Controversial Who had the most justified reason to become a villain

[Shiroyru]

Does Katakuri count as a villain? If so, him

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Does Katakuri count as a villain? If so, him

He's not a villain. He just want to protect his family from threats.

 

[Roo]

Doffy was always a horrible person. I feel like some of you guys totally missed the point of his backstory

 

[Shiroyru]

He's not a villain. He just want to protect his family from threats.

I mean he did just straight up murder 3 chefs because they accidentally saw him during his Merienda

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

I mean he did just straight up murder 3 chefs because they accidentally saw him during his Merienda

That's not really villainous. That's just privacy issue.

 

[Shiroyru]

That's not really villainous. That's just privacy issue.

Lmao murdering 3 people isn’t villainous? Bruh

 

[Juanpiz]

I mean he did just straight up murder 3 chefs because they accidentally saw him during his Merienda

Apart from his evil boss

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

I mean he did just straight up murder 3 chefs because they accidentally saw him during his Merienda

This is One Piece, maybe they were just sent to the hospital

 

[Garp the Fist]

Arlong.

Doflamingo was born an irredeemable piece of shit. If he stayed in Mariejois he’d have been an enthusiastic God’s Knight.

 

[Shiroyru]

Arlong.

Doflamingo was born an irredeemable piece of shit. If he stayed in Mariejois he’d have been an enthusiastic God’s Knight.

Nah. Doffy’s too weak to be a Holy Knight

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Arlong, Robin, but not Doflamingo. The circumstances of his life didn't turn him evil, he literally has a brother who went through the same and turned out the opposite.

 

[Rumble]

Sanji.

Sanji is one of my favourite characters and he certainly had his reasons to turn evil, but he also had a loving mother and father.

Not both at the same time, but he had adults in his life that raised, nurtured, loved and protected him.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Sanji is one of my favourite characters and he certainly had this reasons, but he also had a loving mother and father.

Not both at the same time, but he had adults in his life that raised, nurtured, loved and protected him.

I meant it as sarcasm for Sanji leaving the Strawhats in Whole Cake Island and becoming a "villain".

But I agree with what you said.

 

[rerere]

Doffy was always a horrible person. I feel like some of you guys totally missed the point of his backstory

How much of Doflamingo's actions are a product of his nature and how much a product of his nurture is something Oda intentionally kept vague and up for debate.
It's the reason why he's the best villain of the serie by a good margin and also the reason why it's still a good topic almost a decade after his Arc.

 

[Juanpiz]

How much of Doflamingo's actions are a product of his nature and how much a product of his nurture is something Oda intentionally kept vague and up for debate.
It's the reason why he's the best villain of the serie by a good margin and also the reason why it's still a good topic almost a decade after his Arc.

According to his own bro he always was like this

 

[Sir Yasheen]

How much of Doflamingo's actions are a product of his nature and how much a product of his nurture is something Oda intentionally kept vague and up for debate.
It's the reason why he's the best villain of the serie by a good margin and also the reason why it's still a good topic almost a decade after his Arc.

Literally all nature. Corazon is living proof of that. It’s not vague at all it’s stated in black and white Doffy was an evil child despite his family’s best efforts.

I don’t know how anyone can read Doffys flashback and think he was a tragic tale who would’ve turned out any different

 

[PeronaNerona]

Doffy's dad was a weapon's-grade retard. Maybe go down to the surface by yourself to see what it's like before destroying your entire family ? Send them a postcard or something.

 

[Juanpiz]

Literally all nature. Corazon is living proof of that. It’s not vague at all it’s stated in black and white Doffy was an evil child despite his family’s best efforts.

I don’t know how anyone can read Doffys flashback and think he was a tragic tale who would’ve turned out any different

Somewhat tragic bc the citizens choose him and his family to get revenge bc they were the only touchable Celestial Dragons

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Somewhat tragic bc the citizens choose him and his family to get revenge bc they were the only touchable Celestial Dragons

And when that happened there was no change in Doffy. He double downed on his evil nature. He was the same before and after that vengeance. Doffy was literally just evil and always would’ve been

 

[Peroroncino]

Me