Speculations Why doesn't shanks eat a devil fruit

#1
So this is a topic I've been thinking about for quite some time.

Shanks, obviously, hates blackbeard. Shanks would likely stop at nothing to kill blackbeard. Hence, with blackbeard having two broken DFs, why doesn't shanks eat a DF of his own and give his crew DFs in order to even out the odds and possibly get the edge over the blackbeard pirates?

Is there something about DFs that we don't know about to where Shanks is utterly opposed to eating one? Another thing would be this, why couldn't shanks eat a DF, if only just to regain his arm back.

I don't care how strong 1 armed shanks is, 2 arms is always better than 1. Even if he can use a sword just fine with one arm, a second arm would allow him to possibly duel wield(as we saw Rayleigh do in the Oden flashback) or possibly even use a gun alongside his sword(like he does in some of the one piece video games).

Shanks is one of the most powerful men in one piece. With his connections to the gorosei as well as his shear influence in the new world, he could easily get his hands on almost any DF he chose to. So why doesn't shanks eat one?

Blackbeard is essentially like Xebec, but more dangerous. He wants to rule the world and I'm sure that shanks wants to stop him. If Blackbeard gained even more power, like if he for example ate a 3rd DF, I feel as if Shanks would have no other choice but to eat a DF in order to hope to rival him.

as for what DF he could eat, there are several options


I like the idea of him eating the sara sara no mi model axolotl in order to regain his arm(axolotls can regenerate limbs). This would not only preserve his fighting style but actually enhance it. Like I said, two arms are better than one.

another option would be, and I know some of you might not like this, the mera mera no mi. Oda has said in an interview that sabo will be in trouble next year in the manga. If sabo were to die, Shanks would be the best inheritor for the mera mera no mi.

The reason for this is that the mera mera no mi has been portrayed as the fruit which counters the will of the yami yami no mi. It is the light that counters the darkness(figuratively that is. In terms of actual superiority, the yami yami is obviously stronger). Ace obviously took on blackbeard and lost. Sabo has a rivalry with the blackbeard pirates, with him fighting burgess in Dressrosa; something that eventually led to blackbeard invading baltigo.

Given as Shanks has always sought to counter blackbeard, it would be symbolically perfect for him to be the final inheritor of the fruit. it also helps that he met ace and served under Ace's father for many years.

anyways what are your thoughts. Why doesn't shanks eat a DF? Could shanks eat a DF in the future? And if so, what power would he eat?
 
#2
Shanks strikes me as a person who would only eat a DF if he was personally the one who found it so not to take it from someone else. DF's are already notorious to find & I dont think he's really lookin (and if he is, he's drunk)
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#5
Shanks believe in his own power. Maybe he thinks that he could be a disadvantage to have a DF against BB.

First he will have to change his fighting style, to adapt etc.

Second maybe he knows the power of the Yami Yami and knows that against BB having a DF is maybe the opposite of the solution because BB can nullify the DF and attract you if you have one.

With DF he will have other weaknes : sea stone and water. And Teach has now those weaknesses.

And maybe Shanks greatest power is COC related so a DF will not really increase this power
 

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
#6
Shanks believe in his own power. Maybe he thinks that he could be a disadvantage to have a DF against BB.

First he will have to change his fighting style, to adapt etc.

Second maybe he knows the power of the Yami Yami and knows that against BB having a DF is maybe the opposite of the solution because BB can nullify the DF and attract you if you have one.

With DF he will have other weaknes : sea stone and water. And Teach has now those weaknesses.

And maybe Shanks greatest power is COC related so a DF will not really increase this power
Your point about self confidence is very valid. I would also add honor.

Something tells me it would feel like a dishonor for Mihawk to eat one. He doesn't even care about swimming.
 
#7
Shanks believe in his own power. Maybe he thinks that he could be a disadvantage to have a DF against BB.

First he will have to change his fighting style, to adapt etc.

Second maybe he knows the power of the Yami Yami and knows that against BB having a DF is maybe the opposite of the solution because BB can nullify the DF and attract you if you have one.

With DF he will have other weaknes : sea stone and water. And Teach has now those weaknesses.

And maybe Shanks greatest power is COC related so a DF will not really increase this power
I guess perhaps advanced CoC is so powerful that him eating a DF wouldn't really make a difference as far as his power goes.
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
#10
Shanks believe in his own power. Maybe he thinks that he could be a disadvantage to have a DF against BB.

First he will have to change his fighting style, to adapt etc.

Second maybe he knows the power of the Yami Yami and knows that against BB having a DF is maybe the opposite of the solution because BB can nullify the DF and attract you if you have one.

With DF he will have other weaknes : sea stone and water. And Teach has now those weaknesses.

And maybe Shanks greatest power is COC related so a DF will not really increase this power
Yeah, I’m under the assumption that his proficiency with Haki is tops in the world/story...if he’s got the strongest spirit/force of will, a DF would just be gilding the lily. Also, the whole “having one arm” thing makes swimming difficult enough, don’t need to make him completely ineffective in the water.
 
#11
people try to come up with stupid arguments won't work here

no one can be bothered form more power
no one really is in disadvantage with a DF , most Top tiers are DF users and fine with it
Shanks after losing an arm had every fucking right in the world to eat a DF
Shanks have every right to use a sea stone sword as well if not eat a DF


so ...

Shanks can eat a Logia ... and be +Roger level EASY .... but no
Shanks can use a sea stone blade ... and be way more deadly to all DF users .... but no


that's make no fucking sense what so ever ... and Oda NEED AN REAL ANSWER FOR THIS

same logic goes for Mihawk , Garp , Dark King and Roger
 
M

MD Zolo

#12
I am on the boat that DFs are weapons that can be controlled by somebody at top (Imu) to some extent and hence Shanks doesn't eat one.

In fact nobody in Roger Pirates save Buggy is known to have a DF. Nobody in Shanks' crew is known to have a DF either.

It must relate to Imu.
 
#13
I am on the boat that DFs are weapons that can be controlled by somebody at top (Imu) to some extent and hence Shanks doesn't eat one.

In fact nobody in Roger Pirates save Buggy is known to have a DF. Nobody in Shanks' crew is known to have a DF either.

It must relate to Imu.
this seem like the most logical theory as well ....

but Shanks is perfectly OK with having a crew member who is a DF user ... he asked Marco to join him

but again ... Imu doing this can make the perfect sense ... but Oda need a lot of effort to justify the bug
 
#16
Personally, I like the idea of one of the strongest pirates in the world being just a normal human with no Devil Fruit. Big Mom, Kaido, Whitbeard, Blackbeard and most of the former warlords had them (we don't know about Weevil, if I remember right). It proves that you don't have to have a Devil Fruit to be one of the strongest (just like Roger).
 
#20
He bites Ray's style so deeply. That guy obviously has no DF and is easily one of the five strongest characters as a casual guy pushing 80. Why go through that trouble and depend on spamming some rock paper scissors crap when you're like them?

We all knew that though. What's more interesting is what he was doing with the Gomu fruit
 
Top