some things to dissect here
"I would characterize his focus this game as very narrow - he interacts mainly with a handful of players, most of whom are also his suspects (Me, Enryu, X)."
narrow focus as in forcing interactions with your scumreads which is perfectly normal?
you might want to read d1 where a significant amount of your interactions were simply around alibaba and zem
that is a perfectly natural way of solving the game than throwing a name out and showng no effort to fllow through or put pressure on.
"I don’t like his hedging on baba, he’s involved with pressuring him and seems to follow along with why he’s suspicious but is very easily turned the other way, I don’t sense any investment from him."
i just dont think alibaba's claim was fake while you got too hung up on the idea he was mafia. pressure and interaction got him to talk, explain his intentions and fully claim. congrats you lynched an indie , might go arguably worse today.
"Finally, I wouldn't say this with full confidence, but Enryu/X seem plausibly townie."
one of the failed kills and a claim
not really a novel take.
hope noe of you pranked us with pretending to be attacked, if thats even possible 
