Speculations Would Smoker vs Luffy be one of the most beautiful fights?

Would Smoker vs Luffy be beautiful?

  • Yeah

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
#2
I don't know. They don't have dynamic like Garp and Roger. I see coby as the more fitting role for it.

To me he would would like Sengoku , Also he can have meaningful fight if Sengoku , Fujitora , Smoker are on their way to cross guild.
 
#7
Only if Luffy isn't actively trying to hurt him.

Smoker doesn't register as a threat.

He was a low diff post skip.

He's base level Armament 1HKO territory now.
 
Last edited:
#8
IF Smoker becomes the one Logia user to awaken his fruit, then yes. It is possible he could do a great variety of things including even changing the size of his body like how Luffy does... maybe
 
#11
Only if Luffy isn't trying to actively hurt him.

Smoker doesn't register as a threat.

He was a low diff post skip.

He's base level Armament 1HKO territory now.
He’s not. People seriously need to understand how power creep works.

Just for reference, Rodo’s cat took more than a base level CoA punch.
Post automatically merged:

My guess is Koby and Smoker will fight Luffy 2v1. Oda will give them ACoC and logia awakening respectively so it will actually be a tough fight for Luffy.
 
#12
Smoker's awakening could do weird stuff tbh

I believe that Logia Awakening causes the original Logia Intangibility to go to another level.

The intangibility of Logia users had a problem after the time-skip. This problem arose because people started using their own spirit/will to find the "original body" of the Logia user.

An example of this occuring was when Smoker got hit by Vergo despite being a Smoke Man. Normally, this wouldn't happen, but NEW RULES concerning Armament Haki were discovered.

I propose that NEW RULES will apply again when Logia Awakening occurs. People consider intangibility practically meaningless since the Armament Haki rules came out, but the new rules with Logia Awakening might reverse this.

Logia Awakening may cause things "OTHER THAN THE USER'S OWN BODY" to become affected by their Devil Fruit ability. Logia may be able to do things like use the ability to warp from place to place as long as their material is nearby. (Greenbull already pulled some similar crap by being blown away and reviving as a damn seedling)

Material that is now defined as NOT PART OF THEIR BODY can potentially be swapped out with their real body whenever they get attacked by Armament Haki. PREVIOUSLY ANY PART OF THE SMOKE WAS SMOKER'S BODY, BUT IT WON'T BE ANYMORE IF HE AWAKENS. HE CAN USE THINGS OTHER THAN HIS BODY.

Soooo ... Logia Awakening might be some shit
 
Last edited:
#13
He’s not. People seriously need to understand how power creep works.

Just for reference, Rodo’s cat took more than a base level CoA punch.
Yes they should, starting with you.

It doesn't seem to dawn on you Luffy didn't show off the extent of his pre-skip training until he revealed Snakeman versus Katakuri.

Boundman was far too powerful for Doflamingo to deal with, and he punked Smoker and Law, who also punked Smoker.

Oda chose to make Smoker that weak, it is what it is.
 
#14
Yes they should, starting with you.

It doesn't seem to dawn on you Luffy didn't show off the extent of his pre-skip training until he revealed Snakeman versus Katakuri.

Boundman was far too powerful for Doflamingo to deal with, and he punked Smoker and Law, who also punked Smoker.

Oda chose to make Smoker that weak, it is what it is.
Characters are as strong as the plot demands them to be.

In PH, Smoker was still a mid diff fight for Luffy. Why shouldn’t Smoker have kept up with Luffy just like Kid, Law, and the monster trio?

Y’all seriously think Lucci got advanced haki and awakening but Oda really forgot about one of Luffy’s biggest marine rivals?
 
#15
Yes they should, starting with you.

It doesn't seem to dawn on you Luffy didn't show off the extent of his pre-skip training until he revealed Snakeman versus Katakuri.

Boundman was far too powerful for Doflamingo to deal with, and he punked Smoker and Law, who also punked Smoker.

Oda chose to make Smoker that weak, it is what it is.
Characters are as strong as the plot demands them to be.

In PH, Smoker was still a mid diff fight for Luffy. Why shouldn’t Smoker have kept up with Luffy just like Kid, Law, and the monster trio?

Y’all seriously think Lucci got advanced haki and awakening but Oda really forgot about one of Luffy’s biggest marine rivals?
I mean they get stronger every arc, base WCI Luffy probably mid diffs base Fishman Island Luffy
 
#18
I mean they get stronger every arc, base WCI Luffy probably mid diffs base Fishman Island Luffy
This is like going to the gym twice, and saying "I'm more powerful than ever". While it's true, it's not as big of a difference as you think.

If these characters get as strong as some people here make them out to be, SHs wouldn't need a 2 year time skip.
 
#19
Well, you can certainly see the static thinkers and those who are dynamic thinkers.

A static thinker, in the context of thinking styles, is someone who tends to view the world in a fixed and unchanging way, lacking flexibility and adaptability in their thought processes. They often believe that abilities and intelligence are predetermined and unchangeable, and they may resist challenges or feedback. This contrasts with a dynamic thinker, who embraces change and sees potential for growth and improvement.

Somebody could become powerful for a reason that isn't as obvious or straightforward as training is.
 
Top