Character Discussion Zoro the Phoenix of Wano and Kaido the Dragon.

Do you agree on Zoro being Wano's Phoenix?


  • Total voters
    25
#22
Aren't the Ying Yang animals the Seiryuu (east) and the Byakko (west)?
And isn't Suzaku (south), the "phoenix", not actually a phoenix? Despite being similar to the chinese phoenix in apperance, Suzaku is not actually a phoenix. At least that's what I remember. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Right or wrong, and despite I not agreeing with it, it's a very nice written thread. Enjoyed reading it.
:sweat:
I use the Chinese comparison in this thread. And in Chinese mythology, as far as I know Yin and Yang are represented by Phoenix and Dragon. And in my opinion, the direction these animal represent does not contradict with what I intend to show as they are not totally the opposite like West (Tiger) and East (Dragon) but complement a little South (Phoenix) and East (Dragon).
I can't not vouch for Suzuka being entirely based of Phoenix but a large part of Japan's culture is influenced by Chinese's one so we can't say it's impossible either. However from what I remember when reading Detective Conan, Suzuka has a high chance of being Phoenix.
Thanks a lot, nothing wrong with disagreeing with me. I appreciate your feedback! :sweat:
I did a little research and the South Bird and East Dragon are indeed put together as opposites quite often, not the Tiger.
Good to know.
Going back to the topic.
The Suzaku is said to appear in times of good fortune. This kinda bothers me because when we see Zoro for the first time post TS, he cuts down some pirate's ship and tell them something like "you should curse fate for putting such a plague in your way", or something like that.
He was represented as a sign of misfortune (for enemies, but misfortune nonetheless).
The Vermilion Bird is also associated with the female genre, demonstrating characteristics as "noble and elegant". Also doesn't quite fit Zoro's portrayal. He is noble, I give you that. But elegant? Dont know about that one.
The "Fire element" thing also doesn't quite hold, because the Azure Dragon's element is "Wood". Since we don't see such correlation for Kaido, doesn't really make sense to expect it for Zoro.
Not only that, both Luffy, Sanji and Franky are somewhat capable of using Fire abilities. Zoro doesn't seen special just because of it.
I dont particularly care if ZKK happens or not. Only that, if it does, it is done in a satisfactory manner. But I truly don't see it happening.
I think the points you made are good, but I don't feel like they hold much ground.
What do you think?
Yes, in the East, they are usually if not always potrayed together. There are quite the amount of quotes, phrases, names coming from the couple of dragon and phoenix. Tiger is usually more associated with eagles from my knowledge. Yes again we can make a link from Zoro, a tiger canonnically, being associated with eagle, a call to phoenix ref imo.
Yes Zoro associated himself with a curse, but a curse upon his enemies, while being the call of fortune for his allies (notably, he initialized the stopping the Bird Cage plan which united all sides of the battle bar Donquixote Family).
I agree with the Vermilion Bird being associated with female, as in Yin, but in eastern stories, nothing wrong with men using Yin energy even if it's rare. Since you agreed on the "noble" part, I'll comment on the "elegant" side. Samurais are in the upper class of society, they are required to master many arts, traditional ceremonies, and such being elegant is nothing new about Zoro. The art of Iai is a form art only extraordinary samurai can perform. Not to mention the act of seppuku is also view as a ceremony, and Zoro was shown of capable of performing it even when seeing it for the first time.
For the use of fire, I only meant it as both animal has something in similar that they are known for using fire related powers, not their elements from mythos. Zoro have fire element is just a plus, if he does not have it, it doesn't impact much on my comparison as I do not go deep into that side.
Ye I understand, it's difficult so see how ZKK happening with the chance of it shadowing Luffy being high. But I did make a comparison to the Hobbit, what do you think of it? Also this thread is to brush aside the idea of Kaido not being Zoro's main oppenent more than making a point about ZKK, it was only at the end that my wanking side got the better of me ngl. xD
Thank you again, I really appreciate your feedbacks on this topic.
 
