Powers & Abilities As a Black Blade, Enma Will Absorb the Opponent's Ryuo Rather Than Zoro's

#41
What do you mean by nerfing your opponent? It would be a power like any other where you meet the right conditions and it harms the enemy. Like Kidds awakening or Crocodile's sand ability is a good comparison. It wouldn't be a god-like power, just something the opponent has to overcome like anything else.
The powers dont suit a protagonist. He supposed to be the one overcoming the opponent not the other way round.
 
#42
The powers dont suit a protagonist. He supposed to be the one overcoming the opponent not the other way round.
His opponent already has to overcome some of his abilities, it's only natural that as his strength increases there's more for the opponent to overcome. What expectations for Zoro's fights do you have lol? Are you pissed that Luffy Law and Kidd awakened, since they should have to overcome things not their opponents?
 
#43
His opponent already has to overcome some of his abilities, it's only natural that as his strength increases there's more for the opponent to overcome. What expectations for Zoro's fights do you have lol? Are you pissed that Luffy Law and Kidd awakened, since they should have to overcome things not their opponents?
The only thing his opponent should be trying to overcome is his swordsmanship....not his magical sentient swords.

Stop comparing him to DF users.
 
#44
The only thing his opponent should be trying to overcome is his swordsmanship....not his magical sentient swords.

Stop comparing him to DF users.
Oda gave swords wills and personalities, not me. I'm just working with what he's writing, rather than denying certain aspects of swords because I don't like it.

"Stop comparing him to DF users"? I was only using your criteria of hero-type characters as an example. So it's ok for Luffy's opponents to have to 'overcome' his various abilities but not Zoro's? And to justify that you've used the one and only difference between the characters I mentioned and Zoro, being that they have devil fruits. Fine, why do Sanji's opponents have to overcome his exoskeleton but Zoro's opponents shouldn't have to overcome any of his abilities?
 
#46
Oda gave swords wills and personalities, not me. I'm just working with what he's writing, rather than denying certain aspects of swords because I don't like it.

"Stop comparing him to DF users"? I was only using your criteria of hero-type characters as an example. So it's ok for Luffy's opponents to have to 'overcome' his various abilities but not Zoro's? And to justify that you've used the one and only difference between the characters I mentioned and Zoro, being that they have devil fruits. Fine, why do Sanji's opponents have to overcome his exoskeleton but Zoro's opponents shouldn't have to overcome any of his abilities?
got to agree with chrono here that power is like a devil fruit and is not fitting of a good guy power it won't make sense for the villain to try and overcome the good guys power it is meant to be the other way around
 
#47
got to agree with chrono here that power is like a devil fruit and is not fitting of a good guy power it won't make sense for the villain to try and overcome the good guys power it is meant to be the other way around
My point is that bad guys overcome good guys' powers all the time. It's definitely valid if you don't think the power makes sense for Zoro's character/personality but acting like he'd be the only strawhat with powers to overcome is just false
 
#49
Oda gave swords wills and personalities, not me. I'm just working with what he's writing, rather than denying certain aspects of swords because I don't like it.

"Stop comparing him to DF users"? I was only using your criteria of hero-type characters as an example. So it's ok for Luffy's opponents to have to 'overcome' his various abilities but not Zoro's? And to justify that you've used the one and only difference between the characters I mentioned and Zoro, being that they have devil fruits. Fine, why do Sanji's opponents have to overcome his exoskeleton but Zoro's opponents shouldn't have to overcome any of his abilities?
Overcome what. Luffy's powers dont weaken them. Your effectively want to give Zoro a power that weakens his opponent. How tf is that an interesting fight for Zoro. How would that ever make him grow and overcome.

Exoskeleton is added defense. Again not nerfing his opponents.
 
#50
My point is that bad guys overcome good guys' powers all the time. It's definitely valid if you don't think the power makes sense for Zoro's character/personality but acting like he'd be the only strawhat with powers to overcome is just false
bad guys don't get nerfed because they touch the good guy sword that would be ridiculous, and also none of the strawhats nerf their opponents so it would be weird if only zoro does that
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#51
Overcome what. Luffy's powers dont weaken them. Your effectively want to give Zoro a power that weakens his opponent. How tf is that an interesting fight for Zoro. How would that ever make him grow and overcome.

