Status
Not open for further replies.

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
It may be my unfamiliarity, but why would Cal need a good read on Conq to tell him to sheep him? Seems like it wouldn’t matter would it? If I’m confident in my own reads then people sheeping me would just be more voting power for myself right? I wouldn’t think that the “sheep’s” alignment would matter. Or am I missing something?
Sheep votes are votes generally thrown without reason or suspicion. So it makes it hard to actually judge these votes when the player putting this vote served no purpose than to blindly follow. So you won't know what sort of vote actually classifies as suspicious.

So in an environment that encourages sheeping, votes thrown without suspicion or reason allows scum to throw in potentially harmful votes on random wagons.
 
Sheep votes are votes generally thrown without reason or suspicion. So it makes it hard to actually judge these votes when the player putting this vote served no purpose than to blindly follow. So you won't know what sort of vote actually classifies as suspicious.

So in an environment that encourages sheeping, votes thrown without suspicion or reason allows scum to throw in potentially harmful votes on random wagons.
Okay this makes sense. Thank you lol.
 
So I think we are dealing with specific conversions this game as I mentioned in that post. Most probably roles that don't have stand abilities. Since conversions aren't mentioned in the write ups, any investigations that yield a flavor name of a character that doesn't have a natural stand might be a candidate that has been converted.
If there are conversions then it has to be From Kiras Father, hes the one that fires arrows into people giving them stands and then having them protect Kira.

I dont know about Kira being Mafia though, he should be more like an indie SK since in the anime hes alone and his Father and group of people he gave stands to act independently.

Either way i feel like the idea of cult would work with the Flavor of those guys.

I dont remember there being any other thing that happens in the anime that would count as a “conversion”, maybe Keigo (okuyasus brother) who turns people into stand users too.



I always err on the side of caution, my love :blush:
Caution is fine but you assumed and said it as if it was the case before asking the hosts. This could induce other players into thinking so too, and thus make them not want to share night actions.

Which is more to the benefit of scum than town. So hopefully @melont
 

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
If there are conversions then it has to be From Kiras Father, hes the one that fires arrows into people giving them stands and then having them protect Kira.

I dont know about Kira being Mafia though, he should be more like an indie SK since in the anime hes alone and his Father and group of people he gave stands to act independently.

Either way i feel like the idea of cult would work with the Flavor of those guys.

I dont remember there being any other thing that happens in the anime that would count as a “conversion”, maybe Keigo (okuyasus brother) who turns people into stand users too.
Hm, so a cult and an indie SK. It could be possible. A mafia having conversion and killing abilities sounds pretty powerful imo. It would make sense if the conversion and killing were done by 2 separate entities.

Caution is fine but you assumed and said it as if it was the case before asking the hosts. This could induce other players into thinking so too, and thus make them not want to share night actions.
Oh, not at all. I was just advising that certain claims could be punishable and certain investigative results as well cause of the Killer Queen Bite the Dust ability I read on the wiki.
 
Oh my god! I sent by mistake.. well this was a waste of a post.

@Melontonin can we claim actions or is that not recommended either?
Cal has six posts, though.
Yes and The 6 he made are entirely useless.
1 of which he asked someone else to sheep him and just somehow trusts Conquistador.

I think it warrants a push for a reaction at the very least.
A common misconception from people who either think they can read me like a book, or are intimidated by my scum play. I don't self meta myself but if I did as someone who is very very self aware, the better word would be "effort". My activity means nothing, but since I'm available and able to actively participate I will.
I can attest, but i know you cant lie to me so are you town ? :catblush:


It may be my unfamiliarity, but why would Cal need a good read on Conq to tell him to sheep him? Seems like it wouldn’t matter would it? If I’m confident in my own reads then people sheeping me would just be more voting power for myself right? I wouldn’t think that the “sheep’s” alignment would matter. Or am I missing something?
If Cal is scum then he would want people to sheep him either way, i dont know what Conquistador is and neither should he. But the way he talked to him pinged me a bit, it felt like maybe he knew Conq was town isomething.

Thats the point for me.


Fuji asked four different players for a reaction to Cal's six posts, then voted him and said he was dipping for the night. Yeah, it's not great optics to me. I mean, if you're going to suss someone for telling another to sheep them, then by all means go ahead, I just think that it's a bit misguided at this point in the game.
I asked because i was wondering if anybody saw what i saw, and im sorry but at this point in the game you gotta start somewhere and pressure somebody.

But oh please guide “misguided” Ol me!
 
Wait so I'm slow, do we think there's a cult + mafia or is it more likely to be an either or situation given there's only twenty players?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top