#24
I use the Chinese comparison in this thread. And in Chinese mythology, as far as I know Yin and Yang are represented by Phoenix and Dragon. And in my opinion, the direction these animal represent does not contradict with what I intend to show as they are not totally the opposite like West (Tiger) and East (Dragon) but complement a little South (Phoenix) and East (Dragon).
I can't not vouch for Suzuka being entirely based of Phoenix but a large part of Japan's culture is influenced by Chinese's one so we can't say it's impossible either. However from what I remember when reading Detective Conan, Suzuka has a high chance of being Phoenix.
Thanks a lot, nothing wrong with disagreeing with me. I appreciate your feedback! :sweat:

Yes, in the East, they are usually if not always potrayed together. There are quite the amount of quotes, phrases, names coming from the couple of dragon and phoenix. Tiger is usually more associated with eagles from my knowledge. Yes again we can make a link from Zoro, a tiger canonnically, being associated with eagle, a call to phoenix ref imo.
Yes Zoro associated himself with a curse, but a curse upon his enemies, while being the call of fortune for his allies (notably, he initialized the stopping the Bird Cage plan which united all sides of the battle bar Donquixote Family).
I agree with the Vermilion Bird being associated with female, as in Yin, but in eastern stories, nothing wrong with men using Yin energy even if it's rare. Since you agreed on the "noble" part, I'll comment on the "elegant" side. Samurais are in the upper class of society, they are required to master many arts, traditional ceremonies, and such being elegant is nothing new about Zoro. The art of Iai is a form art only extraordinary samurai can perform. Not to mention the act of seppuku is also view as a ceremony, and Zoro was shown of capable of performing it even when seeing it for the first time.
For the use of fire, I only meant it as both animal has something in similar that they are known for using fire related powers, not their elements from mythos. Zoro have fire element is just a plus, if he does not have it, it doesn't impact much on my comparison as I do not go deep into that side.
Ye I understand, it's difficult so see how ZKK happening with the chance of it shadowing Luffy being high. But I did make a comparison to the Hobbit, what do you think of it? Also this thread is to brush aside the idea of Kaido not being Zoro's main oppenent more than making a point about ZKK, it was only at the end that my wanking side got the better of me ngl. xD
Thank you again, I really appreciate your feedbacks on this topic.
I personally think Zoro is the tiger.
But nice thread anyways
:sweat:
 
#25
South Bird?
What a coincidence!
Post automatically merged:

Damn Oda and his foreshadowing :steef:
3 votes on each of the 3 options resulting in 33.3% for each.
:steef:
Post automatically merged:

Ruined already.:josad:
Nah it's good have diverse opinions, the only problem is that those in disagreement do not offer their reasons.
HELL NAW. Zoro is the tiger while Marco or Sanji is the Phoenix/Vermillion Bird.
Sanji is the vermillion bird

Zoro is literally the tiger we already known this. Make a dragon and tiger post not a bird post
Sanji is canonnically a bighorn sheep as shown in the cover page of chapter 651. Don't take your supposed "leaks" with no confirmed backup to use as an argument.
that's some deep point's you got there.
when zoro defeated ryuma. ryuma's corps was engulfed in flames which may symbolize the death of a legend and before he's turned into ash he gave his beloved sword with his legacy to zoro signaling the rebirth of the legend.
swords carry inside them their master's will so zoro giving shisui back to wano is like bringing ryuma back home.
Yes that is a good remark, I really forgot about that detail. What more, Ryuma was the only zombie in TB not defeated by salt! Oda made sure to highlight that! Another big evidence of the second coming of Ryuma. Thank you! :cheers:
Post automatically merged:

I personally think Zoro is the tiger.
But nice thread anyways
:sweat:
Thank you. And ye I agree on Zoro being the tiger as Oda show that to us on chapter 651 cover page. But that's why I said the phoenix is a better pick only for this arc, as it symbolize the theme the most.
 
#26

Damn Oda and his foreshadowing :steef:

Nah it's good have diverse opinions, the only problem is that those in disagreement do not offer their reasons.


Sanji is canonnically a bighorn sheep as shown in the cover page of chapter 651. Don't take your supposed "leaks" with no confirmed backup to use as an argument.

Yes that is a good remark, I really forgot about that detail. What more, Ryuma was the only zombie in TB not defeated by salt! Oda made sure to highlight that! Another big evidence of the second coming of Ryuma. Thank you! :cheers:
Post automatically merged:


Thank you. And ye I agree on Zoro being the tiger as Oda show that to us on chapter 651 cover page. But that's why I said the phoenix is a better pick only for this arc, as it symbolize the theme the most.

sanjis the only one who actually fits the vermillion bird. Zoro is the tiger. Zoro can’t be both because it wouldn’t make sense
 
#27
Lots of talk about Byakko, Suzaku, Seiryu.

