Questions & Mysteries Why did Kaido place Shanks alongside the 4 people who’ve defeated him?

Fujishiro

Love is a painful illusion
Literally everything points he's stronger than all the swordsman.

Black blade is the peak.

WB still used a supreme grade blade and Hakk with it too. Where's the Black blade?
Whats this everything you speak off? ''Muh black blade?'' something we know very little about except that its the peak of swordsmanship? What else points towards him being stronger then all other swordsmen in history?

Mihawk is the strongest swordsman, Whitebeard isnt a swordsman. Whitebeard was the WSM, Mihawk is a man.

Or is he not? Is he an alien?
Good luck with this guy, nothing gets through to him:milaugh:
I am aware, Im just bored though.
 
C

Cruxroux

Whats this everything you speak off?
His title , his potrayal , everytime called superior than shanks.


''Muh black blade?'' something we know very little about except that its the peak of swordsmanship?
Lmao you yourself know , it's peak and refuse to accept it when it comes to mihawk , hypocrite activity isn't it lmao.


What else points towards him being stronger then all other swordsmen in history?
3.6 B bounty , been called the strongest and sits at the top of all swordsman.
Only two black blade in existence , And Mihawk turned a superior grade into black blade compared to ryuma.


Mihawk is the strongest swordsman, Whitebeard isnt a swordsman. Whitebeard was the WSM, Mihawk is a man.

Or is he not? Is he an alien?
These title don't exist simuntaneously lmao.
He uses a supreme grade blade and haki.
What was stopping him from getting a black blade lol.

Or is he not? Is he an alien?
At his time he was called the strongest , then came kaido , then Mihawk.
It's as easy as that lmao.
If they existed at the same time , mihawk would have taken the title.
WB held the title even when he wasn't the strongest in marineford.


I am aware, Im just bored though.
Lmao ,
- no evidence to any of your point.
- never accepts anything canon , try to go for something which doesn't exist. Mihawk is superior to all swordsman , that's a canon fact , whatelse is there to prove it? It's literally said multiple times in canon language and yet you ask for more..... having a hard time acccepting a fact?
Bro thought he cooked something with not accepting given evidence and using doubt to cover it up with wb was called Man , is mihawk not a man 😂😂😂.

Ofc you're bored , you never have a valid point.
Post automatically merged:

Good luck with this guy, nothing gets through to him:milaugh:
Lmao how many L's you have taken so far 😂😂.
 

Fujishiro

Love is a painful illusion
At his time he was called the strongest , then came kaido , then Mihawk.
.
Kaido was called the strongest in his prime, while Mihawk is also in his prime whats your answer to that?

These title don't exist simuntaneously lmao.
Its funny you say that yet try to apply Mihawks title to people who were long dead before he received it.

Fascinating hypocrisy.

- never accepts anything canon , try to go for something which doesn't exist. Mihawk is superior to all swordsman , that's a canon fact ,
Eh I do though? I accept Mihawks title, he is the world strongest swordsman and superior to all the current swordsmen. That is factual.

His title , his potrayal , everytime called superior than shanks.
Kaido is also portrayed superior than Shanks, well all pirates. But I also forgot you dont consider Mihawk to be a pirate because it doesnt fit your agenda.

If they existed at the same time , mihawk would have taken the title.
This is a baseless fanboy statement.
 
C

Cruxroux

Kaido was called the strongest in his prime, while Mihawk is also in his prime whats your answer to that?
Kaido is 57-59 year old.
That's not the prime.

In a year or two he would be under old legend category if he was alive.
Mihawk and shanks 39-41 , Is the peak.


Its funny you say that yet try to apply Mihawks title to people who were long dead before he received it.

Fascinating hypocrisy.
Says the one who knows black blade is peak yet none of the top tiers swordsman ever had it.

Eh I do though? I accept Mihawks title, he is the world strongest swordsman and superior to all the current swordsmen. That is factual.
Kaido ~> Shanks
And so is Mihawk.
Mihawk is the current strongest title holder.


