What exactly is the question? I don´t understand at which point I should have "slipped" anything?
One player was converted, likely from scum to town. Then there was another converting attempt but as the target already was converted it instead converted back to scum plus the player who tried to convert him joined him, also becoming scum.
Now check the WU and Prof´s reaction. While I don´t say we should fully trust Prof he pretty much explained why he normally couldn´t have been targeted by the same player twice and if I can remember called it ´meme-worthy´ if someone would have done so.
Don´t know if I got everything right but the list I made was all just my personal assumptions.
Maybe
@Dr_Professor83 has to say anything about the whole situation (again) by himself.
After your disagreement regarding me calling Blue an obvious indie that´s already your second attempt to frame me for something.
Tell me, why and where should I have slipped something? I´m just doing what we should do and make some educated guesses because that early in the game it´s impossible to say things for sure but you have to do something that can be worked with. You´re accusing me of making a slip but you are townlocking people for no reasons or suspecting them for reasons that make much less sense by yourself.