You've referenced being a Third Party, do you mind disclosing your role and/or win condition?
Link please?
On day 1, Robin came out that his ability failed on me. His ability is to empower townies to become a magical girl each night and he said if the target is not part of town, the ability will fail. He questioned why his ability failed
That I'm not so sure of why it failed. I claimed Kurumi and I revealed some of my abilities already. You can also see my actions in the write ups so you can question them if you like and I'll answer. I am immune to poisoning and Odd brought the idea that because I am already a 'magical girl', it's possible that the ability can fail. Robin also states that could be a possibility even though there's no role restriction.
Robin is a claimed pro town indie. He survived a superkill despite being rolecrushed. He was also jailed last phase and this phase. I don't feel like pursuing another indie hunt and whoever the jailer is, I hope they are town and can deal with Robin instead.
Thanks for the explanation. I think I'll try going over the writeups later (I am about spent for the day, I just want to quickly clear my alerts and then I'll be logging off).
The idea that empowerment would fail if a character is already a magical girl seems weird to me. I would expect such a restriction to be revealed in a Role PM.
I'd guess that either Robin is Lying or you're not Town. You guys are probably from different factions (if I were to hazard a guess, this is a Scum vs Town confrontation) From the little I'm aware of, Robin's behaviour has seemed off to me and their supposed narrative around the actions that happened to them seems extraordinary (and thus unlikely).
I think I'll keep Robin as my pick. Their flip should be informative regarding the debate you've had with them.