Where's the Genbu love?
Maybe Whitebeard was the Genbu? It fits, he was old but powerful asf, is a protector, has a big big family, he carried his family, was the biggest factor in the balancing of the world. Earthquakes are believed to be caused by land dragons iirc, and turtles are often believed to be related to dragons.
Post automatically merged:





sanjis the only one who actually fits the vermillion bird. Zoro is the tiger. Zoro can’t be both because it wouldn’t make sense
I am not debating on wether Sanji fits the animal or not, but about you using that as an argument like it is canon/confirmed against my take while not offering your defends on your take. And you said that Zoro's a tiger in canon, I said I agree to that, even in my op, but the phoenix is a better pick for this arc alone because of the reasons I listed.
And Sanji's animal in canon is a bighorn sheep, so it wouldn't make sense for him to be both. See how that sounds?
 
Last edited:
#28
Maybe Whitebeard was the Genbu? It fits, he was old but powerful asf, is a protector, has a big big family, he carried his family, was the biggest factor in the balancing of the world. Earthquakes are believed to be caused by land dragons iirc, and turtles are often believed to be related to dragons.
Post automatically merged:


I am not debating on wether Sanji fits the animal or not, but about you using that as an argument like it is canon/confirmed against my take while not offering your defends on your take. And you said that Zoro's a tiger in canon, I said I agree to that, even in my op, but the phoenix is a better pick for this arc alone because of the reasons I listed.
And Sanji's animal in canon is a bighorn sheep, so it wouldn't make sense for him to be both. See how that sounds?

no because zoro is supposed to be the tiger which goes into the story of the tiger and dragon. The Phoenix only fits sanji. You say you aren’t debating if it fits him but he’s the only way it actually fights. Especially since zoro has said before sanji looks like he is about to transform
 

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
#29
I use the Chinese comparison in this thread. And in Chinese mythology, as far as I know Yin and Yang are represented by Phoenix and Dragon. And in my opinion, the direction these animal represent does not contradict with what I intend to show as they are not totally the opposite like West (Tiger) and East (Dragon) but complement a little South (Phoenix) and East (Dragon).
I can't not vouch for Suzuka being entirely based of Phoenix but a large part of Japan's culture is influenced by Chinese's one so we can't say it's impossible either. However from what I remember when reading Detective Conan, Suzuka has a high chance of being Phoenix.
Thanks a lot, nothing wrong with disagreeing with me. I appreciate your feedback! :sweat:

Yes, in the East, they are usually if not always potrayed together. There are quite the amount of quotes, phrases, names coming from the couple of dragon and phoenix. Tiger is usually more associated with eagles from my knowledge. Yes again we can make a link from Zoro, a tiger canonnically, being associated with eagle, a call to phoenix ref imo.
Yes Zoro associated himself with a curse, but a curse upon his enemies, while being the call of fortune for his allies (notably, he initialized the stopping the Bird Cage plan which united all sides of the battle bar Donquixote Family).
I agree with the Vermilion Bird being associated with female, as in Yin, but in eastern stories, nothing wrong with men using Yin energy even if it's rare. Since you agreed on the "noble" part, I'll comment on the "elegant" side. Samurais are in the upper class of society, they are required to master many arts, traditional ceremonies, and such being elegant is nothing new about Zoro. The art of Iai is a form art only extraordinary samurai can perform. Not to mention the act of seppuku is also view as a ceremony, and Zoro was shown of capable of performing it even when seeing it for the first time.
For the use of fire, I only meant it as both animal has something in similar that they are known for using fire related powers, not their elements from mythos. Zoro have fire element is just a plus, if he does not have it, it doesn't impact much on my comparison as I do not go deep into that side.
Ye I understand, it's difficult so see how ZKK happening with the chance of it shadowing Luffy being high. But I did make a comparison to the Hobbit, what do you think of it? Also this thread is to brush aside the idea of Kaido not being Zoro's main oppenent more than making a point about ZKK, it was only at the end that my wanking side got the better of me ngl. xD
Thank you again, I really appreciate your feedbacks on this topic.
I'm severely sleep deprived right now, so I will not address everything.
Just the end.
I also think Kaido is Zoro's main fight. But is also Luffy's, Kidd's, Killer's, and Law's. I advocate in the sense that the 5v2 WILL remain a 5v2.
I also advocate that Zoro will have a brief 1v1 against Kaido, occasion during which he will open the scar and be acknowledged.
but I also advocate for the 4 CoC clash.
Who knows how Oda will develop this 5v2. I dont think he invested a lot of panel time on Kidd for nothing.
But as I said before, regardless of the outcome, I just hope for Sanji 1v1 a Calamity. Whatever happens on the roof, happens.
:sweat:
 
