General & Others Was Whitebeard the Winner or Loser during the Golden Era?

[Desa]

I think Whitebeard didnt play. So he wasnt a winner or loser.

But I also demonte him from beint at Roger level since we learn Roger's actual rival was Rock. So Whitebeard was just a bystander he fought from time to time.

 

[Xlaw]

He never wanted to become pirate king and successfully prevent other yanko to become PK . So he was winner

 

[MonsterKaido]

loser who ducked waido

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

winner
he stood above the rest
he accomplished his dream

 

[Finalbeta]

Who can someone legitimately believe that Papazuki stands out as a loser is beyond me

 

[MonsterKaido]

He is neither a winner nor a loser depending on what your definition of success is

No one was able to topple him that is a plus but he himself stayed outside most of conflicts

It's neutral I will say

 

[ranady]

He is a Chad.

 

[York]

Can't lose a game you weren't playing

 

[Finalbeta]

He is neither a winner nor a loser depending on what your definition of success is

No one was able to topple him that is a plus but he himself stayed outside most of conflicts

It's neutral I will say

If it's for the avenging Oden matter he did well not to go because he could have had some of his sons lose their lives