Kaido is also portrayed superior than Shanks, well all pirates. But I also forgot you dont consider Mihawk to be a pirate because it doesnt fit your agenda.
Pirate game is a solo play , it's a team play.
Kaido probably had the biggest army when compared to counter parts.


This is a baseless fanboy statement.
His haki is the strongest amomg them , that's why Black bkade. It's as easy that to undsrstand.
 

Fujishiro

Love is a painful illusion
Kaido is 57-59 year old.
That's not the prime.
Said who?

In a year or two he would be under old legend category if he was alive.
Hes 2 years or so older then Akainu and Akainu is also in his prime.

Mihawk and shanks 39-41 , Is the peak.
Said who? BB is older then Shanks and still growing stronger and didnt reach his prime yet.


Says the one who knows black blade is peak yet none of the top tiers swordsman ever had it.
Muh black blade is the peak of swordsmanship nothing else that we know of so far.

Kaido ~> Shanks
And so is Mihawk.
Mihawk is the current strongest title holder.
If Kaido was > Shanks why cant he have been > Mihawk as well?

Mihawk is the strongest swordsman title holder, lets not give him a title he doesnt have.
Pirate game is a solo play , it's a team play.
Kaido probably had the biggest army when compared to counter parts.
Since when does strongest pirate mean strongest pirate crew lmao?


His haki is the strongest amomg them , that's why Black bkade. It's as easy that to undsrstand.
ACoC was introduced as the strongest haki type offensively. If forging a black blade requires COA mastery then its wholy irrelevant to ones complete strenght
 
Last edited:
Having a Black Blade definitely does not imply complete superiority to other swordsmen.
After all people like Katakuri have an Awakened df yet Luffy matched him without awakening his.
All having a Black Blade does is, at most, show that the man who forged it has a very high level of CoA.
 
Read the above and stick to what the manga tells you, nowhere in the manga is it stated that Shanks is superior to Kaido. Not a single instance of it.
Symbolically, there is.
Kaido defeated Kidd, but it Shanks who retired a stronger version of Kidd.

The fact that Kaido wanted to go to Marineford yet he didn't, and Shanks appeared without any wounds, means that Shanks made Kaido surrender instantly without putting any real fight.
Seeing what he did to Greenbull, yeah not farfetched to think he also wifi diffed Kaido.
 

Fujishiro

Love is a painful illusion
Symbolically, there is.
Kaido defeated Kidd, but it Shanks who retired a stronger version of Kidd.

The fact that Kaido wanted to go to Marineford yet he didn't, and Shanks appeared without any wounds, means that Shanks made Kaido surrender instantly without putting any real fight.
Seeing what he did to Greenbull, yeah not farfetched to think he also wifi diffed Kaido.
Topi bro, how have you been?
 
Symbolically, there is.
Kaido defeated Kidd, but it Shanks who retired a stronger version of Kidd.

The fact that Kaido wanted to go to Marineford yet he didn't, and Shanks appeared without any wounds, means that Shanks made Kaido surrender instantly without putting any real fight.
Seeing what he did to Greenbull, yeah not farfetched to think he also wifi diffed Kaido.
I think this would be mentioned by Kaidou or Shanks considering Kaidou is called the WSC and something like that happening would be a major contradiction to it.
 
I think this would be mentioned by Kaidou or Shanks considering Kaidou is called the WSC and something like that happening would be a major contradiction to it.
Kaido already mentioned it indirectly, by putting Shanks in that panel


Actually, the fact that Shanks in that panel is already adult Shanks (which looks exactly the same as Marineford Shanks) rather than child Shanks whom Kaido meet during God Valley, and then putting him in the pedestal, should tell you something already.
 