Exoskeleton is added defense. Again not nerfing his opponents.
Nami nerfed Cracker

Brulee saved luffy kata stabbed himself

Whore distracted queen who attacked himself as well

Gamma knife nerfed doffy

Kaidos done a gauntlet
 
#52
Overcome what. Luffy's powers dont weaken them. Your effectively want to give Zoro a power that weakens his opponent. How tf is that an interesting fight for Zoro. How would that ever make him grow and overcome.

Exoskeleton is added defense. Again not nerfing his opponents.
Literally anything that hinders your opponents or makes it harder for them to win is something to overcome. It's not a guaranteed thing that Zoro would be able to weaken his opponent. Like any other ability, certain conditions have to be met. You're assuming in this scenario Zoro can steal opponent's haki at will, I only mean he could if they're weak enough to allow it.

bad guys don't get nerfed because they touch the good guy sword that would be ridiculous, and also none of the strawhats nerf their opponents so it would be weird if only zoro does that
Brook can make his enemies fall asleep, so that isn't true I'm afraid. Can't Luffy also change his opponent's body with his power too? We're moving into the endgame of the story, powers as we've seen are getting more and more ridiculous, have a more open mind. You're acting like it's such an op ability when we saw a power like this in alabasta
 
#53
Literally anything that hinders your opponents or makes it harder for them to win is something to overcome. It's not a guaranteed thing that Zoro would be able to weaken his opponent. Like any other ability, certain conditions have to be met. You're assuming in this scenario Zoro can steal opponent's haki at will, I only mean he could if they're weak enough to allow it.


Brook can make his enemies fall asleep, so that isn't true I'm afraid. Can't Luffy also change his opponent's body with his power too? We're moving into the endgame of the story, powers as we've seen are getting more and more ridiculous, have a more open mind. You're acting like it's such an op ability when we saw a power like this in alabasta
brook power does not weaken his enemy it only works against fooders but if zoro can suck peoples haki it would weaken his opponents who are meant to be stronger than him
 
#54
brook power does not weaken his enemy it only works against fooders but if zoro can suck peoples haki it would weaken his opponents who are meant to be stronger than him
Ah, then surely it depends on how Oda handles the ability, no? Besides, like I said, if his enemy can't handle not making contact with one of his blades then they aren't strong enough to beat Zoro. And why? It's because this would make Zoro more powerful. Simple. Just like Luffy wasn't strong enough to beat crocodile until he found a way around it. Or how Zoro wasn't strong enough to beat King until he learned his speed/defence forms.

There's no 'meant to be stronger than him', there's just those weaker than Zoro, and those stronger than Zoro. You mean that with this powerup Zoro would become stronger than some opponents who were previously stronger than him. That's how power-ups work. This is a black blade we're talking about here, it will have been earned.
 
#55
Zoro doesn't need a sword that can absorb his opponent's haki. Swordsmanship is already one of the strongest fighting styles in the manga and has the potential to be the strongest.

Giving a sword that power is turning a sword into a DF. We already know you can add DF powers to a sword so that is not necessary.

What's a stronger defense than a sword that can't be broken? A swordsman with a black blade has the potential to have an unbreakable defense.

I've talked about the potential a swordsman has from creating and possessing a black blade in another post.

Here it is:
It's not just about possessing a black blade. The greatest benefit will come from creating (forging) one.

First, there are known benefits to having a black blade regardless how it is obtained.
- greater defensive power. Black blades are unbreakable so possessing one means the user will never have to worry about their sword breaking so their defensive power will increase.
- greater offensive power. Black blades increases AP because of the stronger blade. When Zoro first used shisui his attacks from shisui were stronger than his other swords attacks.
- better haki preservation. Possessing a black blade is like always coating your sword with a strong blackened CoA haki without needing to actually do that. When haki is needed to create stronger offensive or defensive techniques the user won't need to use as much. Of course, black blades don't actually contain haki so haki will still be needed to counter DF power.

Possible benefits to possessing a black blade.
- I believe black blades are heavy. Creating a black blade increases the weapons weight. Zoro stated Shisui was heavy compared to his other two swords. A heavy blade means the attack will have more weight. That increase in weight will increase the attack power. The user will grow physically stronger from needing to train to control the heavier sword.
- I believe black blades don't possess cursed/dangerous power. Creating a black blade will remove the curse/dangerous power the sword posseses. I don't have anything to support that but I do find it interesting the only difficulty Zoro had using shisui had to do with possessing a black blade, nothing about shisui.

Let's look at the possible benefits one can obtain from creating (forging) a black blade.

At this time nobody knows how black blades are created but the manga has given us some insight so we have some information to work with.

