I think the issue here is that Gambit doesn’t sound townie at all. He was very satisfied with getting me lynched despite what mechanical reasons to not do that. Tonally he seemed ready to give up before he was thrown a rope and I’m pretty sure mafia is going to make abilities to let them mimic others.
Only cause for doubt is the quick draw in which Gambit said he was Parasite/Venom. It was a very sloppy claim knowing that the real Parasite/Venom is out there.