Kaido already mentioned it indirectly, by putting Shanks in that panel


Actually, the fact that Shanks in that panel is already adult Shanks (which looks exactly the same as Marineford Shanks) rather than child Shanks whom Kaido meet during God Valley, and then putting him in the pedestal, should tell you something already.
Shanks was a baby during god valley lol
 
Kaido met Shanks on his way to Marineford, Shanks intimidated Kaido so much that Kaido puts him into Top 5 Pedestal even after 2 years later.

While Shanks, who casually wifi diffed Greenbull, ending Kidd's career in single attack, doesn't think much about his encounter with Kaido.

What must be 1 of the biggest day in Kaido's lifetime, is just another day for Shanks.
Post automatically merged:

Shanks was a baby during god valley lol
Yeah, Kaido put Shanks in the panel not for God Valley incident.
He put Shanks in that panel because 2 years ago he got wifi diffed and intimidated so much he cancelled his trip to Marineford.
 
This has nothing to do with the thread topic that shanks defeated Kaido in the past. The narrative simply doesn't allows a scenario for that.
Shanks being stronger than Kaido means that it's responsible that Shanks had defeated Kaido in the past. Look I also use to believe Kaido was stronger than shanks but then Shanks one shotted Kid and killer and it became pretty obvious that Shanks is higher on the totem pole than Kaido
 
Kaido met Shanks on his way to Marineford, Shanks intimidated Kaido so much that Kaido puts him into Top 5 Pedestal even after 2 years later.

While Shanks, who casually wifi diffed Greenbull, ending Kidd's career in single attack, doesn't think much about his encounter with Kaido.

What must be 1 of the biggest day in Kaido's lifetime, is just another day for Shanks.
Post automatically merged:


Yeah, Kaido put Shanks in the panel not for God Valley incident.
He put Shanks in that panel because 2 years ago he got wifi diffed and intimidated so much he cancelled his trip to Marineford.
For a guy who causally has tea time with the Gorosei meeting a Yonko is another Tuesday
:milaugh:
 
Shanks being stronger than Kaido means that it's responsible that Shanks had defeated Kaido in the past. Look I also use to believe Kaido was stronger than shanks but then Shanks one shotted Kid and killer and it became pretty obvious that Shanks is higher on the totem pole than Kaido
Not at all. There was a small fight where no one win most likely. Had shanks defeated Kaido back then , he won't have the hype of one on one champ or his title of world's strongest which is based on his opinions about his power anyways. Why would the populace in general think Kaido is the strongest if he lost to shanks?
Post automatically merged:

Kaido met Shanks on his way to Marineford, Shanks intimidated Kaido so much that Kaido puts him into Top 5 Pedestal even after 2 years later.

While Shanks, who casually wifi diffed Greenbull, ending Kidd's career in single attack, doesn't think much about his encounter with Kaido.

What must be 1 of the biggest day in Kaido's lifetime, is just another day for Shanks.
Post automatically merged:


Yeah, Kaido put Shanks in the panel not for God Valley incident.
He put Shanks in that panel because 2 years ago he got wifi diffed and intimidated so much he cancelled his trip to Marineford.
Shanks only going for one piece after Kaido and BM are defeated says otherwise.
 
Shanks only going for one piece after Kaido and BM are defeated says otherwise.
Kaido the coward didn't even bother looking for One Piece and kept hiding in Wano. The moment he knew Big Mom was entering Wano only with half of her crew, he got really panicked but luckily King faced the problem alone. Kaido is a chicken wuss compared to King's pteranodon.
 
Kaido the coward didn't even bother looking for One Piece and kept hiding in Wano. The moment he knew Big Mom was entering Wano only with half of her crew, he got really panicked but luckily King faced the problem alone. Kaido is a chicken wuss compared to King's pteranodon.
Nah. Kaido was challenging yonko single handedly. Kaido was building his strength and he knows the main enemies are WG and he needs ancient weapons to beat them. On the other hand shanks only goes for one piece now that Waido is defeated. Hell shanks got scarred by a blackbeard who didn't had any DFs. Let that sink in lol.
 
Top