Powers & Abilities Was Trebol initially a logia?

[Eustass Captain Cream]

Hello Folks,

Usopp tryed to fight Trebol and succeeded to cut him into half (triple?) in Chapter 741. But the attack did no damage to Trebol and everyone tought it was because he is a logia.

Later we see he is just very skinny and got an Paramecia fruit. Did Oda just changed his Fruit type later on or did i miss something? Didnt see anyone mentioning it yet.

Its a bit sad as it would have been a good fight for Usopp.

 

[Germa66]

Probably. Same as Katakuri

 

[Garp the Fist]

Oda’s never explained what the hell actually happened here.

Special Paramecia’s might explain it

 

[NAMELESS]

Yep.That is a plot hole right there!

 

[Gorosei Informer]

Hello Folks,

Usopp tryed to fight Trebol and succeeded to cut him into half (triple?) in Chapter 741. But the attack did no damage to Trebol and everyone tought it was because he is a logia.

Later we see he is just very skinny and got an Paramecia fruit. Did Oda just changed his Fruit type later on or did i miss something? Didnt see anyone mentioning it yet.

Its a bit sad as it would have been a good fight for Usopp.

A very similar problem happened with Katakuri, I think when it was Jinbei vs him at the tea party where in the manga, Jinbei refers to him as a Logia but then it was "fixed" for the volume release to say he's a "Special Paramecia" instead?

This whole thing with Trebol also really bothered me and I agree, he should have been an actual fight for Usopp. I think Robin had difficult with his DF too or so?

 

[Jailer]

Retcon happened

 

[PurpleSwordsman]

It's more like Oda wanted us readers to think that he was a logia and that's why we later had that dialogue with Luffy.
We readers were as surprised as Luffy when he used Haki and didn't hurt him and asked why.

But it'll be weird if he did it only for this.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Trebol was probably a Logia but then retconned into a paramecia like Katakuri.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

I stopped thinking about Trebol the second Dressrosa ended, so this is an incredible catch…from now on, I’m an #UsoppKilledTrebol diehard

 

[Finalbeta]

Trebol was probably a Logia but then retconned into a paramecia like Katakuri.

You think the same occurred with Magellan and a few others perhaps? I'm not that confident honestly.

 

[Nel-Zel fiasco]

trebol got retconned like katakuri ?! gonna reread again

 

[sanjikun]

I always thought he just moved his entire body to the top half. He had CoO to spot Usopp's attack.

Might be a Katakuri scenario though.

 

[NAMELESS]

I always thought he just moved his entire body to the top half. He had CoO to spot Usopp's attack.

Might be a Katakuri scenario though.

It could be case,but his body is a bit too long to fit that little space!
This looks like a plot hole to me!

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

Hello Folks,

Usopp tryed to fight Trebol and succeeded to cut him into half (triple?) in Chapter 741. But the attack did no damage to Trebol and everyone tought it was because he is a logia.

Later we see he is just very skinny and got an Paramecia fruit. Did Oda just changed his Fruit type later on or did i miss something? Didnt see anyone mentioning it yet.

Its a bit sad as it would have been a good fight for Usopp.

Yes
Many actually made a meme about it LOL

 

[sanjikun]

It could be case,but his body is a bit too long to fit that little space!
This looks like a plot hole to me!

It reminded me of these magic tricks

 

[Gorosei Informer]

You think the same occurred with Magellan and a few others perhaps? I'm not that confident honestly.

I definitely believe it happened with Magellan, whether it was prior to his introduction in the manga or not or at least in the anime? Him being a Paramecia never settled well with me and it led to one of the most stupidest and aborrent gags, character flaws and ways to nerf a character imo.

 

[Salah WG]

Yes, i always thought about that Scene, it can be kinda justified by saying Trebol jumped but that's really far-fetched
I think it was clearly drawn in a way that Trebol is a Logia & there is no Body hiding inside

I think the reason Oda made both Trebol & Katakuri's DFs Paramecia is because of Logia DF Origin
I think he found out that the Origin Story for DFs he created doesn't justify Mochi & Trebol's Sticky Substance as Logia & must be Paramecia

 

[Roronoa-sama]

trebor is the kata rival
@Echizen_Jo_Ndule

 

[Finalbeta]

I definitely believe it happened with Magellan, whether it was prior to his introduction in the manga or not or at least in the anime? Him being a Paramecia never settled well with me and it led to one of the most stupidest and aborrent gags, character flaws and ways to nerf a character imo.

Well he looks so deeply rooted as a logia!

The first time I spotted him I was almost sure he would have been unraveled as one but Goda sensei surprised me at that ancient age.

 

[Gorosei Informer]

Well he looks so deeply rooted as a logia!

The first time I spotted him I was almost sure he would have been unraveled as one but Goda sensei surprised me at that ancient age.

Yeah it was really weird but I guess making him a Paramecia was a way to nerf him, due to the issues with Crocodile and Enel previously? But idk, he felt like a Logia or even in hindsight an "awakened Paramecia", I think when he used Venom Demon? I remember having those thoughts/feelings at that time, but it's been ages since I've seen Impel Down.