- largest/strongest CoA haki amount and the best CoA haki control in the manga or near it. There is enough information to confirm blackened haki is needed to create a black blade. But just possessing that isn't enough to create one. Since Zoro has mastered enma he has started to create a green aura around his swords when he's using KoH techniques. We have never seen that before from any character. I believe that is Zoro adding an incredible large amount of controlled blackened haki to his swords and that is the first step to creating a black blade.

- incredible powerful CoC haki and control. We know just to fully master a sword the user must bend the sword to their will. If you create a black blade you aren't just bending it to your will you are changing the sword. That can only be possible if you can completely dominate the sword.

- I'm sure I'm missing one or two more things needed to create black blade.

Of course, a black blade creator will receive a huge increase in CoC strength. Having the skills/power to create a black blade and creating one will make the user stronger. As they grow stronger so will their CoC strength. Similar to what happened to Luffy when he obtained awakening.
Combine with the Pinnacle of swordsmanship, the ability to cut anything, and they are a walking irresistible force paradox. A sword that can cut anything vs a shield that can't be broken. With that power who can stop them.

I still don't think people truly understand the potential swordsman have One Piece.
 
#57
Nami nerfed Cracker

Brulee saved luffy kata stabbed himself

Whore distracted queen who attacked himself as well

Gamma knife nerfed doffy

Kaidos done a gauntlet
Ok and ?

Luffy's powers still dont nerf his opponents. That plot did.

Secondly just cause its happened doesnt mean its good writing. Youve effectively brought out the worse moments in OP combat. Youve literally proved the point that Zoro having this ability would just be as bad as those scenarios. Clown ass.
 
#58
Zoro doesn't need a sword that can absorb his opponent's haki. Swordsmanship is already one of the strongest fighting styles in the manga and has the potential to be the strongest.

Giving a sword that power is turning a sword into a DF. We already know you can add DF powers to a sword so that is not necessary.

What's a stronger defense than a sword that can't be broken? A swordsman with a black blade has the potential to have an unbreakable defense.

I've talked about the potential a swordsman has from creating and possessing a black blade in another post.

Here it is:


Combine with the Pinnacle of swordsmanship, the ability to cut anything, and they are a walking irresistible force paradox. A sword that can cut anything vs a shield that can't be broken. With that power who can stop them.

I still don't think people truly understand the potential swordsman have One Piece.
Zoro already has a sword that absorbs haki. If you don't want at least one of Zoro's swords to behave as though it's alive that ship's sailed I'm afraid. There's an opportunity for real depth and lore to be added to one of the most popular fighting styles in the story and you'd rather black blades to just be a stronger material? There's no way this unique disposition in blades stuff is ending here, and if that means a few characters in the entire story get further abilities is that such a bad thing?

That being said you are right, swordsmen have the privilege that few other types of fighters have as they can typically one-shot their opponent. But that doesn't change the fact that Zoro isn't at all versatile outside of that, black blades being unbreakable isn't helpful as armament at Zoro's level achieves that already.

For what you say about Zoro/swordsmen to be true their opponent has to have only defence, he could barely handle fighting onimaru and killer at once so what good is the ability to cut anything. You say a black blade is the best defence, yet Zoro isn't able to block every attack with his swords so who cares, is my line of thinking.

What powerups do you see Zoro having in his future, aside from the obvious haki improvements. How do you imagine his and Mihawk's last fight looking like? Oda rarely has Zoro's matchup end up as just a slashing contest, all of his big fights have another dimension to them.
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#59
Ok and ?

Luffy's powers still dont nerf his opponents. That plot did.

Secondly just cause its happened doesnt mean its good writing. Youve effectively brought out the worse moments in OP combat. Youve literally proved the point that Zoro having this ability would just be as bad as those scenarios. Clown ass.
No I didn't window licker. I just as usual proved you wrong. I said nothing about zoro.
 
#60
Literally anything that hinders your opponents or makes it harder for them to win is something to overcome. It's not a guaranteed thing that Zoro would be able to weaken his opponent. Like any other ability, certain conditions have to be met. You're assuming in this scenario Zoro can steal opponent's haki at will, I only mean he could if they're weak enough to allow it.
At the end of the day the best fights come when the opponent isnt nerfed and are at full power. This allows the protagonist to have a real challenge. This ability ruins that.

If this ability only works on weaklings its literally as useless as Base CoC used to be. Just a fodder clearing power. Who tf cares.
 
Top