Questions & Mysteries Who is the traitor?

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

ardym

#61
Carrot cannot be the traitor she has a special relationship with Pedro who sacrificed himself for the strawhats
 
#67
Come on, be realistic here. You would have to be on a different level of stupid if you were the traitor and just told Jack "Hey, Raizo is somewhere in this big country. Won't tell you where exactly!"
That could actually have happened. Jack isn't the smartest and he would much rather believe another mink than a samurai.

But what if Nekomamushi is the traitor? :steef:
 
I

Inspector_Mu

#68
Carrot isnt the traitor
She has never been away from zou before
 
Last edited by a moderator:
#70
Everyone of the minks knew where Raizo was hiding.
Srry, I missed the discussion, I don't remember the moment when it was said that they all know that Raizo was in the tree with the Road Poneglyph. Where is it said?

I always thought that the only people who knew where Raizo was were Inu/Neko and the Whale Forest Guardians (cos their duty is protecting the Road Poneglyph within the Whale Tree).
 
#71
That could actually have happened. Jack isn't the smartest and he would much rather believe another mink than a samurai.

But what if Nekomamushi is the traitor? :steef:
Do you just willfully ignore perfect logic now?
I don
Who else could be the traitor? Law? :pepeke:
Kanjuro, on the first page you can read a perfect summary of why he is the prime candidate.
 
#74
Point is, Kanjuro is the only person who can be tied to all the misfortune happening, it's not funny
He isn't actually.

1. Kanjuro didn't know Raizou was on Zou. He only suspected that was where he would be. Whereas Jack knew for a fact that Raizou was definetly on Zou and that the minks were hiding him.

2. The only way to find Zou is by having a mink onboard, or by having a vivre card of someone on Zou. If they had the vivre card of a mink on Zou, then that mink is most likely the traitor, as it would be hard to get a vivre card without that person's knowledge. Kanjuro wasn't on Zou at the time of Jack's first attack, so they couldn't have been using his vivre card, and he isn't a mink so he doesn't know how to get to Zou either.

3. Kanjuro knew about the ankle mark symbolism from before he even left Wano. He could've just snitched to Orochi and Kaido then and had all Kozuki allies captured then.
Orochi and Kaido only found out about the ankle tattoo after its meaning was told to the straw hats, Law and Carrot.
 
Last edited:
#75
He isn't actually.

1. Kanjuro didn't know Raizou was on Zou. He only suspected that was where he would be. Whereas Jack knew for a fact that Raizou was definetly on Zou and that the minks were hiding him.

2. The only way to find Zou is by having a mink onboard, or by having a vivre card of someone on Zou. If they had the vivre card of a mink on Zou, then that mink is most likely the traitor, as it would be hard to get a vivre card without that person's knowledge. Kanjuro wasn't on Zou at the time of Jack's first attack, so they couldn't have been using his vivre card, and he isn't a mink so he doesn't know how to get to Zou either.

3. Kanjuro knew about the ankle mark symbolism from before he even left Wano. He could've just snitched to Orochi and Kaido then and had all Kozuki allies captured then.
Orochi and Kaido only found out about the ankle tattoo after its meaning was told to the straw hats, Law and Carrot.
Kanjuro is a traitor theory just got destroyed lmao. Never thought it made sense. It has to be a mink.
 
#77
Sorry man, but if you actually still believe in Carrot (all evidence against it) while ignoring a way more logical argument for Kanjuuro, it's very ... interesting.
I ask you a question. Further up the page, why not answer?

Srry, I missed the discussion, I don't remember the moment when it was said that they all know that Raizo was in the tree with the Road Poneglyph. Where is it said?

I always thought that the only people who knew where Raizo was were Inu/Neko and the Whale Forest Guardians (cos their duty is protecting the Road Poneglyph within the Whale Tree).
 
#78
Sorry man, but if you actually still believe in Carrot (all evidence against it) while ignoring a way more logical argument for Kanjuuro, it's very ... interesting.
Kanjuro being the traitor makes even less sense than Carrot...:pepeke: I'd even say Nekomamushi is the traitor rather than Kanjuro.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top