[FNZ] Role Madness [Season 2] Round 1 - The Dancing Valentine

[Ratchet]

I think it also bears repeating that we are yet to see any evidence at all that scum are actually present between Poison, Emi and Mango. It's very possible that we're arguing which town to lynch here. So lynching through all three is dangerous thinking at best. Scum logic otherwise.

 

[Lindltaylor]

@Ratchet for now I have high incentive to believe that Mango is not scum. So if it's not Emilia, then I assume we are all going with poison. I personally want to go for poison.

@Poison please do come and help us figure out your alignment.

 

[MangoSenpai]

I think it also bears repeating that we are yet to see any evidence at all that scum are actually present between Poison, Emi and Mango. It's very possible that we're arguing which town to lynch here. So lynching through all three is dangerous thinking at best. Scum logic otherwise.

It's not impossible, but the fact that we have a repeat of what was supposed to be yesterday, I really doubt the hosts would make an impossible to win in game event. Even if this is a Mafia ability or whatever, I just don't see how it would be balanced.

 

[Lindltaylor]

Also I want to just say that @Jew D. Boy isn't usually like this. I think he too is probably ticked off now. I've played 2 games with the guy and he's actually pretty chill.

I strongly advice players to not take these games too seriously. We all make mistakes and that's fine tbh.

 

[Lindltaylor]

Also I want to just say that @Jew D. Boy isn't usually like this. I think he too is probably ticked off now. I've played 2 games with the guy and he's actually pretty chill.

I strongly advice players to not take these games too seriously. We all make mistakes and that's fine tbh.

I meant this for @Ratchet lol.

First time seeing you ticked off though Ratchet.. or maybe not. I've seen it before I guess lol.

Anyway, regarding the game. @krogothwolf what do you make of Flower calling you a hiding scum yesterday? Didn't see you defend yourself against that. Were you just buys?

 

[Ratchet]

It's not impossible, but the fact that we have a repeat of what was supposed to be yesterday, I really doubt the hosts would make an impossible to win in game event. Even if this is a Mafia ability or whatever, I just don't see how it would be balanced.

I think it's a repeat because the modkill yesterday circumvented the lynch restriction. So for it to be fair then I can see why it would get repeated today. That's also why I'm no longer proposing we test it out - if it were a fake writeup, forcing it again today would make no sense.

 

[MangoSenpai]

I think it's a repeat because the modkill yesterday circumvented the lynch restriction. So for it to be fair then I can see why it would get repeated today. That's also why I'm no longer proposing we test it out - if it were a fake writeup, forcing it again today would make no sense.

That's what I said, just with other words.
All I'm saying is that it wouldn't be fair if all 3 were town, it doesn't make much sense to put in a thing like this that is impossible for Town to win.

 

[Lindltaylor]

I think it's a repeat because the modkill yesterday circumvented the lynch restriction. So for it to be fair then I can see why it would get repeated today. That's also why I'm no longer proposing we test it out - if it were a fake writeup, forcing it again today would make no sense.

This is true, especially since Noctis even acknowledged that Midnight was lynched rather than modkilled.

 

[Ratchet]

That's what I said, just with other words.
All I'm saying is that it wouldn't be fair if all 3 were town, it doesn't make much sense to put in a thing like this that is impossible for Town to win.

At the same token, would it make sense for a member of scum to be in there, essentially outing themselves? They increase their chances of being lynched to 1 in 3 everytime, that seems weird to me. I think scum *could* be present, but I don't think they *have* to be. And that kinda works as a punishment for town engaging in mechanics carelessly I feel.

 

[MangoSenpai]

At the same token, would it make sense for a member of scum to be in there, essentially outing themselves? They increase their chances of being lynched to 1 in 3 everytime, that seems weird to me. I think scum *could* be present, but I don't think they *have* to be. And that kinda works as a punishment for town engaging in mechanics carelessly I feel.

This logic doesn't make sense to me. We can't avoid lynching one of the 3, which means that one of them must die no matter what. Why would a mechanic like that be unwinnable for town? There's a 1/3 chance that one of us is the maf. You could mislynch 2 times. But I don't think it would be good for the game.. Mafia usually got very strong abilities to make up for the fact that they're greatly outnumbered.

