[FNZ] Role Madness [Season 2] Round 13 - Harry Potter

[Jew D. Boy]

Can you explain about this a little bit more?

What happened to me? Well, if it wasn’t Gram, I’d like to see if anyone will own up to it…maybe they can explain what they did, if he’s actually telling the truth.

 

[ConquistadoR]

What happened to me? Well, if it wasn’t Gram, I’d like to see if anyone will own up to it…maybe they can explain what they did, if he’s actually telling the truth.

No like how much more time do you have?

 

[Gambit]

wow what a night there

 

[Jew D. Boy]

The problem I have with this is it doesn't really explain Day 1 at all. If I just take roles aside and focus on Mafia it's incongruent.

I’m not gonna pretend like I was totally focused during the last day phase, so I’m not sure exactly what it doesn’t explain.

Post automatically merged: Sep 18, 2021

No like how much more time do you have?

I wasn’t given a timeframe, but something happened to me and it’s the kind of thing that a) only a certain character could reasonably do, and b) isn’t something I can survive without intervention. Don’t expect anyone to save me, since I’m not particularly good at this game or motivated to be, but I’ve come up with a crackpot theory around it and if I’m right, Gram isn’t who he says he is.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

The janitor bit does make me wary, since Gram could just be using Destroya’s role as a fake claim…I still have a theory about what happened to me that would implicate him as scum in spite of what he says, but I’m not sure I should share it at the moment.

So Dest could be Ginny Wesley

 

[Gambit]

.

This is all you hace to say? I suggest you drop out.

Anyway, I am very excited to hear more from Rej.

 

[Ratchet]

I’m not gonna pretend like I was totally focused during the last day phase, so I’m not sure exactly what it doesn’t explain.

Gram vouched for Nick. If Gram is scum, what does he gain from that? Nick didn't say anything about it, which tells me he has at least some knowledge on Gram even if he's not claiming it, so then for Gram to openly buddy Nick becomes an extremely risky prospect, and the alternative (that is, Nick and Gram are scum) is even riskier.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Gram vouched for Nick. If Gram is scum, what does he gain from that? Nick didn't say anything about it, which tells me he has at least some knowledge on Gram even if he's not claiming it, so then for Gram to openly buddy Nick becomes an extremely risky prospect, and the alternative (that is, Nick and Gram are scum) is even riskier.

I agree, it would be sloppy if it’s true…but I’m usually of the mind that it could be a big-brain play to deflect, like it’s so obvious that we don’t pursue it and they hide in plain sight. The problem with that is it leads ME to get too much into the tinfoil

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Vote Lynch Grammaton

 

[Grammaton]

Can I get your theories on why you think I know Nick is town, specifically?

(Outside of the obvious i could be scum and he’s not on my team play)

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Can I get your theories on why you think I know Nick is town, specifically?

(Outside of the obvious i could be scum and he’s not on my team play)

You answered it already.

Can i have the name of your abilities quick.

 

[ConquistadoR]

isn’t something I can survive without intervention

I think I can. How long do you have left?

 

[Ratchet]

I agree, it would be sloppy if it’s true…but I’m usually of the mind that it could be a big-brain play to deflect, like it’s so obvious that we don’t pursue it and they hide in plain sight. The problem with that is it leads ME to get too much into the tinfoil

I mean, to be clear, of the possibilities in play I think it's more likely that Grammaton is scum and Nick Town, than Grammaton and Nick both being scum is. But in any case, I feel like I have to assume some level of misplay in either of those two scenarios, which I'm generally not fond of doing.

 

[Ratchet]

Can I get your theories on why you think I know Nick is town, specifically?

(Outside of the obvious i could be scum and he’s not on my team play)

...? You've already claimed his name is listed in your PM.

 

[Grammaton]

You answered it already.

Can i have the name of your abilities quick.

No you may not

 

[ConquistadoR]

I mean, to be clear, of the possibilities in play I think it's more likely that Grammaton is scum and Nick Town, than Grammaton and Nick both being scum is. But in any case, I feel like I have to assume some level of misplay in either of those two scenarios, which I'm generally not fond of doing.

Yeah I'd go with this. Its tough to see Gram as scum, openly connecting himself to another scum on D1

 

[Grammaton]

...? You've already claimed his name is listed in your PM.

Yes, but why? In what context?

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

(Outside of the obvious i could be scum and he’s not on my team play)

Actually if you end up being scum, the ropes on Nick throat would tighten thn not

 

[Ratchet]

Yes, but why? In what context?

I'm not sure what purpose on speculating on this is supposed to serve, but my guess would be Masons or your role is tied in some way to his. From there I can speculate as to flavour reasons why that would be, but given your claim, it should be rather clear why I'd prefer not to.

 

[Seraphoenix]

Vote Lynch Grammaton

goodbye