General & Others Which Justice do you correspond with?!
- Thread starter Xione
- Start date
Issho's. He tows the line between order and freedom, something I think the story has been leaning towards, given it presents extremes of order and freedom in a negative light; being Sakazuki and Teach.
Issho, and other like minded marines such as Smoker and Tashigi, harbor a justice that seeks to do the morally right thing rather than following indoctrinated mantra of justice that is "Absolute Justice". It's rather inconsistent in its practice, as Sakazuki and other marines who follow Absolute Justice would rather sweep their shortcomings and inner corruption under the bus, not actually addressing it, and expect the populace and their ranks to comply. It becomes less about justice and more about control.
Issho, and other like minded marines such as Smoker and Tashigi, harbor a justice that seeks to do the morally right thing rather than following indoctrinated mantra of justice that is "Absolute Justice". It's rather inconsistent in its practice, as Sakazuki and other marines who follow Absolute Justice would rather sweep their shortcomings and inner corruption under the bus, not actually addressing it, and expect the populace and their ranks to comply. It becomes less about justice and more about control.
Honestly, my justice is a cocktail of everyone Lol
Sometimes Absolute, sometimes Blind justice, sometimes Lazy Justice and so on
I just don't believe that we have found a form of justice that is complete... I think that shit depends on:
- What situation you are dealing with, how serious the crime is, what casualties/harm does it cause?
- Who are you dealing with? Is it someone repeatedly causing problems? What are the motivations of that person? What ambitions he has?
And you can include MANY Factorsas well
I don't think Justice is a term that has an absolute right path for it all the time... I think that stuff can change depending on all kinds of factor...
I'll give you a small example just to clarify the difference:
- Stealing in general is a crime, that should be punished with imprisoning the thief...
- During the end of Arlong Park arc, we have Nami steal the wallets of her town folks when she's about to join the crew, if you asked the towns folk, they would NEVER consider it a crime in that instant to be imprisoned
This is just an example to clarify what I mean by different situations have different decisions to make
Similarly, sometimes, it calls for absolute harsh justice, some other situations calls for more merciful justice, and so on... it's never always clear
Sometimes Absolute, sometimes Blind justice, sometimes Lazy Justice and so on
I just don't believe that we have found a form of justice that is complete... I think that shit depends on:
- What situation you are dealing with, how serious the crime is, what casualties/harm does it cause?
- Who are you dealing with? Is it someone repeatedly causing problems? What are the motivations of that person? What ambitions he has?
And you can include MANY Factorsas well
I don't think Justice is a term that has an absolute right path for it all the time... I think that stuff can change depending on all kinds of factor...
I'll give you a small example just to clarify the difference:
- Stealing in general is a crime, that should be punished with imprisoning the thief...
- During the end of Arlong Park arc, we have Nami steal the wallets of her town folks when she's about to join the crew, if you asked the towns folk, they would NEVER consider it a crime in that instant to be imprisoned
This is just an example to clarify what I mean by different situations have different decisions to make
Similarly, sometimes, it calls for absolute harsh justice, some other situations calls for more merciful justice, and so on... it's never always clear
Combine Sakazuki's efficiency + Issho's morality = Perfect Justice.
Issho's insight is better and his decisions are more beneficial in the long run (warlord abolishment proved to be the right decision fot the world) but sometimes you just feel too satisfied with how Sakazuki relentlessly annihilates threats to get the job done in time.
Issho's insight is better and his decisions are more beneficial in the long run (warlord abolishment proved to be the right decision fot the world) but sometimes you just feel too satisfied with how Sakazuki relentlessly annihilates threats to get the job done in time.