merged: Jun 24, 2025

Insane that Greenbull having a figure he admires like Akainu is seen as a bad thing, even though this fleshes out not only Greenbull and Akainu

And gives a new dynamic to the Marines. People are crazy

Gigamaki makes red puppy fans insecure. They're low-key traitors to the admiral fandom who twerk for Akainu to be seen as relative to trash like Rat hair, Cuckeye, Luffy's deadbeat dad and Pissrock instead of his fellow admirals

 

[RyoQ]

Gigamaki makes red puppy fans insecure. They're low-key traitors to the admiral fandom who twerk for Akainu to be seen as relative to trash like Rat hair, Cuckeye, Luffy's deadbeat dad and Pissrock instead of his fellow admirals

Any Admiral fan who slanders GB is not a real Admiral fan and is a bitch who wants to be accepted by Shanks, Zolo fans

It's ez to be merely an Akainu fan. The entire forum voted him #2 strongest in the verse last year

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

Mihawk
Vista
Venus
Smoothie
Gion
Tokikake

Post automatically merged: Jun 24, 2025

Maybe i should exclude Mihawk..

Gion is cool

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2025

Gigamaki makes red puppy fans insecure. They're low-key traitors to the admiral fandom who twerk for Akainu to be seen as relative to trash like Rat hair, Cuckeye, Luffy's deadbeat dad and Pissrock instead of his fellow admirals

Word would Aramaki face off against Zoro for being the other green and racist guy with a blade in the verse?

 

[MonsterKaido]

He didn't fight Shanks to the finish, he backed off as soon as he knew Shanks would win lmfao

Kaido is a pussy who chose to fortify Wano of all places because it is difficult for the Marines he is hiding from to invade

Kaido was going out for expeditions. When ace came he was out of wano.

His intro also happened out of wano.

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

Kaido was going out for expeditions. When ace came he was out of wano.

His intro also happened out of wano.

Oda probably should have had more interactions with BM/Kaido and factions like the marines. As of now they feel pretty disconnected from everything

 

[MonsterKaido]

Mihawk till further notice
Shanks
Oden
Kaido

I thought you had Mihawk as your fav?

 

[Topi Jerami]

No 7. Whatever Oda did with her is working

Just like Yamao, both were getting carried by their good looking. That's all.

 

[Ven437]

Just like Yamao, both were getting carried by their good looking. That's all.

Everybody on top 10 except carrot is good looking

Zoro and law popularity for women is carried exactly bc they are good looking. don't kid yourself this shit not exclusive for guys to female char

 

[HerreraIsBack]

1. Lolden

One of the best written ones

 

[Topi Jerami]

Everybody on top 10 except carrot is good looking

Zoro and law popularity for women is carried exactly bc they are good looking. don't kid yourself this shit not exclusive for guys to female char

When character like Blackbeard is at 46 while shitty characters like Hancock, Carrot (she got Sulong form) and Sabo are at Top 10 and Yamao at 11, we know the popularity contest is actually a beauty contest.

 

[GeneralP123]

Vegaskunk
Jinbore
~ Hody ~
Oden
Rebecca

Vegapunk is my boi

Jinbe is the best strawhat

I can agree with Oden

Hody is on my list

Rebecca is garbage, she's so bad that I forgot about her!

Post automatically merged: Jun 25, 2025

When character like Blackbeard is at 46 while shitty characters like Hancock, Carrot (she got Sulong form) and Sabo are at Top 10 and Yamao at 11, we know the popularity contest is actually a beauty contest.

Popularity polls highest rankers are usually just main characters/pretty characters/cute characters.

 

[Natalija]

Vegapunk is my boi

 

[kurwa]

No 7 because Japan is filled with loser simps

Carrot’s there for similar reasons

Carrot is there because she was botted just like nami

there’s a video literally showing these 2 cheating so hard it’s hilarious

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Characters like Vander Decken and Hody are well-written imo. they perfectly fill their roles in the story. They're supposed to be disgusting and disappointing respectively.

 

[gz89]

I thought you had Mihawk as your fav?

He still is but I've long since accepted that his sole purpose is to be the biggest obstacle Zoro has to overcome and that's fine with me.

I'm also not a fan of the Nerona/Imu Mihawk theories.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Probably in the 200s

I acknowledge Aramaki as a character only higher minds enjoy and that automatically discludes 99.9% of normies

Post automatically merged: Jun 24, 2025

Insane that Greenbull having a figure he admires like Akainu is seen as a bad thing, even though this fleshes out not only Greenbull and Akainu

And gives a new dynamic to the Marines. People are crazy

Dude's acting like Aramaki has Griffith levels of depth and writing