1 has to be mafia imo. Don't see why we're forced to lose a Town like this..

 

[Ratchet]

This logic doesn't make sense to me. We can't avoid lynching one of the 3, which means that one of them must die no matter what. Why would a mechanic like that be unwinnable for town? There's a 1/3 chance that one of us is the maf. You could mislynch 2 times. But I don't think it would be good for the game.. Mafia usually got very strong abilities to make up for the fact that they're greatly outnumbered.

1 has to be mafia imo. Don't see why we're forced to lose a Town like this..

Because if it is down to losing the RPS game, it punishes scum way more than it punishes the Town. Because it tells the Town that one of the three is scum, and that if that same person shows up multiple times without scum being lynched then they're almost locked to be scum just through mechanics. I think it makes more sense for the mechanic to just grab losers from each pair and make the town lynch between them, if town keep doing what gets them in that issue then that's on them really. I mean we'll see I guess, I'm not fond of lynching through all three people here though until scum is found.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Also I want to just say that @Jew D. Boy isn't usually like this. I think he too is probably ticked off now. I've played 2 games with the guy and he's actually pretty chill.

I strongly advice players to not take these games too seriously. We all make mistakes and that's fine tbh.

Would really like to know what I did wrong here...I criticized his gameplay like we all do to each other, and then he threw a bevy of personal insults at me. I’ve seen people get into tiffs like this and apologize afterward; he doubled down and stood by his rhetoric. This isn’t a “both sides” kind of deal, he decided to be an asshole for no reason in a game on an anime forum.

 

[Finalbeta]

Last DP was dumb IMO, but I suppose I've no prior experience with no claim games.
I still didn't like Usopp's drowning the thread though. It felt like we were just trying to carry on and try for sins and false alarms.

I was gonna say that all I know is that Flower didn't kill Usopp, but now she's outed as town anyway so well that's fine.

Like I just said, All I know is that Flower couldn't have killed Usopp. That's all I know from my night

No don't reveal anything. I asked those when I forgot that the game was no claim. Please don't reveal anymore info.

Mango was about to put himself into quite a trouble here. He also made up that poem.

A scum would more likely not risk such stunts.

I think I may have gotten it right and Emilia, Alibaba and krog are indeed the last scums. It should be either Emilia or Mango to be the last.

 

[MangoSenpai]

Because if it is down to losing the RPS game, it punishes scum way more than it punishes the Town. Because it tells the Town that one of the three is scum, and that if that same person shows up multiple times without scum being lynched then they're almost locked to be scum just through mechanics. I think it makes more sense for the mechanic to just grab losers from each pair and make the town lynch between them, if town keep doing what gets them in that issue then that's on them really. I mean we'll see I guess, I'm not fond of lynching through all three people here though until scum is found.

But I never got challenged to RPS, so I can't have lost.
I don't know tough.. The more I think about it the more uneasy I feel about this all..

I know I'm flipflopping a lot right now, but I don't know man.. I feel like I want to trust @Finalbeta and @Flower's read for now..
While I'm uneasy about Poison, I think I'm gonna just stick with QueenEmi afterall..

Vote QueenEmilia
@Noctis @Rej @AL sama

 

[T-Pein™]

So? Coming in next day and lynching her cause she pushed me hard isn't a good way to go about things, you come off as spiteful scum.

Noted your soft defense on flower

 

[MangoSenpai]

Noted your soft defense on flower

put me on that list too.

 

[T-Pein™]

put me on that list too.

No,

[Vote lynch Poison]

 

[QueenEmilia]

But I never got challenged to RPS, so I can't have lost.
I don't know tough.. The more I think about it the more uneasy I feel about this all..

I know I'm flipflopping a lot right now, but I don't know man.. I feel like I want to trust @Finalbeta and @Flower's read for now..
While I'm uneasy about Poison, I think I'm gonna just stick with QueenEmi afterall..

Vote QueenEmilia
@Noctis @Rej @AL sama

why are you sticking with me?

you called me out for not replying to lind (when I did but u just missed it) but u didn’t reply to my question earlier, what makes poison and flower less sus than me?

 

[T-Pein™]

put me on that list too.

You will commit sudoku if queen flips town?

 

[T-Pein™]

Not a fan of

Krogoth.
Flower
Poison.