Character Discussion Why Law is Joining The Crew

What would you think/like Law to do going forwards?


  • Total voters
    22

Warchief Sanji D Goat

Queen Gunko!➡️⬆️⬇️⬅️
#81
I said it before and I will say it again. Ain't no Supernova joining another Supernova's crew. Even if Law's goal is to trying discover the truth of the D, it doesn't mean that he will join other crew to achieve it.:kayneshrug:
 
#82
Law is Joining the Crew and here is why

First, we establish that Luffy is stronger than Law. This is done through Luffy defeating Doffy and further on fighting stronger and stronger opponents through Cracker, Katakuri, and now Kaido & Big Mom. Also, most people already accepted Zoro is stronger than Law so there is no conflict of interest there. WSS will always be one of the strongest in the Verse especially given that Zoro surpasses Mihawk.

Luffy already thinks of Law as a crewmember. And Law is one of the major driving forces of the plot. His infatuation with the Will of D is such a big deal.

ROLE: Heart Seat or Surgeon. In my opinion its the Heart Seat that Doffy wanted Law to be. Like a sacrifice. Remember Vergo and Corazon were Doffys past heart seats and they both perished. Law was given an overpowered Devil Fruit with the Ability to Rule the world coupled with something else according to Doflamingo. I believe it is some sort of Heart Seat where law uses the Perpetual Youth Operation some point in either Raftel post-battle with Blackbeard or in Marygeoise against Imu, or Gorosei?

DREAM: To find the meaning of the Will of D
SAD BACKSTORY: Flevance
BENEFACTOR: Donquixote Rosinante (Corazon/Cora-san)
BOUNTY: 500,000,000
LUFFY BOUNTY: 1,500,000,000

Supporting Reasons (w/ Canon showing)
  • Law was willing to die to Fuji and Doffy rather than call Luffy his subordinate in Greenbit.
  • Luffy explicitly said Law is on my crew. Law denied.
    • This is the same case with strawhat like Zoro, Nami, Sanji, Jinbei, Franky, Brook, Chopper who deny at first and later accept because they see Luffy for who he is.
  • Will of D Bond
    • Monkey D. Luffy & Trafalgar D. Water Law
  • Post Marine ford Law saved Luffy along with Jinbei, Ivankov (Serving in for Dragon), Buggy, and Shanks who are all tied very closely with Luffy
  • Law held Luffy's Strawhat for a significant Period during a Tumultuous time
    • Other People who've held the hat have been Ace, Zoro, Nami, Robin, Margaret, Buggy, Shanks, and Tama [with the exception of Margaret, everyone has a very close tie with Luffy]
  • Law Saves Bellamy parallel to Zoro saving Smoker
  • Law was swilling to die alongside Luffy if Doffy lost.
  • Luffy saves the strawhats from their shambles and Luffy saves Law from Doffy
  • Luffy finishes Laws fight for him like he does for the rest of the strawhats
    • He defeats Doflamingo.
    • Destroys Dressrosa.
    • And has Fujitora on his side the whole time.
    • Doflamingo is locked up in Level 6 Impel Down.
As of 996, the story now requires Law to travel with Luffy. Law will not become an Enemy after all their interactions/moments. He knows the ties the strawhats have with Luffy. He knows Luffy character and Ambitions. To know the meaning of the Will of D, Law has to travel with Pirate Kings crew. Law by himself realistically will not get there.


Law is a Captain of his own crew?
  • Jinbei was Captain of Sun Pirates.
  • Franky was the Boss of the Franky Family.
  • Usopp was Captain of the Usopp Pirates.
  • Zoro asked to be Captain of Baroque Works before killing Mr. 7.
  • Brook was a temporary Captain for the Rumbar Pirates.
  • Oden was the Leader of the 9 Red Scabbards.
@bennbeckman @Oblivion @Zoro D Goat @Krusher1357 @Seth @Jew D. Boy @Light D Lamperouge @Don DaSlayer @Luffy bin Dragon @Hades @Finalbeta @Pantheon @Garp the Fist @yj @Hades @Kuro Ashi @Aknolagon @Fenaker @KAIDO D. STRONGER @Cinera @rerere @ReggieZoldyck21 @Midnight Delight @Ravagerblade @Jiihad @PeperLevi @Paperchampion23 @playa4321 @T.D.A @Ice devil slayer @etc etc etc
I've huge doubts on Law joining the crew, but for sure you made good points in this thread

Good job :myman:
 

Finalbeta

Hero of Albion
#84
I said it before and I will say it again. Ain't no Supernova joining another Supernova's crew. Even if Law's goal is to trying discover the truth of the D, it doesn't mean that he will join other crew to achieve it.:kayneshrug:
Some novas may keep joining other novas (like it already occurred) but not be part of the same crew I mean, rather be strictly bound allies, like it happened with Luffy and Law I mean, or even Kidd's alliance.
 
