[FNZ] Role Madness Urusei Yatsura Mafia #1

[Charlie]

I don´t like how Charlie is addressing the flavour claiming as topic. It was already mentioned in the opening post that flavour claiming basically brings us nowhere in this round as flavour is not alignment indicative at all.

Opening post is saying about both role and flavour. So yeah, claiming both has consequences. Correct me if i'm wrong but then Rej said that flavour means nothing.

 

[Charlie]

Not a good response.

All you have to say?

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

my boy kekko rolled the insane cop.
He scanned you as town.
But because he is the insane variable he gets the opposite results meaning you are mafia.

From my role it looks like i am town :) , sorry this insane cop i have no idea about it.

 

[Ratchet]

All you have to say?

Well, the main issue is it doesn't address the correct elements.

1 - Your first recourse is to say others have used gifs and nothing else - in an attempt to discredit my accusation, you attempt to establish my position as one where I say those things are fine. It's obviously not my position, but I can't read into someone using gifs, I can read into someone attempting to talk about the game.

2 - Your last post is to insinuate that as scum, you'd also just post gifs to blend in - I don't believe you think this is an accurate depiction of your approach to scum.

3 - Your focus is on attacking the reasoning behind it, and you also use recent games (I can think of only one, where I was scum) as a means to discredit the line of accusation. The reasoning is obviously going to be weak, it's the motivation that's important here, and I haven't seen any indication that you've considered this.

In short, it's defensive, unduly so, and is more manipulative than genuine because of how its constructed.

 

[Charlie]

From my role it looks like i am town :) , sorry this insane cop i have no idea about it.

He's just messing with you. If it says (Town) next to your name, you are town. If you were mafia you would have more people in your PM

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

He's just messing with you. If it says (Town) next to your name, you are town. If you were mafia you would have more people in your PM

Ya town as hell.

 

[Charlie]

1 - Your first recourse is to say others have used gifs and nothing else - in an attempt to discredit my accusation, you attempt to establish my position as one where I say those things are fine. It's obviously not my position, but I can't read into someone using gifs, I can read into someone attempting to talk about the game

So long story short - you just dislike i'm talking about the game?

2 - Your last post is to insinuate that as scum, you'd also just post gifs to blend in - I don't believe you think this is an accurate depiction of your approach to scum

Pretty sure i know better what i'd do.

Your focus is on attacking the reasoning behind it, and you also use recent games (I can think of only one, where I was scum) as a means to discredit the line of accusation. The reasoning is obviously going to be weak, it's the motivation that's important here, and I haven't seen any indication that you've considered this

I'm not saying you are scum because you use that reasoning. I mean maybe, idk. I'm saying that it's not first time you said my posts feel "mailed in" when i was town. Weird that you still use it as argument for me being scum.

In short, it's defensive, unduly so, and is more manipulative than genuine because of how its constructed

Ratchet, can you bring up one game where i didn't get defensive after something like that?

 

[Seatonnes]

literally nothing has happened, stop metagaming so early, you will look like a clown if you are wrong

 

[Michelle]

Charlie, except people posting gifs who were too many indeed, but a lot were cute so that was a plus, in the game some people posted mafia related content.
Do you have any opinion about them?

 

[Ratchet]

So long story short - you just dislike i'm talking about the game?

Are you going to continue being disingenuous like this? Do you believe this is the issue I'm taking here?

I'm not saying you are scum because you use that reasoning. I mean maybe, idk. I'm saying that it's not first time you said my posts feel "mailed in" when i was town. Weird that you still use it as argument for me being scum.

Well, you'll first have to establish me actually doing this, and being wrong about it, in a game, or several games, where I'm not scum.

Ratchet, can you bring up one game where i didn't get defensive after something like that?

Appeal to meta denied.

 

[Michelle]

Its my first game aswell

literally nothing has happened, stop metagaming so early, you will look like a clown if you are wrong

I don't think I could make such a post in my first game, but maybe you absorbed with the Wiki articles some game experience, somehow.
I am envious on such skill

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

literally nothing has happened, stop metagaming so early, you will look like a clown if you are wrong

Thats how pros play i think.

 

[Seatonnes]

I don't think I could make such a post in my first game, but maybe you absorbed with the Wiki articles some game experience, somehow.
I am envious on such skill

i have never played forum mafia, i have played plenty of mafia/mafia-esque games

 

[Charlie]

Using search option, mailed in + Ratchet

Bleach game

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/bleach-soul-society-arc.40179/page-28#post-4128025

Ratchet - SK, me - Town

Waifu game

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...equiem-of-eternity.35336/page-59#post-3731546

Ratchet - town, me - pro Town indie

There are probably other examples on NF.

So yeah, i don't understand how you still use this as argument for me being scum

 

[Michelle]

i have never played forum mafia, i have played plenty of mafia/mafia-esque games

Ok, that's a decent explanation

 

[Ratchet]

Ratchet - SK, me - Town

I was Town in this game. Why are you saying I'm the SK? The problem is, you obviously believed I was the SK, which invalidates your premise anyway.

Ratchet - town, me - pro Town indie

You were, in fact, not town, and had no incentive to hunt Scum on a wide scale. Which is why they'd be mailed in...

 

[oddoddfruit]

literally nothing has happened, stop metagaming so early, you will look like a clown if you are wrong

Plenty has happened for those in the know, everybody who has posted has provided information for us to work with

 

[oddoddfruit]

Morning morning



I gotta say Odd this was quite a claim to make within the first two or so hours of the game starting. Do you really believe Mafia would not have any early posters?

I believe in bait and setting traps but you didn’t set it off right, which is a good thing. Have a town read

 

[oddoddfruit]

Yo, so talking about game is "safe and easy" and posting pokemon gifs is where's, idk, gamesolving at?

You've been saying my posts feel "mailed in" in a few recent games before. I don't think i was scum in any of them. Is there no reflection?

Like, i know its D1 and reasoning is always shetty in general but this is literally picking up odd one out. As if I wasn't just posting pokemon gifs to fit in if i was mafia

Charles, you’ve set off my alarms and there’s nobody to twist my bias either

 

[Alwaysmind]

Ahem - check OLF too

Only fan?