#30
I'm severely sleep deprived right now, so I will not address everything.
Just the end.
I also think Kaido is Zoro's main fight. But is also Luffy's, Kidd's, Killer's, and Law's. I advocate in the sense that the 5v2 WILL remain a 5v2.
I also advocate that Zoro will have a brief 1v1 against Kaido, occasion during which he will open the scar and be acknowledged.
but I also advocate for the 4 CoC clash.
Who knows how Oda will develop this 5v2. I dont think he invested a lot of panel time on Kidd for nothing.
But as I said before, regardless of the outcome, I just hope for Sanji 1v1 a Calamity. Whatever happens on the roof, happens.
:sweat:
pretty sure Kidd and zoro will both get a short solo against kaido. I’m betting on Kidd creating a giant mech and having a short solo fight vs kaido or big mom or both. Zoro vs kaido in full zoan
 

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
#31
Damn Oda and his foreshadowing :steef:

Nah it's good have diverse opinions, the only problem is that those in disagreement do not offer their reasons.


Sanji is canonnically a bighorn sheep as shown in the cover page of chapter 651. Don't take your supposed "leaks" with no confirmed backup to use as an argument.

Yes that is a good remark, I really forgot about that detail. What more, Ryuma was the only zombie in TB not defeated by salt! Oda made sure to highlight that! Another big evidence of the second coming of Ryuma. Thank you! :cheers:
Post automatically merged:


Thank you. And ye I agree on Zoro being the tiger as Oda show that to us on chapter 651 cover page. But that's why I said the phoenix is a better pick only for this arc, as it symbolize the theme the most.
Sanji is literally a GOAT.
Lmao.
:stealthblack:

I know we are talking about that cover page or whatever where's there's a santoryuu tiger using bamboos, but where did Oda say Zoro was a shark? SBS i presume? Did he talk about the others, and the reasoning behind all of them? Would be cool to include it here so we can analyze it further.
Post automatically merged:

pretty sure Kidd and zoro will both get a short solo against kaido. I’m betting on Kidd creating a giant mech and having a short solo fight vs kaido or big mom or both. Zoro vs kaido in full zoan
I actually think only Zoro will have a 1v1 moment.
Luffy and Kidd are going to take down Kaido like Goku and Frieza taking down Jiren.
The other 3 will take down BM and be knocked by Kaido right after.
What MIGHT happen is Luffy and Kidd going down, Kaido standing up, then Zoro coming with one of his random one shots teleports and finishes Kaido.

Wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldnt be surprised either.
Post automatically merged:

@I'mTired
Now I remembered something.
How can Zoro be Suzaku, the opposite of Seiryu, if Oda himself said that if Zoro would get a DF, he would get the Seiryu one?
So Oda himself sees Zoro as more like an Azure Dragon himself, then a Vermilion Bird.
What you think about this?
 
Last edited:

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#32
Sanji is literally a GOAT.
Lmao.
:stealthblack:

I know we are talking about that cover page or whatever where's there's a santoryuu tiger using bamboos, but where did Oda say Zoro was a shark? SBS i presume? Did he talk about the others, and the reasoning behind all of them? Would be cool to include it here so we can analyze it further.
Post automatically merged:


I actually think only Zoro will have a 1v1 moment.
Luffy and Kidd are going to take down Kaido like Goku and Frieza taking down Jiren.
The other 3 will take down BM and be knocked by Kaido right after.
What MIGHT happen is Luffy and Kidd going down, Kaido standing up, then Zoro coming with one of his random one shots teleports and finishes Kaido.

Wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldnt be surprised either.
Post automatically merged:

@I'mTired
Now I remembered something.
How can Zoro be Suzaku, the opposite of Seiryu, if Oda himself said that if Zoro would get a DF, he would get the Seiryu one?
So Oda himself sees Zoro as more like an Azure Dragon himself, then a Vermilion Bird.
What you think about this?
Didn't oda say he didn't want zoro to actually eat the fruit but his sword.
 