#87
The problem is that you are using Pre Timeskip logic on Post Timeskip One Piece
Allies who hang out in the sunny for hundreds of Chapters is the norm in Post Timeskip One Piece when Vivi and Wiper were the only ones who got that kind of treatment Pre Timeskip(not counting the War Saga as the Crew were separated)
 
#88
The problem is that you are using Pre Timeskip logic on Post Timeskip One Piece
Allies who hang out in the sunny for hundreds of Chapters is the norm in Post Timeskip One Piece when Vivi and Wiper were the only ones who got that kind of treatment Pre Timeskip(not counting the War Saga as the Crew were separated)
Wiper? Wiper? The guy who was an antagonist for half the arc and still didn't get along til the end? The guy with no strawhat related dreams/ambitions? Wiper would never join.

I still believe Vivi may come into the crew again
 
#90
I love that Law is a Captain, but it is a fact that his crew is weak compared to Luffy and even Kidds.

I think that will be one of the catalyst in Law possibly joining Luffy, he will have to come to the realization that his crew can advance no further, and their lives could be lost if they continue moving forward with him. They already screwed up and nearly ruined the plan, and got Law captured. Law would probably send them to Zou, especially Bepo.

Also, Law's doesn't seem as interested in being Pirate King like Luffy and Kidd, he's interested in finding out what it's about, but not having the title for himself.

Law not only wants to know the Will of D, but he also wants to " break the gears" of the WG, don't forget that. Law wanted revenge on Doffy, but he also hates the WG for what they did to Flevance and what better way to get revenge than joining the one Pirate who has successfully ruined the WGs goals and caused major chaos.

I would love Law joining, but I'm fine if he stays a Captain too, but his crew would really need leveling up if so.
 
#91
I love that Law is a Captain, but it is a fact that his crew is weak compared to Luffy and even Kidds.

I think that will be one of the catalyst in Law possibly joining Luffy, he will have to come to the realization that his crew can advance no further, and their lives could be lost if they continue moving forward with him. They already screwed up and nearly ruined the plan, and got Law captured. Law would probably send them to Zou, especially Bepo.

Also, Law's doesn't seem as interested in being Pirate King like Luffy and Kidd, he's interested in finding out what it's about, but not having the title for himself.

Law not only wants to know the Will of D, but he also wants to " break the gears" of the WG, don't forget that. Law wanted revenge on Doffy, but he also hates the WG for what they did to Flevance and what better way to get revenge than joining the one Pirate who has successfully ruined the WGs goals and caused major chaos.

I would love Law joining, but I'm fine if he stays a Captain too, but his crew would really need leveling up if so.
It is still possible that he doesn't join, recruits some Scabbards, Beast Pirates headliners. But I doubt it, since they still couldn't hold a candle to Luffy's army
 
#92
Man I’m not underrating Jinbe at all. It’s the F6 who are being underrated and Franky being overrated because he’s in front of Sasaki lol

You’re even going to underplay Doffy and call him “mere YC level” just to hype Jinbe? Come on man I can’t take this seriously.

I’m not downplaying Jinbe at all.
Look General Frank is made of Wapometal

Even Whitebeard couldnt break this
 
#98
I dont know what you mean. All the TopiRoppo are like Daifuku/ Oven level, they haven't done anything to show otherwise.
Any of the flying 6 can beat Daifuku or Oven.
The only reason you believe them to be the same level is because of their ranking in their respective crews. The flying 6 have been portrayed higher and some even close to YC level. All ancient zoans, all crazy durability, regen. What exactly are Oven and Daifuku doing that comes close to this? Page one is tanking attacks against raid suit Sanji and Gear 3 armament Luffy after training for 6 days. Daifuku gets his genie pinned by Yonji and kicked about and clashes easily by base Sanji. Ichiji is speed blitzing Oven and his group like they're nothing. Sorry but F6 over Oven and Daifuku. You telling me X.Drake a worst gen Captain is the same level and Oven and Daifuku? Oven who has observation and can’t even keep up with bass Sanji. Yet Page 1 in hybrid is fighting RS Sanji who can also turn invisible yet they’re still going blow for blow?:yonjidoggy: :willsmith:
 
Last edited:
#99
Law is Joining the Crew and here is why

First, we establish that Luffy is stronger than Law. This is done through Luffy defeating Doffy and further on fighting stronger and stronger opponents through Cracker, Katakuri, and now Kaido & Big Mom. Also, most people already accepted Zoro is stronger than Law so there is no conflict of interest there. WSS will always be one of the strongest in the Verse especially given that Zoro surpasses Mihawk.

