Questions & Mysteries Whitebeard couldve win during the paramount war?

[Master Of All Arts]

What ifs are pretty useless. I don't know why people put Whitebeard on such a pedestal. Yes, he was the strongest man, but its extremely ignorant imo if you think that Whitebeard is gonna come out on top against both Garp and Sengoku. Those two are about the same age as Whitebeard and weren't sick, they would hold their own against him even if it was a 1v1. That's not even mentioning the 3 admirals that were there. That's simply not something a single crew, even a yonko's, can match up against. And for those who think he can just sink the island, he can't. He'll drown and die.

And I don't even wanna hear about that "If he didn't get stabbed, admirals wouldn't be able to touch him". If you think any yonko is coming out without a scratch against a full on fight against an admiral then I don't know what to tell you. Its kinda funny how bias people are with what happened with Whitebeard vs Admirals. Despite multiple clashes, the only time Whitebeard did damage to an admiral was when he sneak attacked Akainu. SNEAK ATTACK. The one thing people clowned Kaido on so much in his fight against Oden.

 

[Xlaw]

Bah...people need to open their small eyes wide and should read manga again...
After overpowering Ace , Luffy was in range of Akainu's attack and was ready to make hole in Luffy's chest.
That killing blow was intended toward Luffy but Ace sacrificed himself...

The end result might have the same in all scenario , Luffy encountered Aokiji , Sengoku , Akainu and Kizaru and still survived , which is demonic luck...
Ace had to die in his place...
So stop fucking downgrading Ace for dying in Luffy's place.

 

[Formerly Seth]

It depends on what you count as a W during the paramount war here.

Looking at the objective Whitebeard Fleet set for themselves they secured a W, well at least before Ace decided to sacrifice everyone's effort and everything for his retarded pride.

If you are talking about the W from a battle standpoint I would argue if healthy or even Prime Whitebeard would do something there.

Remember the more dangerous/active Whitebeard would be the more attention he would have from the Admirals. I don't believe Whitebeard could take on let's say for example Garp, Sengoku, Aokiji, Kizaru at the same time ( assuming that Akainu would keep Whitebeard's commander at bay ).

 

[Xlaw]

About wining war without getting stabbed in chest ! He could have managed to free Ace but I don't see WB winning this war . Except if another yanko had helped him..

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Bah...people need to open their small eyes wide and should read manga again...
After overpowering Ace , Luffy was in range of Akainu's attack and was ready to make hole in Luffy's chest.
That killing blow was intended toward Luffy but Ace sacrificed himself...

The end result might have the same in all scenario , Luffy encountered Aokiji , Sengoku , Akainu and Kizaru and still survived , which is demonic luck...
Ace had to die in his place...
So stop fucking downgrading Ace for dying in Luffy's place.

Ace is a dumbass who die because he's dum-dum
Pleb

 

[BidaPowersTV]

What ifs are pretty useless. I don't know why people put Whitebeard on such a pedestal. Yes, he was the strongest man, but its extremely ignorant imo if you think that Whitebeard is gonna come out on top against both Garp and Sengoku. Those two are about the same age as Whitebeard and weren't sick, they would hold their own against him even if it was a 1v1. That's not even mentioning the 3 admirals that were there. That's simply not something a single crew, even a yonko's, can match up against. And for those who think he can just sink the island, he can't. He'll drown and die.

And I don't even wanna hear about that "If he didn't get stabbed, admirals wouldn't be able to touch him". If you think any yonko is coming out without a scratch against a full on fight against an admiral then I don't know what to tell you. Its kinda funny how bias people are with what happened with Whitebeard vs Admirals. Despite multiple clashes, the only time Whitebeard did damage to an admiral was when he sneak attacked Akainu. SNEAK ATTACK. The one thing people clowned Kaido on so much in his fight against Oden.

Did you even saw how gura gura no mi can hold up akainu’s power? Thats not what if bruh im just stating the fact that he can hold on to even magma.

Post automatically merged: Jan 12, 2021

It depends on what you count as a W during the paramount war here.

Looking at the objective Whitebeard Fleet set for themselves they secured a W, well at least before Ace decided to sacrifice everyone's effort and everything for his retarded pride.

If you are talking about the W from a battle standpoint I would argue if healthy or even Prime Whitebeard would do something there.

Remember the more dangerous/active Whitebeard would be the more attention he would have from the Admirals. I don't believe Whitebeard could take on let's say for example Garp, Sengoku, Aokiji, Kizaru at the same time ( assuming that Akainu would keep Whitebeard's commander at bay ).

yeah thats why the win over there is that if squardo didnt wounded whitebeard he couldve did a lot more than he did in fact he could even stop akainu from chasing ace or more

he didnt died because of pride, ace died protecting luffy. He died for others thats a self sacrifice the ultimate sacrifice thats what religion calls it.

 

[Midnight Delight]

Arguably if Squardo didn't stab him he probably wouldn't have had his health decline as badly as it did

But at the same time as Marco remarked, his Health was already badly declining, the fact that Squardo managed to hit him in the first place was proof. I don't think he could have fought a Top tier for too long before this weakness would have been exposed

 

[BidaPowersTV]

Arguably if Squardo didn't stab him he probably wouldn't have had his health decline as badly as it did

But at the same time as Marco remarked, his Health was already badly declining, the fact that Squardo managed to hit him in the first place was proof. I don't think he could have fought a Top tier for too long before this weakness would have been exposed

but like i said that wound change everything, whitebeard that if that didnt happen probably he wouldnt have hit by akainu. What akainu did was death blow whitebeard suppose to be dead its just his spirit is so strong that he did the unimaginable

 

[drdreambo]

Most def not, they got bodied super bad...

 

[Erkan12]

Whitebeard was always going to die, he constantly needed serums to live. Once he removed the serums, the heart attack could happen anytime, which means even fodders can stab you and shoot you with bazooka in the head. Whitebeard knew that as well, which is why he wanted to trade his life with Ace's.

Ace could survive, but who cares? He never listened Whitebeard's words, and got rekted by Blackbeard. If Whitebeard didn't beat him, Kaido was going to stomp him as well, he could never be a top-tier with that attitude even if he survived the war.