#33
Sanji is literally a GOAT.
Lmao.
:stealthblack:

I know we are talking about that cover page or whatever where's there's a santoryuu tiger using bamboos, but where did Oda say Zoro was a shark? SBS i presume? Did he talk about the others, and the reasoning behind all of them? Would be cool to include it here so we can analyze it further.
Post automatically merged:


I actually think only Zoro will have a 1v1 moment.
Luffy and Kidd are going to take down Kaido like Goku and Frieza taking down Jiren.
The other 3 will take down BM and be knocked by Kaido right after.
What MIGHT happen is Luffy and Kidd going down, Kaido standing up, then Zoro coming with one of his random one shots teleports and finishes Kaido.

Wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldnt be surprised either.
Post automatically merged:

@I'mTired
Now I remembered something.
How can Zoro be Suzaku, the opposite of Seiryu, if Oda himself said that if Zoro would get a DF, he would get the Seiryu one?
So Oda himself sees Zoro as more like an Azure Dragon himself, then a Vermilion Bird.
What you think about this?
Oda said his sword would eat the dragon DF not him.
Zoro is the tiger because A tiger figure representing Zoro was shown on Odas desk.
 

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
#34
Didn't oda say he didn't want zoro to actually eat the fruit but his sword.
Yes, but still gonna give Zoro the Seiryu power. That would be his "opposite", if we take into consideration the arguments presented on this thread. That's why I brought it up.
Wouldn't it contradict with this line of thought?
Post automatically merged:

Oda said his sword would eat the dragon DF not him.
Zoro is the tiger because A tiger figure representing Zoro was shown on Odas desk.
The Azure Dragon reigns over the Tiger zodiac sign.
Coincidence? :P
 
#35
Yes, but still gonna give Zoro the Seiryu power. That would be his "opposite", if we take into consideration the arguments presented on this thread. That's why I brought it up.
Wouldn't it contradict with this line of thought?
Post automatically merged:


The Azure Dragon reigns over the Tiger zodiac sign.
Coincidence? :P





The tiger and the Eastern dragon, A fated metting indeed.

Zoro The tiger Against Kaido the Eastern Dragon.

Destiny awaits, Zoro will Slay Kaido.

Yeah but Zoro's different dont worry he will be okay.


Believe

Believe

ZKK!
 
#39
no because zoro is supposed to be the tiger which goes into the story of the tiger and dragon. The Phoenix only fits sanji. You say you aren’t debating if it fits him but he’s the only way it actually fights. Especially since zoro has said before sanji looks like he is about to transform
So you're not gonna address to why Oda potrayed Sanji as a goat? Can you show me something concretes to go with your take on Sanji being the phoenix?
I'm severely sleep deprived right now, so I will not address everything.
Just the end.
I also think Kaido is Zoro's main fight. But is also Luffy's, Kidd's, Killer's, and Law's. I advocate in the sense that the 5v2 WILL remain a 5v2.
I also advocate that Zoro will have a brief 1v1 against Kaido, occasion during which he will open the scar and be acknowledged.
but I also advocate for the 4 CoC clash.
Who knows how Oda will develop this 5v2. I dont think he invested a lot of panel time on Kidd for nothing.
But as I said before, regardless of the outcome, I just hope for Sanji 1v1 a Calamity. Whatever happens on the roof, happens.
:sweat:
Glad we agree on the topic of Zoro's main fight since it's the main point of the thread. As for how the roof fight is gonna unfold. I agree that what happens will happen.

Now I remembered something.
How can Zoro be Suzaku, the opposite of Seiryu, if Oda himself said that if Zoro would get a DF, he would get the Seiryu one?
So Oda himself sees Zoro as more like an Azure Dragon himself, then a Vermilion Bird.
What you think about this?
First of all, like the other have said, Oda would give it to Zoro's sword. And I think that I didn't just only prove the oppositions between Seiryu and Suzaku, but their similarities also. The two animals complements each other. What the phoenix has over the dragon in favor of Zoro's portrayal is the rebirth ability. And the more non favorable point of Zoro if he was to be compared to be a dragon is the element of stagnation. The two above mentioned reasons are the biggest reasons why Zoro shouldn't be portrayed as a dragon in this arc to me personally.
Sanji is literally a GOAT.
My man Sanji is literally Goat!!!!!!!
Ye I remember that as well, but the wikia lists it as a bighorn sheep for whatever reason so I was just going with that because I'm not knowledgeable on animal's names. It's "bélier" in French, and it think it's cooler sounding than goat.
 
Top