General & Others Which Fight is Better? Luffy Vs Doflamingo or Sanji Vs Queen

[pg13]

Manga Perspective Only

A lot of Controversy with both of these fights, The Doflamingo fight is criticized due to pacing and the interruptions between it. The 10 minutes luffy needed that lasted about 5 chapters. And the somewhat anticlimactic ending.

Sanji Vs Queen gets criticized for being to short, and having an anticlimactic ending.

But Since Sanji Vs Queen smoked Luffy Vs Cracker I am curious to see how it compares .

But Overall Which one is the better fight?

Spoiler: LUFFY VS DOFLAMINGO

Spoiler: SANJI VS QUEEN

 

[spawn]

There's pretty much nothing good about the Sanji fight.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Luffy versus Doffy. It’s not a sweep but Doffy had more charisma and an entire arc to build him up. Queen was…

Laser beam laser beam laser beam laser beam

until the last chapter. Choreography was not with this fight. The message for Sanji was top notch and Queen representing Sanji’s Germa animosity was great though. It’s what brings this close alongside Queen’s lovely personality

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Choreography goes to Luffy vs Doffy. Narrative goes to Sanji vs Queen.

There's pretty much nothing good about the Sanji fight.

Or you're just a hater.

 

[radiant07]

Sanji had decent moments in that fight but overall the fight was not horrible mostly cause of Queen. Luffy's fight negs.

 

[Julius]

Luffy vs Doflamingo's fight is all over the place, feels weird, lots of characters involved here and there, Doflamingo even used Bellamy to make Luffy holdback

Atleast Sanji vs Queen is a clear 1vs1 with established plots that actually makes sense

Luffy vs Doflamingo is literallly Oda making Luffy do what Law should be doing because Luffy is the main character

Although Luffy vs Doflamingo got a better choreography, which isn't hard, since Sanji is a martial artist and Queen is a brachiossaurus Cyborg. If you compare that fight to Sanji's past fights and clashes you realize how much different it feelsa, although chapter 1034 was really good, it shouldn't have ended the fight there but expand to one more chapter atleast

It's quite hard to top the main character's fights anyway, for obvious reasons

 

[Finalbeta]

Luffy vs Doffy was more enthusing and well structured if I had to pick one.

 

[BlackLegFring]

The random prostitute and mouse inclusion in the Sanji fight is one of the worst moments in the entire manga.
Sanji may be my favourite character, but that goddamn moment is just so…

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Luffy vs doffy had an awesome theming of freedom vs oppression between two amazing characters. Although Sanji vs Queen had a really cool narrative, the fight was an interior struggle and the exterior choreography was lacking.

I love Luffy vs doffy theming and characters a lot and think it’s one of the best.

 

[Jackteo]

It's difficult to even consider Sanji vs Queen as a fight.

 

[Kiku]

Voted for Sanji vs Queen. It was short and fun, neither of which apply to Luffy vs Doflamingo. As soon as Law dropped out of the Duffy fight it was a slog

 

[zenox]

doffy and luffy clashing alone soloes sanji vs queen

 

[IsaziSempi]

Sanji vs Queen had less plot holes. We waited for the doflamingo fight for decades and we didn't get what we wanted. He didn't even turn one of Luffy's crew into puppets.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

How dare you compare the Doffy fight to Queen fight? Queen fight is a joke...

 

[ShootaBoy]

Luffy vs Flamingo. The problem with that fight is that Toei shitted so hard on it. If the animated fight had quality, it would've been the best fight post-time skip.

 

[Midnight Delight]

Doflamingo vs Luffy mainly suffered from an important part being skipped.

Sanji vs Queen suffered from Queen's Moveset being ill fitted for a Sanji fight

 

[Finalbeta]

Liffy vs Doffy was plenty of pathos and twists :cheers:

Sanji Vs Queen too but it felt less hypey to me