General & Others Rate the One Piece Manga Overall

[Light D Lamperouge]

Just as the title says, rate the One Piece manga. Compare it to other manga, say what it's good/bad points are, if you wish, etc etc.

​

 

[Adam-san]

I love one piece but it has it's flaws.
8 outta 10

 

[MarineHQ]

One piece is a 6/10 for me. Would've rated it a solid 8/10 but Post TS really drags the overall rating down considering how major arcs, characters and revelations that pre-ts teased turn out to be a let down.

Naruto is a solid 8/10 in comparison imo. Hxh is a 9/10 if we only look at the story and not Togashi's schedule.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

One piece is a 6/10 for me.

Naruto is a solid 8/10 in comparison imo

I agree with Naruto>One Piece.

 

[Formerly Seth]

Prior to the time skip, I would rate it 6/10. Let's not overrank Oda because pre ts was just better than post ts. It wasn't some incredible peak of literature.

Overall 3/10. Oda completely killed off what he built.

 

[Ar1sE1998]

Pre timeskip - top tier
Post time skip - Pure garbage not even comparable to jjk, aot and demon slayer
Don't hate on me I'm just stating facts

 

[MarineHQ]

I agree with Naruto>One Piece.

Naruto classic is arguably even a 10/10 for me. Shippuden really held majority of the main issues people have with Naruto.

 

[Natalija]

Hold on, can't change my vote anymore

I rate it 9/10 cause it has its flaws, but at the same time I can't think of anything that deserves 10/10, so in that sense OP is probably > all

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Naruto classic is arguably even a 10/10 for me. Shippuden really held majority of the main issues people have with Naruto.

Yeah I think part 1 of Naruto is top top tier. The early arcs are some of the best I've seen and probably had the best beginning/among the best beginnings possible. The Land of Waves arc with Zabuza and Haku was GOATED. Chuunin exams arc was also pretty good and then Sasuke's retrieval. All very very good ones. Shippuden dragged it down somewhat, especially the ending arcs, but overall Naruto as a manga is still pretty good imo.

 

[ZenZu]

Pre skip - 9.5/10
Post skip - 5.5/10

So overall it's sitting at 7.5/10 I guess. Since it's not over it can go up or down. The conclusion of a story weighs heavily for me.

For context, Bleach is 4/10, Naruto 5/10 (both dogshit conclusions), HxH 9/10 (unfinished though).

 

[Tai long]

I gave one piece 9/10 meaning no manga deserves above 9.
no manga above 300 chapters is above one piece to me

 

[Roo]

bad fanfic

 

[Monster Luffy]

Wano is a big let down but One piece is still better than dogshit mangas new generation shonen like JJK, MHA.

Also, One piece >= Naruto >>>> Naruto shippuden expect pain arc.

I don't rate HxH since it is Hiatus x Hiatus forever.

But one has to admit nothing can be compared to one piece which can still stand strong despite being very big manga and Oda able to do weekly manga unlike Hiatus x Hiatus. The only reason Hiatus x Hiatus didn't get trash talked is because of its hiatus.

The only manga imo above one piece are gintama, aot (minus last arc).

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Pre Ts 8/10
Post Ts 4/10​

 

[DJOMOLO]

Pre TS - 1/10 (No Kaido)
Post TS- 10/10 (Kaido is here and glorious)

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Pre TS - 1/10 (No Kaido)

Spoiler

 

[DJOMOLO]

Spoiler

He is ugly in here. Pre TS is 1/10 for Kaido's bad design

 

[Lord_Braggy]

9/10

 

[roronoa_fan]

One Piece isn't perfect, or even excellent, but it's better than most works that fall into the same category. 7/10

 

[Cross_Marian]

Pre ts: solid 8.5
Post ts: maybe a 4
Let’s say a 6/10 overall