Lot of smooth brained people keep criticizing Garp for not leaving the Marines after what he witnessed and do God Valley.
They never care about what will happen if he actually quit Marines.
He can become a pirate and try to actively challenge the WG, which Rocks already tried but failed spectacularly, which means Garp has no chance either, to remind you, Rocks has more knowledge on how to take down Imu than anyone else we have seen till that point. Heck, even Joyboy failed to do it.
Marines will be objectively worse as an organisation if Garp is not in it and try to Groom the next generation into proper guardians of Justice.
VAs seems to get a Battleship of their own and some crew he can chose to man the ship(I don't know it for a fact).
He took some people who can do evil shit bad putting them to good use.
You can't use posthawk justification on why Garp didn't create Revolutionaries, cause they didn't exist till that point and there was no concept of it before Dragon. Lot of people don't have ground breaking Ideas like the Geniuses here on the forum who has more knowledge than any single person in the story.
People can't think of everything. There was an interview where some one asked "Why didn't Newton think of this?" upon learning more about Lagrangian and Hamiltonian Mechanics, and the answer given was "No one could think of everything".
Even Rocks suggested Garp is better off as Pirate, which cements that there was no other faction Garp could chose.
If you take away all good people from Marines, you just made a worse system to fight against. You get people like Greenbull to just run the show.
Also Garp's training is what made Aokiji as powerful as he is and his directions, and we have no proof he would have ever have his fruit without him being on the Marines.
Also Aokiji is the reason Nico Robin lives. If Sakazuki had seen her, she would have been dead. Tashigi wouldn't be able to show the path to Mausoleum to Alabasta in Luffy. If Kuma never joined the WG, Strawhats would have been dead in New World or even in Saboady.
Think of damage people like Nezumi did to Nami's Village, Now replace every marine with someone of his mentality and see how world is better for it.
They never care about what will happen if he actually quit Marines.
He can become a pirate and try to actively challenge the WG, which Rocks already tried but failed spectacularly, which means Garp has no chance either, to remind you, Rocks has more knowledge on how to take down Imu than anyone else we have seen till that point. Heck, even Joyboy failed to do it.
Marines will be objectively worse as an organisation if Garp is not in it and try to Groom the next generation into proper guardians of Justice.
VAs seems to get a Battleship of their own and some crew he can chose to man the ship(I don't know it for a fact).
He took some people who can do evil shit bad putting them to good use.
You can't use posthawk justification on why Garp didn't create Revolutionaries, cause they didn't exist till that point and there was no concept of it before Dragon. Lot of people don't have ground breaking Ideas like the Geniuses here on the forum who has more knowledge than any single person in the story.
People can't think of everything. There was an interview where some one asked "Why didn't Newton think of this?" upon learning more about Lagrangian and Hamiltonian Mechanics, and the answer given was "No one could think of everything".
Even Rocks suggested Garp is better off as Pirate, which cements that there was no other faction Garp could chose.
If you take away all good people from Marines, you just made a worse system to fight against. You get people like Greenbull to just run the show.
Also Garp's training is what made Aokiji as powerful as he is and his directions, and we have no proof he would have ever have his fruit without him being on the Marines.
Also Aokiji is the reason Nico Robin lives. If Sakazuki had seen her, she would have been dead. Tashigi wouldn't be able to show the path to Mausoleum to Alabasta in Luffy. If Kuma never joined the WG, Strawhats would have been dead in New World or even in Saboady.
Think of damage people like Nezumi did to Nami's Village, Now replace every marine with someone of his mentality and see how world is better for it.
