Questions & Mysteries Which punch satisfied you more?

[Erkan12]

I couldn't decide.

Stylisticly they are very similar. Both are right handed enraged punches from behind.

Enraged Quake Bubble by half dead Yonko Whitebeard;

Enraged G3 Red Rock by Fifth Yonko Luffy;

Akainu's face;

Kaido's face;

 

[Jo_Ndule]

quake punch on Akainu felt satisfying

 

[GeneralP123]

Akainu is a bigger douchebag, so that punch felt quite a bit better

 

[BangOO🍅]

Whitebeard satisfied more especially because after Akainu killed Ace

 

[MarineHQ]

Quake punch on Akainu for sure

 

[Luffy bin Dragon]

Akainu punch

 

[Erkan12]

Let's defend Akainu (you see I am not hater, power level discussions are different)

Akainu wasn't actually trying to kill Ace, He actually tried to kill Luffy, but Ace gave his life for Luffy. It was accidental, and Akainu was doing his job as a marine. Kaido on the other hand, used hostage to win.

 

[MarineHQ]

Let's defend Akainu (you see I am not hater, power level discussions are different)

Akainu wasn't actually trying to kill Ace, He actually tried to kill Luffy, but Ace gave his life for Luffy. It was accidental, and Akainu was doing his job as a marine.

Akainu wanted to show Ace his little brothers death before he dies which is actually even more fucked up than killing Ace straight up which made that punch even more satisfying

 

[Luffy bin Dragon]

Akainu wanted to show Ace his little brothers death before he dies which is actually even more fucked up than killing Ace straight up which made that punch even more satisfying

He was doing his job there are way more fucked up case in the us military in iraq and other places

 

[Ballel]

He was doing his job there are way more fucked up case in the us military in iraq and other places

But this manga is still targeted at young teens so it has to maintain a certain child-friendliness level.
Akainu is still an ass.
For me Whitebeard's punch is more satisfying.

 

[Mr. Tuna Sandwich]

Crydo punch, put all the Crydotrads in their place

 

[Ballel]

Crydo punch, put all the Crydotrads in their place

God your avy

 

[Mr. Tuna Sandwich]

God your avy

I see you like this work of art hmmm...:laughmoji:

 

[Ballel]

Let's defend Akainu (you see I am not hater, power level discussions are different)

Akainu wasn't actually trying to kill Ace, He actually tried to kill Luffy, but Ace gave his life for Luffy. It was accidental, and Akainu was doing his job as a marine. Kaido on the other hand, used hostage to win.

They wanted to kill Ace in the first place, he was about to be executed.

 

[Finalbeta]

Not sure why this was set as a contest.

Whitebeard's wins hands down by a billion light-years. It's not anywhere close.

The hype was superior, the sheer power of the strike, the emotion of the moment, Ace had just died I mean.

 

[Steven]

Akainu getting humiliated was way better

 

[Erkan12]

Sure you can feel bad for Ace, if you don't think Akainu actually went for Luffy first, even though Ace attacked Akainu first, despite the fact he needed to run at that moment, it was kind of Ace's stupidity but Ace still sacrificed himself for Luffy willingly, and Akainu was doing his job as a marine.

But how about Oden? Oden died after turning into a clown because Kaido used hostage What about the things that the mink tribe has suffered? Torture, losing limbs etc.? And what about Yasuie? He died too. Killer turned into a clown because of being a pleasure. And the samurai? After all the things that they suffered, they even get beaten up to pulp by Kaido in the end.

 

[KiriNigiri]

I frankly found Sakazuki tanking Newgate's blow more impressive than the blow itself.

 

[Robin swan]

Quake punch wb more memorable...imo red rock not gonna be memorable especially once luffy starts using g4 on hybrid kaido. Imo king kong gun is still better.

 

[ShishioIsBack]

Whitebeard was better emotional moment, by far.

Luffys punch was better flex