Nah Oda is not consistent.
1 month ago Kid lost to a 3YC
Law was overpower by Godflamingo and EpicFujitora.
In 1 month timelapse the only improvment that we saw for Law was awakening (we know that he has no CoC) and we havent see good hacky feat for Law so far due to overused of axe df power.
For Kidd we know that he lost to Cracker (He had very good use of his df, + good stats in armament hacky he could bypass Luffy hacky an hacky that was enough for defeating Don Flamingo). That tell me that cracker would win vs Law too.
Now we having see any major fight for law,Kid (kid got betrayed by Apoo when Kaido felt from the sky so we can't count that as a fight)
That leave us directly to the rooftop fight, in which clearly Luffy&Zoro overshadow this 2.
1 chapter ago, we got this so call new PU for Law/Kid awaken use of the df, that sound was kind effective on Big Mom (we know Oda overhype statment in general so I take it for what it is)
Now we can clearly say that a guy like Katakuri that master awakening df + other form of hacky is definitely more lethal than Law&Kid that only recently used awaken df without any hacky feat.
To conclude yeah Kid and Law are at best 1YC commander.