I'm still catching up (I started from page 380 and I'm on page 385 now).
My thoughts on the game so far.
Town Reads
- Reborn
- I liked his interrogation of Robin and Queen
- He felt authentic in his questioning and was aggressive in his Scum hunting. That fits the Town!Reborn meta I'm used to.
- OddOddFruit
- He seems genuine, and the general feeling I'm getting from him feels Townish.
- This is more good vibes from him than a meta read or analysis of his posts, so I'm less confident.
Scummy
- Robin
- I don't understand why they said they would be willing to see their captor dead despite believing that their captor is innocent.
- If I'm understanding things correctly, they claimed Third Party and so are not Town regardless. I think I might try and ISO them later on.
- Could someone please tell me what Robin claimed?
- FB
- His name was tabooed.
- This suggests Scum might be trying to prevent him from getting Lynched.
- He was also voted onto the Council despite being not generally being a good Town (or any faction really) player or appearing particularly Town I think.
- His rationale for his actions and his claiming felt very nonsensical and didn't really make much sense to me. This may just be his usual play though.
- Another alternative is that he's being framed or setup because Scum knows he's an easy Lynch.
- If I have the time, ISOing Beta would be ideal.
For now, I think I'll pick Robin. I may change my pick after reading more and ISOing the particular players I mentioned.
Yeet @Robin
@novaselinenever
@Fujishiro: you asked for my opinions.