Speculations Was Mihawk on a Crew Before?

#21
It should occur to most of us that Mihawk probably hasn't been moving around independently his entire life. He wasn't always the strongest swordsman, and he would need a crew to help him even get into situations where he could challenge other swordsmen, wouldn't he?

It's an odd assumption to think that Mihawk was, even as a teen, roaming the seas by himself. He would be contending with who? Whitebeard, Roger, Kaido, Big Mom, and other people like them (Garp, Admirals, Sengoku, the other would-be warlords, etc). He wasn't just neg diffing them every time he encountered them as a teen. It's very unlikely (practically impossible) considering there's no proof he did anything like that.
 
Last edited:
#24
Kaido was just walking around fucking people up in wars until he was recruited by Rocks at age 15. Mihawk, while he's likely not a natural born monster like Kaido or Big Mom, is probably the same.
He doesn't really need a crew to do these things, he's just always been at the right level of strength to survive on his own.
The difference being you're filling a gap you don't know about when we know Kaido had to rely on things like other people taking him places or feeding him (the marines). Was he his own navigator? Who was taking him from place to place?

There is a lack of proof that Mihawk has roamed the seas freely and without relying on anyone else prior to the way he's been currently portrayed. Yes, as a warlord, he roamed by himself, but would he still do that without the protection of the marines? He commented on how he had to move and be chased after he lost his status. For a guy who is supposedly unafraid of everybody, that's kind of odd. He also shirked at the idea of competing against people like Straw Hat Luffy and Red Hair (Shanks). So, if he's supposed to be posturing, he isn't doing it well.
 
Last edited:
#26
He would be contending with who? Whitebeard, Roger, Kaido, Big Mom, and other people like them
These are people who are entirely stationed in the new world… Mihawk is stated to have traveled AROUND THE ENTIRE WORLD

Why do you think it’s impossible for him to have done this himself?

but would he still do that without the protection of the marines?
the marines didn’t give him protection, what the fuck are you talking about?

his deal with the marines is that they don’t disturb him.

Obviously, why would he randomly decide to be a pirate instead of just being a swordsman who follows the law?
his goal is fight every swordsman that’s stronger than him… That includes Marine swordsmen and even holy knight swordsmen… And these are serious fights too, so if he kills the people he’s fighting then what will happen?
but would he still do that without the protection of the marines?
the marines didn’t give him protection, what the fuck are you talking about?

his deal with the marines is that they don’t disturb him.
 
Top