Break Week Would Big mom be more popular if she was in her prime?

[Swallalala]

The main reason she isn’t that popular is because of her design. Boa is extremely popular only because she’s hot.

BM had the same figure as Nami/Robin when she was younger so I definitely think she would be far more popular, at least top 30 in the popularity poll

 

[Ryuarashi]

Imagine if Black Maria was Big Mom, even with her clumsy personality she would been top 5 favorite for most.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

Yes

 

[Midnight Delight]

Yes

 

[MarineHQ]

Absolutely yes

 

[Afroking]

Is Smoothie popular?

She isn't ,so you got your answer.

 

[HA001]

Is Smoothie popular?

She isn't ,so you got your answer.

What if Big Mom looked like your pic

 

[Konstantis]

Is Smoothie popular?

She isn't ,so you got your answer.

Smoothie is not popular case she is written like garbage.

Same thing goes for Big Mom. It's not age thing, but writening. If she was written well, than she would be popular, but she is written as a joke, like any other Wano character.

 

[SmokedOut]

Absolutely. She'd probably be more popular than Hancock.

The real question is, did she purposely become hideous for her DF to work? Young BM would inspire lust more than fear.

 

[Swallalala]

Is Smoothie popular?

She isn't ,so you got your answer.

Smoothie isn’t popular because she has no screentime

 

[Finalbeta]

I think she was probably never hot. If I'm not mistaken the classic depiction of her in her younghood is fanmade.

 

[NAMELESS]

If she was young and hot again i bet there would a 100 sexy fan arts made about her.

 

[Reborn]

To some extent yes. Looks do matter in attracting fans. But it's for short term only

In long run how that character is portrayed becomes more appealing to fans than the looks.


BM had big hype when she was first introduced in FI but her hype took massive hit during WCI and to make matter worse in Wano too

Let's take Kaido - had one of the most badass intro but everything is gone at this stage. His ranking in not that good either despite his own arc is going on.

So it's more about portrayal than looks

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

Yep all the coomers would love her

 

[uyuu]

The main reason she isn’t that popular is because of her design. Boa is extremely popular only because she’s hot.

BM had the same figure as Nami/Robin when she was younger so I definitely think she would be far more popular, at least top 30 in the popularity poll

This pic should get Oda into sayin "say no more fam"

 

[Afroking]

What if Big Mom looked like your pic

Make her competent and and her intimidation looks would shoot up her popularity.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

I think she was probably never hot. If I'm not mistaken the classic depiction of her in her younghood is fanmade.

No it’s from an sbs

and oda reaffirmed this version of big mom when we got those snippets of the rocks pirates between acts 2 and 3

 

[Finalbeta]

If she was young and hot again i bet there would a sexy 100 fanarts made about her.

But we can merely count some that are non canon

 

[The Legend]

Nah all the hunger pangs, o-lin, mama mode, cannibalism, child abuse, constant clowning and all that shit has a limit and big joke has already exceeded it...
But it is better than Mr. 100 kidnappings

 

[Fuckthis3]

Is Smoothie popular?

She isn't ,so you got your answer.

Smoothie is not popular case she is written like garbage.

Same thing goes for Big Mom. It's not age thing, but writening. If she was written well, than she would be popular, but she is written as a joke, like any other Wano character.

Yet Smoothie still got fans cus of her looks other so yea it works