General & Others Which crew has the best Yonkou Commanders??

[Eagle]

Which crew has the best Yonkou Commanders? Not only YC1, but also YC2 and YC3.

 

[Gear]

My opinion, is Shanks crew: Beckman, Lucky Roux and Yassop
The why:

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Every crew has good right hands or YC1's.

Kaido's crew has Queen, which is a double edged sword.
Linlin has Smoothie who is non existent.
Whitebeard has Jozu who is currently a cripple but otherwise was going toe to toe with Shichibukai and an Admiral.

So whitebeard wins the YC2 round.

Kaido has Jack. Which is a detriment.
Linlin has Cracker, who is pretty decent.
Whitebeard has Vista, who fought Mihawk and jumped Akainu with Marco when needed to.

So again, goes to the Whitebeard pirates.

All around quality goes to the WBs. Can't judge Shanks or BB yet.

 

[roronoa_fan]

 

[kumae]

Everyone less meme

 

[kom5]

Whitebeard overall
Marco, Visa and Jozu

Shanks because they look cool

Kaido weak trio

Linlin trash trio

 

[Kiiro]

I would say Kaido. Since his commanders seek power.

 

[Gear]

Linlin trash trio

Everyone less meme

if not even Katakuri can save that crew, then it's really sad

 

[Seth]

Shanks.

 

[Charlotte Horchata]

So many focusing on power scaling as if the OP even mentioned it

How sad of a fandom. No design, psychology of the characters, themes...? Is everything about who punches harder?

 

[Finalbeta]

Should be the RHP considering Benn's majestic portrayal in particular but also their overall numbers.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

None of them tbh. Smoothie and Cracker can't compared to the likes of Katakuri. Queen has the personality but somewhat lacking as a fighter. King is a good YC overall. Jack is just....... Jozu is meh while Vista is alright, Marco is awesome. Shanks' Commanders have good designs but lacking personalities and motives.

 

[PirateKingDrew]

I'm going to ignore powerscaling as best for me which ones did i like in the story, who had the best impact on paper and who left a lasting impression.

so the winner for me as of chapter 1040 is Katakuri who gave us the best 1 on 1 Luffy fight in the series since Lucci

 

[Finalbeta]

If Benn was really about as potent as Shanks

Imagine that folks... :cheers:

 

[thedarkdragon11]

WBP, no contest... No idea about RHP, BBP...

 

[Ask D question]

-Strongest commanders goes to shanks

-Most interesting commanders is kaido

King was greatly written

Queen was really cool and entertaining and I loved what he symbolized

Jack as disappointing as he is was really great as a character and gave more depth to kaido's,

-Coolest commanders is WB

For big mom it's hard to say cause katakuri is a top tier character, but all the rest are trash

Snack got his title removed

Smoothie is redefining the laws of physics because of her non existence

Cracker is fine but not that great although I really liked him

 

[stealthblack]

Rocks had Linlin, kaidou, wb and shiki

 

[BlackLegFring]

The WBP. They are just functionally the best in all-around utility.

The Big Mom pirates would have been in contention if Oda treated Smoothie right.

 

[The White Crane]

Which crew has the best Yonkou Commanders? Not only YC1, but also YC2 and YC3.

Kaido only has a good YC1, but his YC2 is shit. Same with Linlin. Their YC3s are also average.

WB wins this, for now.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Barring Shanks, we have Whitebeard big mom and Kaido.

Whitebeard has three best commanders
Marco
Jozu
Vista

Kaido has two great commanders
King
Queen

But he has Jack who has tenacity but is disappointing

Big Mom only had one good commander
Katakuri

Smoothie was pointless throughout WCI and cracker for some reason couldn’t get past a few trees to take down Nami to beat Luffy.

If we’re talking who had the most enjoyable commanders Kaido hands down.

King - Badass and pretty cool
Queen - Most entertaining character post timeskip
Jack - Gotta respect a man who keeps getting back up