Sorry for coming to the party late, I had 30+ pages to catch up on, I mostly skimmed through though.
My bet is that N'zoth is real, especially after the announcement where he appeared, it said "don't trust your investigations, N'zoth is here". N'zoth is the Old God of Madness, he'll corrupt and incite paranoia and fear into people. I wouldn't put it behind him to make fake writeups to create chaos and madness.
Better butter up your bum
@Melontonin
If you look back, BK had a passive that made ALL investigation type abilities fail on him. I got the message that nothing happened when I tried to check him
They asked, I merely answered. At the time I only knew who I was and what my wincon was, and I suppose I'm easy to convince- sometimes. I didn't feel like I had anything in particular to lose, and I didn't see myself a detriment to Town.
I am kinda sus of myself too, ngl.