Controversial Why Kidd is a pathetic character

Is Kidd the worst written character in animanga history?


  • Total voters
    30

Kizaruber Eats

Joyboy reveal when?
#41
No wonder all the ladies want to cosplay Kid, this is what a female Kid would canonically look like.

Wid out here proving that it takes a real man to be best girl. Another glorious victory for the Damned One.
HELL YEAH MY BROTHER, YOU GET IT LMAO! Female Law and Kidd look so amazingly hot and pretty, its weirdly hilarious! Bless Goda for giving us Female Law and Bepo canonically (the latter was pure funny ofc) and if only we could get the same with Kidd and Killer, it would be priceless!

Female Kidd would basically be a better Nami too in a way personality wise and in other ways too lmao. Kinda like how Law is Robins equivalent too.

:ShishioIsBack::holdw::Woro:beanmean:
 
#43
. Despite having one of the most conceptually interesting Devil Fruits, the Jiki Jiki no Mi, which grants him magnetism-based powers, he uses it in the most unimaginative way possible. Instead of manipulating magnetic fields creatively, using his abilities to disarm opponents, control the battlefield, or enhance his own movement, Kidd’s idea of fighting is simply making big metal fists and smashing things. This is not only predictable but also far less versatile than other Worst Gen contemporaries like the one who carried his ass in the BM fight, Law, whose Ope Ope no Mi allows for precise, game-changing attacks. But that's ok. Law has arguably the best fighting style in the series. Let's compare Midd to someone more similar like Luffy. Even Luffy continuously evolves his combat techniques through Haki mastery and Gear transformations. Kidd, however, never adapts, never learns, and never changes, making his battles feel repetitive, uninspired, and completely lacking in strategic depth. He blindly charges into fights with the same brute-force mentality every single time, which inevitably leads to disastrous results like getting 0.5 shot by Shanks.
Kid’s fighting style is literally Luffy’s, but magnets instead of rubber.

G3 ~ Punk Gibson
G4 ~ punk rotten

Luffy’s awakening:
  • turns things into rubber
  • Giant form
  • Bajrang gun

Kid’s wano DF buffs:
  • Turns things magnetic
  • Giant bull form
  • Rail gun
ofc Kid is naturally weaker due to plot, as he’s a side character.

but I find it ironic how almost everything people hate about Kid is true about Luffy. They have the same fighting style. Luffy even acts recklessly and has gotten himself one shot. Luffy is arrogant, he claims he will be pirate king, despite being far younger and less experienced than most his enemies.

The only difference between Luffy and Kid is that Luffy is more noble, the plot favors him
Post automatically merged:

THIS IS NOT AI, I SPENT 5 DAYS TYPING THIS UP!
I believe this is what people in the lolcow community would classify as “A-Logging”
 

Kizaruber Eats

Joyboy reveal when?
#44
As the great Sugoi said
Kidd has better chance to be successful in real life than the generic 15 yo Japanese teen fav self insert character that only exist in fiction
:beckmoji:
LMAO, DAMN! So true though, underdogs who have to fight for survival, against the most unfair odds, being outcasts with most of the world against them and overly hated, misunderstood > nepo babies with silver spoons and no personalities and thus souls too.

Gonna post this unironically as my reaction to Sugoi's great roast now lmao:

(Loud volume and well obnoxious editing warning ofc lmfao:)


:kobeha::kobeha::kobeha::kobeha::kobeha::kobeha:
 
Last edited:
#52
I love Kidd, he's the next shiki, off to a not good start then rising in fame and power, his power literally parallels shiki's, both lost a limb and replaced it with scrap metal or a weapon they use

Kidd's a great guy, great character, once his head comes up on elbaf and Lilith recognizes him as Vegapunk 07, the failed experiment that vegapunk left on the island Kidd grew up on, now just a head due to shanks so she rebuilds Kidd into a new, more robotic form that Kidd can operate well, making him stronger and now metal besides his head
 
#54
And here's the summary
Summary:

Kid is trash, I don't like him, he's a failure in the anime, he's done nothing useful for the series, nothing against big mom. He had potential but his character was wasted, Flaw carried the Big Mom fight and Kid did absolutely nothing. Kid got rejected by a girl which I call him a clown for since I don't like him. Did I mention how trash kid is? Yeah, I don't like him, he's so wasted and a failure and oh dif I mention how I don't like him? Yeah, I don't like kid at all, he's the worst character. Oh I forgot to mention how much I hate kid, oh did I forget to mention how I hate kid 😭😭😭😭😭😭

(Yes this is the summary of this slander that this guy wrote, and yes most of it from what I skimmed through was about how he hates kid)
 
#56
And here's the summary
Summary:

Kid is trash, I don't like him, he's a failure in the anime, he's done nothing useful for the series, nothing against big mom. He had potential but his character was wasted, Flaw carried the Big Mom fight and Kid did absolutely nothing. Kid got rejected by a girl which I call him a clown for since I don't like him. Did I mention how trash kid is? Yeah, I don't like him, he's so wasted and a failure and oh dif I mention how I don't like him? Yeah, I don't like kid at all, he's the worst character. Oh I forgot to mention how much I hate kid, oh did I forget to mention how I hate kid 😭😭😭😭😭😭

(Yes this is the summary of this slander that this guy wrote, and yes most of it from what I skimmed through was about how he hates kid)
I don't hate Kidd dude I'm just an honest objective reader :neesama:
 

Pantheos

Heavy Metal
#59
And here's the summary
Summary:

Kid is trash, I don't like him, he's a failure in the anime, he's done nothing useful for the series, nothing against big mom. He had potential but his character was wasted, Flaw carried the Big Mom fight and Kid did absolutely nothing. Kid got rejected by a girl which I call him a clown for since I don't like him. Did I mention how trash kid is? Yeah, I don't like him, he's so wasted and a failure and oh dif I mention how I don't like him? Yeah, I don't like kid at all, he's the worst character. Oh I forgot to mention how much I hate kid, oh did I forget to mention how I hate kid 😭😭😭😭😭😭

(Yes this is the summary of this slander that this guy wrote, and yes most of it from what I skimmed through was about how he hates kid)
Sounds like an Interview with Donald Trump.
 
Top