Luffy already thinks of Law as a crewmember. And Law is one of the major driving forces of the plot. His infatuation with the Will of D is such a big deal.

ROLE: Heart Seat or Surgeon. In my opinion its the Heart Seat that Doffy wanted Law to be. Like a sacrifice. Remember Vergo and Corazon were Doffys past heart seats and they both perished. Law was given an overpowered Devil Fruit with the Ability to Rule the world coupled with something else according to Doflamingo. I believe it is some sort of Heart Seat where law uses the Perpetual Youth Operation some point in either Raftel post-battle with Blackbeard or in Marygeoise against Imu, or Gorosei?

DREAM: To find the meaning of the Will of D
SAD BACKSTORY: Flevance
BENEFACTOR: Donquixote Rosinante (Corazon/Cora-san)
BOUNTY: 500,000,000
LUFFY BOUNTY: 1,500,000,000

Supporting Reasons (w/ Canon showing)
  • Law was willing to die to Fuji and Doffy rather than call Luffy his subordinate in Greenbit.
  • Luffy explicitly said Law is on my crew. Law denied.
    • This is the same case with strawhat like Zoro, Nami, Sanji, Jinbei, Franky, Brook, Chopper who deny at first and later accept because they see Luffy for who he is.
  • Will of D Bond
    • Monkey D. Luffy & Trafalgar D. Water Law
  • Post Marine ford Law saved Luffy along with Jinbei, Ivankov (Serving in for Dragon), Buggy, and Shanks who are all tied very closely with Luffy
  • Law held Luffy's Strawhat for a significant Period during a Tumultuous time
    • Other People who've held the hat have been Ace, Zoro, Nami, Robin, Margaret, Buggy, Shanks, and Tama [with the exception of Margaret, everyone has a very close tie with Luffy]
  • Law Saves Bellamy parallel to Zoro saving Smoker
  • Law was swilling to die alongside Luffy if Doffy lost.
  • Luffy saves the strawhats from their shambles and Luffy saves Law from Doffy
  • Luffy finishes Laws fight for him like he does for the rest of the strawhats
    • He defeats Doflamingo.
    • Destroys Dressrosa.
    • And has Fujitora on his side the whole time.
    • Doflamingo is locked up in Level 6 Impel Down.
As of 996, the story now requires Law to travel with Luffy. Law will not become an Enemy after all their interactions/moments. He knows the ties the strawhats have with Luffy. He knows Luffy character and Ambitions. To know the meaning of the Will of D, Law has to travel with Pirate Kings crew. Law by himself realistically will not get there.


Law is a Captain of his own crew?
  • Jinbei was Captain of Sun Pirates.
  • Franky was the Boss of the Franky Family.
  • Usopp was Captain of the Usopp Pirates.
  • Zoro asked to be Captain of Baroque Works before killing Mr. 7.
  • Brook was a temporary Captain for the Rumbar Pirates.
  • Oden was the Leader of the 9 Red Scabbards.
@bennbeckman @Oblivion @Zoro D Goat @Krusher1357 @Seth @Jew D. Boy @Light D Lamperouge @Don DaSlayer @Luffy bin Dragon @Hades @Finalbeta @Pantheon @Garp the Fist @yj @Hades @Kuro Ashi @Aknolagon @Fenaker @KAIDO D. STRONGER @Cinera @rerere @ReggieZoldyck21 @Midnight Delight @Ravagerblade @Jiihad @PeperLevi @Paperchampion23 @playa4321 @T.D.A @Ice devil slayer @etc etc etc
Nope :seriously:
 
Law is great, but oda said in interview, he didnt want main character (strawhat pirates) to be overpower...just like perona everyone are wanting her to join but both law and perona df is too OP, i can see them one shotting every enemy and thats lame, besides if luffy needed law assistance in every fights after big mom and kaido then luffy doesnt deserve to be a pirate king

At best law will be an ally because oda wont kill his crew, sun pirates original captain is already dead jinbei is only a vice captain
 
Top