[FNZ] Role Madness Alabasta Arc (Smoker and Mafia victory)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Your role sounds pro scum needing 2 Townies dead, basically.
Eh…you have to outlive 3 roles. 2 of which are Town. That does not sound pro Town at all. At best you are neutral and like a Survivor type. Which is fine, but my role is literally pro Town. I cannot win without Town.
It does not sound like pro town indie.
It *mathematically* is pro town. My role needs 2 townies and 1 scum dead. The ratio of town to scum is likely to be considerably higher than 2:1. That means the one scum dead is more damaging to the scum faction than the townie deaths are to the town one. Not to mention that the scum I need dead is probably the main scum role, whereas the townies I need dead are not Strawhats.

Given that we are on the third cycle with no scum deaths, my voting power is likely to be considerably useful for the town in terms of them remaining in the game. I have an interest in that, because none of the roles flipped so far have been who I need dead, with the exception /maybe/ of Jules. So that's how my role helps. My noble voting power is a considerable voting swing.

What I ask for in return in that townies help me work towards my win. Scum can easily help me because they can eventually afford to out themselves, lynch Crocodile and then use my voting power to win a cycle earlier. Obviously the other townies I need dead will have to be dead for that but so it goes. Town have a harder time but when we see several scum flips the roles I need dead can sacrifice themselves and with my vote counting for two the loss of voting power will be only one. Which isn't an awful trade off for me coming forward.
 
It *mathematically* is pro town. My role needs 2 townies and 1 scum dead. The ratio of town to scum is likely to be considerably higher than 2:1. That means the one scum dead is more damaging to the scum faction than the townie deaths are to the town one. Not to mention that the scum I need dead is probably the main scum role, whereas the townies I need dead are not Strawhats.

Given that we are on the third cycle with no scum deaths, my voting power is likely to be considerably useful for the town in terms of them remaining in the game. I have an interest in that, because none of the roles flipped so far have been who I need dead, with the exception /maybe/ of Jules. So that's how my role helps. My noble voting power is a considerable voting swing.

What I ask for in return in that townies help me work towards my win. Scum can easily help me because they can eventually afford to out themselves, lynch Crocodile and then use my voting power to win a cycle earlier. Obviously the other townies I need dead will have to be dead for that but so it goes. Town have a harder time but when we see several scum flips the roles I need dead can sacrifice themselves and with my vote counting for two the loss of voting power will be only one. Which isn't an awful trade off for me coming forward.
Well, that‘s up for Town to decide tbf. I, too, would like to see some scum blood because it helps me for my wincon.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Well, that‘s up for Town to decide tbf. I, too, would like to see some scum blood because it helps me for my wincon.
What is there for Town to decide? Everything I said in that post was factual. My win con is more damaging for scum than it is for the town, and right now Town need my vote more than scum do. I've outlined what I expect from both factions in exchange for my co-operation, and as of now I'm clearly town-siding. It's not a negotiation - if what I've outlined isn't acceptable for some reason, then town are free to lynch me or vig me if they must. Pointless, in my opinion, but there you go. I tried just playing town last DP but only like 4 players actually bothered reading so I figured if town aren't going to bother scum hunting I certainly won't be.
 
It *mathematically* is pro town. My role needs 2 townies and 1 scum dead. The ratio of town to scum is likely to be considerably higher than 2:1. That means the one scum dead is more damaging to the scum faction than the townie deaths are to the town one. Not to mention that the scum I need dead is probably the main scum role, whereas the townies I need dead are not Strawhats.

Given that we are on the third cycle with no scum deaths, my voting power is likely to be considerably useful for the town in terms of them remaining in the game. I have an interest in that, because none of the roles flipped so far have been who I need dead, with the exception /maybe/ of Jules. So that's how my role helps. My noble voting power is a considerable voting swing.

What I ask for in return in that townies help me work towards my win. Scum can easily help me because they can eventually afford to out themselves, lynch Crocodile and then use my voting power to win a cycle earlier. Obviously the other townies I need dead will have to be dead for that but so it goes. Town have a harder time but when we see several scum flips the roles I need dead can sacrifice themselves and with my vote counting for two the loss of voting power will be only one. Which isn't an awful trade off for me coming forward.
What is there for Town to decide? Everything I said in that post was factual. My win con is more damaging for scum than it is for the town, and right now Town need my vote more than scum do. I've outlined what I expect from both factions in exchange for my co-operation, and as of now I'm clearly town-siding. It's not a negotiation - if what I've outlined isn't acceptable for some reason, then town are free to lynch me or vig me if they must. Pointless, in my opinion, but there you go. I tried just playing town last DP but only like 4 players actually bothered reading so I figured if town aren't going to bother scum hunting I certainly won't be.
I’m in, just help me scum hunt lol. Please.

We need a scum flip so bad and I’m in my element when I don’t have Town leaders to bounce off of.

There’s so many inactives/low contributors this game that Idk what to do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top