[FNZ] Light game Death Note Mini Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
vote doesnt matter, u r pushing and throwing suspicion his way that is fueling votes by others on him
i was asking questions that deserved to be asked
1.why didnt he claim indie at the start if he was protown

2. why would scum out themselves unless you knew they didnt start sepeartely
i would have voted if i felt his claim was bullshit
if i havent voted
pretty tell tale sign i dont seem all that convinced. mellow is hardly a fake claim.

you have voted him
you have asked similar questions , you recognize ali looks bad
and now want to save it all
what a joke.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
all im saying is this lynch benefits mafia more than town

if u can find me a logical reason why ali is fake claiming or why u think he is mafia, im willing to concede

but just wasting an entire lynch based on "if" is a no deal
 
save what? town from wasting a lynch on claimed indie?

remember how it was with gaara? ur gna repeat the same sht again where u mislynch for no logical reason

at best ali is a hostile indie, but even so, why cant we rb him or let maf deal with him. why do we do the work for maf?

and if there is a hostile indie in the game, then i doubt we have 3 mafia. thats just too much anti town
You're reaching hard here Ekko, fuck night actions. We don't even know what we have access to. You're using every angle possible to try and deflect here
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
Nobody is going to counter claim Mellow here, because presuming he's indie he has a wincon to fulfill and is not concerned with correcting an outted scum.

Also, what do you mean *if* Light/Ryuk/Misa is the scum faction? I'm assuming this is your presumption, because if it isn't, your defense of him makes absolutely no sense. You better be certain about this.
what will the scum faction be then?

light/misa/mellow?
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
You're using motivated reasoning and the "it can't possibly be a fake claim" to shore up a poor defense of him. You are not considering his play, nor the wrongful assumptions you might be making here, such as the fact that he might not be given a fake claim to begin with, so this could be his best bet.
yes thats u making the assumption that fake claims exists
im working with the more probaably option that mellow is not a fake claim, and if it was, it will not be given to ryuk of all people, who we suspect ali to be

so rethink this
 
@Ultra drop ur crackpot theory as well im interested
Scum faction is actually Near/Mellow (+ L?). Basically the conclusion Prof came to earlier when I gave him a hint. So far, there's nothing explicitly implying Light has to be mafia, and several things would start to make a bit more sense. A bit premature of a conclusion though, but we cannot use "BaBa WoUlD nEvEr ClAiM MelLoW" as an excuse
 
Ekko, we‘re not derailing from Ali now. There are too many inconsistencies with him to ever consider him trustworthy. He could be anything now and if there‘s a real Mello, ofc he would not cc and play into scum‘s hands. That angle is just a bad reason to not lynch him.
 
yes thats u making the assumption that fake claims exists
im working with the more probaably option that mellow is not a fake claim, and if it was, it will not be given to ryuk of all people, who we suspect ali to be

so rethink this
If scum isn't given fake claims a Mellow claim is probably the best he could do here, anything else results in a risk of him getting counter claimed.
 
@Flower @Dr_Professor83 pls consider the ali wagon

lynching someone that claimed mellow day 1 is not the optimal play

i know alis play has been very questionable. we could atleast cop pr roleblock him or smthing

can we explore dest/don/zolo more?

i dont like lanji/ultra pushes on alibaba tbh. seems opportunistic and i wont give them that
I’m very skeptical about Ali.

I do see where it might not be an optimal lynch but it’s going to be hard to walk away from this one for one of those.

We don’t have a lot of time to properly explore another wagon since we only have a little over an hour left. It’ll basically be a glorified CFD.

I think Zolo’s cryptic post have been super weird even for him, but he’s known to be weird.

Don has barely posted. From his few posts he’d a little off, but I don’t think it’s weirder than Alibaba has handled this Mello claim.

Dest I’d want to give some time so I can see more. I feel like I can probably read him better as we go but it’s too early for me to hang him yet.

You keep saying we can’t afford 3 mislynches, but with Alibaba possibly actually being scum here Idk that our chances of nailing scum are much higher CFDing and hoping on one of the people you named even if all of them are suspicious than by lynching Alibaba .

Not to mention we will probably learn a lot from Alibaba’s flip if we do lynch him.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
i was asking questions that deserved to be asked
1.why didnt he claim indie at the start if he was protown

2. why would scum out themselves unless you knew they didnt start sepeartely
i would have voted if i felt his claim was bullshit
if i havent voted
pretty tell tale sign i dont seem all that convinced. mellow is hardly a fake claim.

you have voted him
you have asked similar questions , you recognize ali looks bad
and now want to save it all
what a joke.
yea he looked pretty terrible and idk what hes doing
but i buy the claim

which is why flavor claims ruin games
idk what ratchet has in store to counter this, probably the good ol deathnote

if flavor claims werent allowed i'd lynch ali on the spot
 
Scum faction is actually Near/Mellow (+ L?). Basically the conclusion Prof came to earlier when I gave him a hint. So far, there's nothing explicitly implying Light has to be mafia, and several things would start to make a bit more sense. A bit premature of a conclusion though, but we cannot use "BaBa WoUlD nEvEr ClAiM MelLoW" as an excuse
what was scum faction last time you played
 
Let's pause here and address the elephant in the room - you think this guy openly claims Light Yagami as scum? I'm not familiar with him, but you can't just soft push on him, you gotta address this and make a stance here
I think he might actually do it.

But he’s super weird sometimes in these games.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top