General & Others What Post-TS does better than Pre-TS

#1
So a lot of people nowadays complain about post-ts and praise pre-ts to high levels. I am not going to argue with those people because everyone is entitled to their opinion and I won't take sides but instead I will point out some things which Post-TS doesn't get enough praise for. It's mainly 2 things, but they are very important, at least to me:
  1. Villains are more fleshed out: Crocodile and Enel were great villains, but we hardly got any backstory for them, Crocodile was just a underground boss who tried to take over a powerful country, Enel was just a random dude who ate a broken DF and became so strong, he declared himself god. Then we had Arlong and Moria, whose backstories were fleshed out after their respective arcs. Lucci and CP9 were rather simple villains, just agents of the world goverment with no real will of their own. On the other hand, Doflamingo, Katakuri, Big Mom and soon Kaido, all have a backstory that establishes their character and each of them is so different from another. And no. I don't consider Blackbeard and Akainu pre-ts villains because they were not defeated yet.
  2. Arcs are more unpredictable: Many people have critised Oda for being too formulaic sometimes and it was true. With the exception of Sabaody/Impel Down/Marineford, every arc was basically the same. The strawhats enter an island, the island is ruled by some evil boss and his crew, the strawhats fight and win all of their 1 on 1's and then Luffy wins in the end. In Post-TS, with the exception of FI, every arc has been completely different, in Punk Hazard only Law, Luffy and Zoro get to actually fight, with Law defeating the endboss of the fight, Dressrosa we get the seperation of the strawhats and the SH-fleet, WCI we got possibly the greatest fight of the series, which we didn't know we would get halfway into the arc. No one at this point even knows how Wano will end.
What do you guys think?
 
#3
Comedy:more gags and hilarious stuff in serious situation!
Pacing:less side characters get flashbacks,etc...
Straw Hat interactions:almost all arcs were about SHP vs arc antagonist!
Pre time skip felt like a group of friends going on an adventure!
Post time skip feels like it is Luffy vs the World!
 

Doggo

Talent is something you make bloom.
#12
So a lot of people nowadays complain about post-ts and praise pre-ts to high levels. I am not going to argue with those people because everyone is entitled to their opinion and I won't take sides but instead I will point out some things which Post-TS doesn't get enough praise for. It's mainly 2 things, but they are very important, at least to me:
  1. Villains are more fleshed out: Crocodile and Enel were great villains, but we hardly got any backstory for them, Crocodile was just a underground boss who tried to take over a powerful country, Enel was just a random dude who ate a broken DF and became so strong, he declared himself god. Then we had Arlong and Moria, whose backstories were fleshed out after their respective arcs. Lucci and CP9 were rather simple villains, just agents of the world goverment with no real will of their own. On the other hand, Doflamingo, Katakuri, Big Mom and soon Kaido, all have a backstory that establishes their character and each of them is so different from another. And no. I don't consider Blackbeard and Akainu pre-ts villains because they were not defeated yet.
  2. Arcs are more unpredictable: Many people have critised Oda for being too formulaic sometimes and it was true. With the exception of Sabaody/Impel Down/Marineford, every arc was basically the same. The strawhats enter an island, the island is ruled by some evil boss and his crew, the strawhats fight and win all of their 1 on 1's and then Luffy wins in the end. In Post-TS, with the exception of FI, every arc has been completely different, in Punk Hazard only Law, Luffy and Zoro get to actually fight, with Law defeating the endboss of the fight, Dressrosa we get the seperation of the strawhats and the SH-fleet, WCI we got possibly the greatest fight of the series, which we didn't know we would get halfway into the arc. No one at this point even knows how Wano will end.
What do you guys think?
Your point 2 makes no sense.
The arcs follow the same structure of "reach some new place. get separated at some point. fight some enemies. get together. make a plan. plan fails, fights, luffy loses, then luffy wins". Sometimes a "side character" gets a fight. It was like this on Pre-TS, and it's still like this on Post-TS. Just because on PH "not all SH's fight", it doesn't break the formula at all, lol.
 
Last edited:
C

Cuistot

#18
Doflamingo is the best villain from the timeskip, and even then i can't shake off how similar he is to Crocodile. People aren't saying it's become formulaic for naught.
 
#20
I love, LOVE One Piece. Both pre and post TS. But since the TS, Oda has been doing Sanji dirty. He's been wanking Zoro endlessly (which he deserves, I also love him) and making Sanji look bad, like, every arc. Finally He's getting cool moments in Wano.
 
Top