Powers & Abilities Why Mihawk's swordsmanship is the greatest

It's all dependant. If there was no WSS prior to Mihawk, say because they might have died, or retired, then Mihawk would had to have been recognized for doing something else, wouldn't he have?

And let's say there was one, and Mihawk beat him, and it's been like that for decades, then how did the first WSS come to be, when there would have been no one to beat to take the title from?
[automerge]1681647137[/automerge]

Lets say for arguments sake he can cut a continent in half, but we just don't know it. But based on what we do know, you're going to go with the island splitter, right?
lol if he can cut a continent in half but he sliced a mountain
whereas the other guy sliced an island
doesnt that make the take of 2nd guy being > 1st guy debunkable ?
so basically this method of showing who the stronger swordsman is pretty fucking shit ?
 
lol if he can cut a continent in half but he sliced a mountain
whereas the other guy sliced an island
doesnt that make the take of 2nd guy being > 1st guy debunkable ?
so basically this method of showing who the stronger swordsman is pretty fucking shit ?
So you agree that we can determine who is the stronger swordsman, without them having to fight, solely based on what they can cut?
 
Last edited:
Seriously? We were told why in the flashback. To protect Zoros Swords so they wouldn't chip or break.

Let me ask you. Zoro knew absolutely nothing about haki preskip. So what exactly was he expecting Mihawk to teach him, when he asked him to train him?
Why do swords need haki for that?
Not chip or break? Just forge or seek a strong sword.

It doesn't sound quite swordman like to use tools outside swordsmanship.
(If you are one of those who think Haki ain't a key thing in swordmanship)
 
Why do swords need haki for that?
Not chip or break? Just forge or seek a strong sword.

It doesn't sound quite swordman like to use tools outside swordsmanship.
(If you are one of those who think Haki ain't a key thing in swordmanship)
Mihawk is the one who said it.

And nope, I'm not one of those. I believe Haki is detrimental to a Swordsman.
 
It's all dependant. If there was no WSS prior to Mihawk, say because they might have died, or retired, then Mihawk would had to have been recognized for doing something else, wouldn't he have?

And let's say there was one, and Mihawk beat him, and it's been like that for decades, then how did the first WSS come to be, when there would have been no one to beat to take the title from?
And until this stops being headcanon, Zoro is the ONE AND ONLY decider of how this works

Zoro’s idea of what a WSS is and Zoro’s idea of how the WSS title is acquired… these are the only ideas that matter about this

If this is frustrating, blame Oda for wasting 1000 chapters giving zero fucks to explain anything
 
And until this stops being headcanon, Zoro is the ONE AND ONLY decider of how this works

Zoro’s idea of what a WSS is and Zoro’s idea of how the WSS title is acquired… these are the only ideas that matter about this

If this is frustrating, blame Oda for wasting 1000 chapters giving zero fucks to explain anything
Zoro is not the sole decider. Mihawk exists, and therefore needs to be beaten in order for Zoro to claim the title. But if Mihawk fell down a flight of steps and died, that doesn't mean Zoros dream is over. By EoS he would be regarded as the WSS one way or another. Zoro dreamed of being the WSS as a child, long before he ever knew Mihawk existed.
 
Last edited:
So you agree that we can determine who is the stronger swordsman, without them having to fight, solely based on what they can cut?
lol ? not at all
this can basically done with any fighter u want with any stat
if char A can lift more weight than char B
and thats the only thing we see from them , for many char A will be stronger
but that simply doesnt mean char A is the stronger fighter
 
lol ? not at all
this can basically done with any fighter u want with any stat
if char A can lift more weight than char B
and thats the only thing we see from them , for many char A will be stronger
but that simply doesnt mean char A is the stronger fighter
But we are not talking about lifting weights. We are talking about cutting an island vs cutting a continent.

So now your saying, it doesn't matter who can cut the Continent, because the Island cutter can be stronger right?

So what could make the Island cutter stronger? Perhaps being a better fighter?
 
Zoro is not the sole decider. Mihawk exists, and therefore needs to be beaten in order for Zoro to claim the title. But if Mihawk fell down a flight of steps and died, that doesn't mean Zoros dream is over. By EoS he would be regarded as the WSS one way or another. Zoro dreamed of being the WSS as a child, long before he ever knew Mihawk existed.
There is no way Zoro doesn’t fight for the title

if you want to talk about Shiryu backstabbing mihawk then fine. Shiryu will be WSS and Zoro will fight him

if Shiryu backstabs Mihawk and then Runs into S-Hawk and S-Hawk kills Shiryu, then Zoro will fight S-hawk

if Shiryu bacskstabs Mihawk, then S-Hawk kills Shiryu, then Greenbull kills S-Hawk, then Samurai Ghandi kills Greenbull, Zoro will fight Samurai Ghandi

outside of the fact that this is a Shonen manga, Oda has made it clear that Zoro has to win in combat for his dream to be achieved

There is no alternative way this plays out. Zoro WILL NOT be WSS via default, or Mihawk just decides Zoro is WSS without fighting or Zoro cuts a big rock and that’s the rock that only the WSS can cut (yet Mihawk never cut it and he is WSS)

no. It will be a fight. Because Oda has not promised or set up any other way.
[automerge]1681658957[/automerge]
Tbf Mihawk's VC also states that he ruthlessly fought competitors until there was none left.



"He trained ruthlessly challenging more and more powerful foes, until he had no more worthy challengers."

Artur is pretty shit at T/L but i remember seeing multiple t/l say the same thing.

@Celestial D. Dragon @ImmaIvanoM
@ConquistadoR
Oda should probably ACTUALLY PUT THIS IN THE MANGA
 
Zoro is not the sole decider. Mihawk exists, and therefore needs to be beaten in order for Zoro to claim the title. But if Mihawk fell down a flight of steps and died, that doesn't mean Zoros dream is over. By EoS he would be regarded as the WSS one way or another. Zoro dreamed of being the WSS as a child, long before he ever knew Mihawk existed.
Well we all know that Oda won't write such an absurb scenario such as Mihawk dying prematurely before losing in a fight so there's no point of using such a hypothetical as an arguement at the end of the day. Anyways as @ConquistadoR posted Mihawk has went all over the world fighting all the notable swordsman he could find and beaten them (although he never went to Wano which makes that a lie, but let's ignore that mark on Mihawk's lore for now), and Zoro's goal is to defeat the man that beat the men, therefore we can conclude that the only way to become the WSS is to be the strongest swordsman. Any other idea is pure headcanon.
 
And btw the reason Mihawk beat Zoro at the Baratie was simply because he was way physically stronger than Zoro. Mihawk's the same guy that can send icebergs to the stratophere, turning the whole thing into mere particles soon after. No showcase of Mihawk's superior skill has been showcased in that fight.
 
Top