Speculations Will Brook get A New Sword?

Dettles

Dettles

‎
#1
#1
With Zoro getting Emna, will Brook get a New Sword too?
We know Tenguyama Hitetsu is a master Swordsmith, could he forge a new sword for Brook, by the end of Wano?
Brook has used two swords that we know of shikomizue (Solid Soul), and an unnamed sword, the one he used during his time with the Rumbar Pirates.
And while we haven’t seen the latter sword since he unveiled shikomizue, I don’t believe he simply discarded it. Given that the sword holds the memories from his former crew and past adventures. Similar to Zoro’s swords either being broken or in Shusui’s case returned to Wano after it was taken from a grave.
That’s why I believe the Sword will be forged for him instead of simply getting a Brand-New Sword. Possibly using one or even both swords as material for it.
(Wildest outcome)
Brook has his new sword forged for him and gets the Tone Dial carrying the Last Song of the Rumbar Pirates imbedded in the hilt or base of the Sword. Then with his Soul Soul Fruit, his new swords with the vibrations from the tone dial and his fruit becomes, similar to a chainsaw that freezes. Adding to his attack strength.
(More realistic outcome)
Brook’s new sword is becomes a new O Wazamono grade sword. And because it was forged just for him, (Maybe even Brook helping in a small way). Works with his powers better.
 
thedarkdragon11

thedarkdragon11

‎
#2
#2
I don't think he will... He doesn't need one... Swords from Wano doesn't fit his swordplay...

The most we can expect would be a Wano "upgrade" (in a form of Wano samurai add-on, or a sub-style based from Wano)...
 
Luffy is the mc

Luffy is the mc

‎
#3
#3
It could be nice. He had some great moments in WCI, but unfortunately I don't think it will happen.
Oda doesn't focus much on power up for characters other than luffy, zoro, sanji, nami and usopp. Not enough time.
 
Garp the Fist

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
‎
#4
#4
Has it been said that Brook had two different swords? I know we only found out it's name post-skip, but that doesn't mean pre-skip it was a different one.

I don't think he'll get a new one though. I think it's more likely he gets Haki to improve his swordsmanship- it was noted in PH that he can't cut steel yet, he should learn that- or boosts his DF. He'd only get a new sword if someone broke his current one
 
Yasuda

Yasuda

‎
#5
#5
I think if Brook gets a power up this arc it will be another hidden power of his Devil Fruit rather than a new sword. I would love for him to get a new one forged by Tenguyama though. It would be a missed opportunity for a master smith such as Tenguyama to not forge a sword for someone at the end of the arc. Zoro, Law, and the Scabbards are unlikely so why not Brook?
 
M

Mohammad211

‎
#6
#6
Garp the Fist said:
Has it been said that Brook had two different swords? I know we only found out it's name post-skip, but that doesn't mean pre-skip it was a different one.

I don't think he'll get a new one though. I think it's more likely he gets Haki to improve his swordsmanship- it was noted in PH that he can't cut steel yet, he should learn that- or boosts his DF. He'd only get a new sword if someone broke his current one
Click to expand...
i think he said Long arms made/give him His Sword
 
Yasuda

Yasuda

‎
#8
#8
Garp the Fist said:
Has it been said that Brook had two different swords? I know we only found out it's name post-skip, but that doesn't mean pre-skip it was a different one.

I don't think he'll get a new one though. I think it's more likely he gets Haki to improve his swordsmanship- it was noted in PH that he can't cut steel yet, he should learn that- or boosts his DF. He'd only get a new sword if someone broke his current one
Click to expand...
Interestingly, the VIZ translation said Soul Solid was forged by the Longarm Tribe. The OP Wiki says sharpened rather than forged though. I wonder if it was translated differently way back then by fan scanlators and the wiki contains the old translation? Or perhaps VIZ got it wrong instead? I'd really like to know what the original Japanese raw says. It's chapter 643 for anyone that wants to check.
 
Garp the Fist

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
‎
#11
#11
thedarkdragon11 said:
Where was that mentioned? I think it was instead implied that he can already cut steel after TS since he can cut dragons...
Click to expand...
I'm sure there's a scene where Zoro, Brook and Kin are on top of Brownbeard, running away from Smiley. They come up to a steel door, Zoro asks Kin if he can cut steel, he says of course and they cut it up. Given that Brook was there and didn't get involved- whereas later in the arc Oda did have the three fight together- I've always assumed that meant Brook couldn't cut steel.

Also, as we now know that cutting steel is Haki, and Brook doesn't have Haki yet
 
KiriNigiri

KiriNigiri

The Road To Harmony
‎
#17
#17
trav said:
Wano is not known to make cane swords. so, no!
Click to expand...
thedarkdragon11 said:
I don't think he will... He doesn't need one... Swords from Wano doesn't fit his swordplay...

The most we can expect would be a Wano "upgrade" (in a form of Wano samurai add-on, or a sub-style based from Wano)...
Click to expand...
Wano is One Piece Japan. In Japan, you can find Shikomizue(concealed sword). Brook’s sword is basically that. So I don’t see why Wano would be any different.

I digress, I don’t think Brook is getting a new sword. But he should learn armament haki.
 
Lampyris

Lampyris

‎
#18
#18
Brook is a DF-based fighter. Oda doesn't put much emphasis on the sheer power or cutting ability of Brook's technique. Like he let Brook stand back as Zoro and Kinemon cut steel in Punk Hazard. Maybe he'll learn haki later on, but I expect his applications to be different from typical swordsman.

Brook is fast, but that's down to his lightweight body and quick legs. He doesn't need a sword to perform his speed feats like running over water. Once again, Brook shines regardless of the quality of his blade.

I don't think Oda has any interest into turning Brook into an inferior Zoro. Brook is not about the World's Strongest Swordsman game at all. His sword acts more as a medium to channel all his other abilities due to his unique make up or DF mastery. Therefore, a sword-based power up to follow Zoro seems unlikely.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top